Live data from Hacker News

Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

techcrunch.com

111–120 of 146 posts

Re: Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

#111

Love the idea of this. Pre-ordered.

I pre-ordered, but there was absolutely no info about whether or not it ships internationally (even after paying). Hopefully they'll be shipping outside the US!

On the home page: "For a limited time: free worldwide shipping with pre-order!"

Re: Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

#113
What kind of battery does it use and how do you charge it? How long before it needs to be charged. Your website is quite informative about the science but seems to leave out this basic operation information. Looks cool anyway, with free shipping to Belgium I'll definitly order one.

Re: Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

#114
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I learned about polyphasic sleep a couple years back, and came across stevepavlina's blog posts about his experience. I want to try it (just for the heck of it, and to see if it fits my lifestyle better) sometime in my life. If you happen to get Wakemate, I'd be interested to know if it helps or eases the transition to polyphasic.

I can't say there is any definite correlation, but Steve now believes in subjective reality and that his love is too big to be contained within a relationship, so think before you leap

I think that too and I get a full 8-9 hours of sleep per night, but I can see your point ;)

Re: Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

#115

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Polyphasic sleep for knowledge workers has been thoroughly debunked by real science. http://www.supermemo.com/articles/polyphasic.htm The science has been done. The tests are clear. Polyphasic sleepers suffer performance losses in mental tasks compared to normal sleepers. In particular, it significantly impairs long-term memory coding. Charlatans like Steve Pavlina always refused to do even basic scientific testing.…

The science has been done. I'm afraid I don't see any citations in that article for studies done specifically on polyphasic sleep. I see citations for the natural length of the human day (24.2 hours), sleep deprivation effects, maximum waking time for humans, etc. But nothing but unbacked, though strongly held, assertions about polyphasic sleep. I may have missed it, but every time the article goes into discussion of…

Claudio Stampi tested all the various forms of reducing sleep and found polyphasic - the uberman style - to be the best out of them all.

At the same time, he found that polyphasic sleep results in poorer performance compared to normal sleepers. And this was considered non-noteworthy, since obviously 2 hours of sleep is worse than 8. You can find his articles on Google Scholar.

Steve Pavlina is the only person I know of who has claimed to be polyphasic for an extended period of time and claimed that there is no performance decrease. Unfortunately, Steve refused to do any scientific testing and relied entirely on his own subjective judgment. He gave it up after 6 months anyway, but still maintains it is effective.

Steve's Pavlina's experience however exactly fits in with the best scientific understanding of sleep (which Wozniak perfectly elucidates). Steve Pavlina was never able to maintain the schedule without an alarm clock, which indicates that his body did not adapt and was not co-operating or behaving in a "natural" way.

The theory that Steve was only getting REM is shot down by his own journals which indicate that he was getting both Delta and REM. My own experience with polyphasic also indicates that while the proportion of REM may increase, you still get delta sleep. I was fully (and rigidly) polyphasic for some weeks but never stopped having delta sleep. I also consistently showed decreased performance that could only be overcome by surges of adrenaline and autonomic excitation in general - which is easily caused when a loud alarm clock wakes you up when your body desperately desires sleep. You are tricking your body into a state of permanent fight or flight.

Anyway the studies were done in the 80s that directly measured performance. But in the modern day extensive studies have been done on sleep and everything we know about sleep now shoots down all the theorizing that the polyphasics use to justify their crazy. The idea that delta wave sleep is useless has been utterly rejected because it has been shown that delta wave sleep contributes to long-term memory encoding. If you cut down on delta wave, you cut down on long-term memory. If you cut down on sleep in general, you cut down on cognitive abilities in general.

This trade off may be worth it for some people, but they should be aware that it is a trade off. Magical thinking like that displayed by Steve Pavlina does not magically make you immune from the negative side effects of sleep deprivation. You get over the drowsiness with sheer strength of will and adrenaline, but the fogginess doesn't go away. (Steve considered the fogginess to be a benefit. But remember this is a guy who believes ghosts tell him how to win at blackjack.)

Re: Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

#116

It would be really cool to see what they could do for those who would like to wake up with their partner. If both could wake up without being groggy, that would be amazing. I'd imagine you might need a bigger window of possible wake up time.

It also depends on how many 'good times' for waking up you have in 20 minutes, and how much they last. For example if you have 2 minutes optimal waking time two times, you might have a 1% chance that a given moment is optimal for both of you.

Re: Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

#117

Love the idea of this. Pre-ordered.

I pre-ordered, but there was absolutely no info about whether or not it ships internationally (even after paying). Hopefully they'll be shipping outside the US!

I pre-ordered one and i'm in Australia. I figured $5 was worth the risk to see if they will ship it to me.

edit: and had i opened my eyes i would have seen the free shipping worldwide!

Re: Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

#118
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I pre-ordered, but there was absolutely no info about whether or not it ships internationally (even after paying). Hopefully they'll be shipping outside the US!

On the home page: "For a limited time: free worldwide shipping with pre-order!"

Yeah, they added that recently. I guess they got that question often.

Re: Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

#119
post #105

I really like the idea, but putting "(works on all phones)" on your front page is kind of shady if the actual requirements are bluetooth and internet access and third-party app support. No phone I've ever owned has all those features.

Those features have been practically ubiquitous on GSM phones for about five years (except for the cheapest 3rd world models). That's as close to "all phones" as you can get.

Then put a star next to "all phones" and add some fine print that bluetooth is a requirement, and app requirements. I'm guessing it's been written for java/symbian/iphone/blackberry? Also a good idea to write the phones tested on.

Not every phone has bluetooth and can run third-party apps, especially if you bought a cheap non-branded phone. Also, not every would know it's necessary for a device like this.

Even better, why not allow us to download the app now?

Re: Wakemate (YC S09) helps you kiss groggy mornings goodbye

#120
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ubiquitous seems a bit of a stretch... :)

Well seeing how it was mentioned all over the media like Dr. Phil, 37 Signals, and Wired, Associated Press, G4TV, etc... I would say it is far more ubiquitous than the zeo. http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=sleeptracker

[deleted]
Post reply on HN