Live data from Hacker News

Jobs at Google (1999)

web.archive.org

121–130 of 133 posts

Re: Jobs at Google (1999)

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Everyone I've talked to in the industry views people with a Masters much less favorably than people with a Bachelors or PhD. And from experience I can say there is a shockingly high number of people with Masters in Comp Sci churning through the hiring pool who can't write a single line of code or even valid HTML. I don't know why this is, but I think a Masters is getting a negative reputation to the point that you mi…

That's really shocking for me to know that a Master's degree is frowned upon these days. However, since its one of my life's dream to get a MS in CS from US, I will do it.

Getting an MS is a sign that the candidate wasn't particularly good before getting one, because of the various reasons people get an MS. And it's not like they became a better developer as a result of getting one.

Re: Jobs at Google (1999)

#122
post #2

Back when Google was really cool! Who got hired into some of these positions?

I almost did. My professor would become Google's director of research and when she did she encouraged me to send a CV as I was about to finish my degree in C.S. I sent it but didn't get hired. Maybe I was just not Google material (i.e.: not good enough) but the official answer I got was that they were focussing on hiring U.S. residents at that point which I wasn't.

Re: Jobs at Google (1999)

#123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I suggest they were incorrect in their claim not to be influenced by those things - that's why they have a diversity problem now. Edited to add: In 1998 I probably would have read this and cheered it as a place where diversity was recognised and welcomed; in 2018 I read it as "we don't feel we have to do anything about our unconscious biases, which we're satisfied with"

(warning typing on bumppy airplane ride on tiny phone, where is my emacs again ?) Given how successful how successful they are and how right they were on so many other things it is hard to tell if they were incorrect or not. But while we are at it let's talk about unconscious bias. This is brought up a lot. If it does exist and is affecting people's decisions why do we always talk about it in thr manner you just have…

Yes, it's racist to make this about how white people are always blamed. It's not about that.

Re: Jobs at Google (1999)

#124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's really shocking for me to know that a Master's degree is frowned upon these days. However, since its one of my life's dream to get a MS in CS from US, I will do it.

Getting an MS is a sign that the candidate wasn't particularly good before getting one, because of the various reasons people get an MS. And it's not like they became a better developer as a result of getting one.

This is crazy!

Is this notion prevalent everywhere in US?

Shouldn't it be otherwise, like the student is hardworking and is persistent enough to get a Masters?

Re: Jobs at Google (1999)

#125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Getting an MS is a sign that the candidate wasn't particularly good before getting one, because of the various reasons people get an MS. And it's not like they became a better developer as a result of getting one.

This is crazy! Is this notion prevalent everywhere in US? Shouldn't it be otherwise, like the student is hardworking and is persistent enough to get a Masters?

The way to determine this is by measuring actual performance.

With more information, like why or how they got an MS, the probability distribution changes. My impression is, there's a set of dimwits from a dimwit part of the industry that decide they should get a Master's in order to better their career. As opposed to, say, getting one right after school because you didn't want to enter the real world, or because a 5-year MS seemed like a good idea, or being brainwashed in general about the value of formal schooling.

Re: Jobs at Google (1999)

#127
post #122
post #2

Back when Google was really cool! Who got hired into some of these positions?

I almost did. My professor would become Google's director of research and when she did she encouraged me to send a CV as I was about to finish my degree in C.S. I sent it but didn't get hired. Maybe I was just not Google material (i.e.: not good enough) but the official answer I got was that they were focussing on hiring U.S. residents at that point which I wasn't.

It was also harder to hire outside of the US back then, so the latter may be more likely.

Re: Jobs at Google (1999)

#128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is crazy! Is this notion prevalent everywhere in US? Shouldn't it be otherwise, like the student is hardworking and is persistent enough to get a Masters?

The way to determine this is by measuring actual performance. With more information, like why or how they got an MS, the probability distribution changes. My impression is, there's a set of dimwits from a dimwit part of the industry that decide they should get a Master's in order to better their career. As opposed to, say, getting one right after school because you didn't want to enter the real world, or because a 5-…

You sound right in so many ways.

>> Getting right after school.

Isn’t getting some real work exp before joining Masters a good thing?

>> 5 year MS

Never heard of such a thing. Is there one?

Re: Jobs at Google (1999)

#129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The way to determine this is by measuring actual performance. With more information, like why or how they got an MS, the probability distribution changes. My impression is, there's a set of dimwits from a dimwit part of the industry that decide they should get a Master's in order to better their career. As opposed to, say, getting one right after school because you didn't want to enter the real world, or because a 5-…

You sound right in so many ways. >> Getting right after school. Isn’t getting some real work exp before joining Masters a good thing? >> 5 year MS Never heard of such a thing. Is there one?

A 5 year MS is where you get both a BS and MS in 5 years. So basically you graduate a year late.

Re: Jobs at Google (1999)

#130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You sound right in so many ways. >> Getting right after school. Isn’t getting some real work exp before joining Masters a good thing? >> 5 year MS Never heard of such a thing. Is there one?

A 5 year MS is where you get both a BS and MS in 5 years. So basically you graduate a year late.

Thanks.

Isn’t getting some real work exp before joining Masters a good thing?

Would like to hear your opinion on this, please.

Post reply on HN