Live data from Hacker News

Reverse Engineering WhatsApp Web

github.com

121–127 of 127 posts

Re: Reverse Engineering WhatsApp Web

#121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like you could get a stable VoIP number and just use that. One time cost and has its uses for cheap long distance calling.

Most people expect you to have 1 mobile phone number, not separate ones for calling and messaging.

I don't see the problem. Once you've registered with your messaging service, like WhatsApp, you're sending messages to people not numbers.

Re: Reverse Engineering WhatsApp Web

#122
post #8

Wow that's impressive. But I would imagine WhatsApp/Facebook can just change their protocol at any time since it is easy to redeploy a new version of the WhatsApp Web client, thus breaking any 3p clients built on the original protocol. That would require yet another reverse engineering effort that can take a while. And by the time its reverse engineered again, they can yet again change the protocol. So the only relia…

I've wanted to create my own WhatsApp client that's and actual native desktop application. If this reverse-engineering process continues, it might now be possible. It's irritating when people say "Signal/WhatsApp has a desktop app!" because technically, they're right, but I have enough web browsers on my system already, thank you very much

> my own WhatsApp client that's and actual native desktop application.

What would it do differently?

Re: Reverse Engineering WhatsApp Web

#123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most people expect you to have 1 mobile phone number, not separate ones for calling and messaging.

I don't see the problem. Once you've registered with your messaging service, like WhatsApp, you're sending messages to people not numbers.

Then if someone wants to call you, they won't be sure which number to use.

Re: Reverse Engineering WhatsApp Web

#124

I see a lot of "just use X instead." Unfortunately, unlike the old chat protocols, switching to any other platform means convincing your contacts to use a new platform. They like you and all, but that means they also have to use a special app just to talk with you now.

It astounds me that something as simple as talking to people is in some ways objectively more difficult now than it was in 1990.

What the hell are we doing?

Re: Reverse Engineering WhatsApp Web

#127
post #19
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wish signal had a webapp.

Not very likely any time soon. There was a long debate about it and they decided that putting your trust entirely in the CA system and Signal's servers every time to not serve a malicious client that couldn't be validated by the user wasn't acceptable.

Why can't I self host a web app.

I just don't want any more applications open.

I'm CA's will be bypassed soon. There's a lot of brain attention on this.

Post reply on HN