Live data from Hacker News

VPN – Very Precarious Narrative

schub.io

121–130 of 281 posts

Re: VPN – Very Precarious Narrative

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He made this point explicit: > Networks like these make it easy for attackers to get a copy of your network data, and if you send something unencrypted, the results can be quite harmful. The web should be ideally end-to-end encrypted with HTTPS. But in case this assumption breaks down, VPN gives an additional headroom for security. Not much (as explained in the article, and thus should not be advertised so), but stil…

The VPN only protects the first hop, it would not be a good backup for https.

It protects the first hop for request data. But response data could be interfered with too.

Re: VPN – Very Precarious Narrative

#123
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, if you are doing illegal stuff very little of what you can find online will protect you. But if you are hiding from non-law enforcement it is easy to get pretty anonymous.

I guess since I have nothing to hide I have nothing to fear! Thanks friend! We are definitely not living in a surveillance state and we have nothing to worry about as long as we do our jobs cheerfully, obey authority, and conform. I love my life, my job, and my government. There is nothing to see here, everything is normative and fine. Those engaging in crimes though, such as watching region locked content outside th…

Same here, friend :)

Re: VPN – Very Precarious Narrative

#124
post #50

What VPN provider would you guys recommend?

TOR browser, or TAILS in a vm are both far superior to a VPN if you actually care about privacy. It is less convenient than using a VPN though - so lots of people sacrifice privacy and money for convenience and the feeling of privacy.

Re: VPN – Very Precarious Narrative

#125

> If you are using your device on a public network, VPNs can help you protect your data. I have a ProtonVPN subscription myself, just for those instances where I am sitting in an airport waiting for my plane Seems like a contradictory message. He just got through telling us how most of the web is now end-to-end encrypted with HTTPS. So why does he need a VPN at the airport? Is he checking his email? I can't imagine t…

>most of the web is now end-to-end encrypted with HTTPS. So why does he need a VPN at the airport?

What percentage of (typically rushed) people at an airport will notice that a website is loading over http instead of https? SSLsplit is pretty useful.

Re: VPN – Very Precarious Narrative

#126
post #118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you setup your own VPN on some leased VPS, then you're the only user. So there's zero help re anonymity. And re privacy and security, you need to trust the VPS provider. No free lunch :(

But a VPS on DO, AWS or gcloud also has numerous services on the same physical machine. It's not like every request coming from that machine is from you or am I missing your point?

Sure. But each VPS has its own IP address. The VPS provider probably retains logs. And its ISP probably also retains logs. And everything involving that IP address is associated with you.

Re: VPN – Very Precarious Narrative

#127
post #125

> If you are using your device on a public network, VPNs can help you protect your data. I have a ProtonVPN subscription myself, just for those instances where I am sitting in an airport waiting for my plane Seems like a contradictory message. He just got through telling us how most of the web is now end-to-end encrypted with HTTPS. So why does he need a VPN at the airport? Is he checking his email? I can't imagine t…

>most of the web is now end-to-end encrypted with HTTPS. So why does he need a VPN at the airport? What percentage of (typically rushed) people at an airport will notice that a website is loading over http instead of https? SSLsplit is pretty useful.

Does your bank, or whatever, not use hsts?

Re: VPN – Very Precarious Narrative

#129
post #120

The real problem with VPNs is that they are sold as a full privacy and security solution to people who don't understand what's going on technically. There are some legitimate reasons to use a VPN. Those are far fewer than the marketing claims of those companies. What I've seen over time: * hide your IP from the service you're using (related to geoblocking) * get around limitations of your ISP (blocked ports or thrott…

A large number of free VPN users seem to be students, using them to get around their schools blocking access to Facebook etc.

Re: VPN – Very Precarious Narrative

#130
post #50

What VPN provider would you guys recommend?

For several years, I've been recommending AirVPN, Insorg, IVPN, Mullvad and PIA. So at this point, I can say that they've all been around for several years, and I've heard nothing bad about them. Ones I have heard bad things about are EarthVPN, HideMyAss, Proxy.sh and PureVPN. And although I've heard nothing bad about ExpressVPN or NordVPN, the fact that they've bribed so many review sites to recommend them annoys me…

wow man thanks. I'm reading your Privacy Guides and they're quite quality materials!
Post reply on HN