Live data from Hacker News

JMAP – a better way to email

blog.fastmail.com

111–116 of 116 posts

Re: JMAP – a better way to email

#111
post #48
post #28

Great job guys! Things like this together with CalDAV and CardDAV are reasons why I pay you guys for service. I just tried the following experiments with my Gmail and FastMail account. There's a reason why FastMail just feels faster! Try this: 1) While having the Gmail iOS app open, mark an email as read on the web 2) See how long it takes for Gmail to reflect the change 3) Now try with FastMail iOS app, see that it'…

Thank you for this comment. I do wonder why they simply didn't say this at the beginning of the article. I understood what they were up to purely because I'm a technical guy, but still I didn't want to actually have to watch the video -- namely because I'm deaf, and far too often there's no captions to explain what's going on so I prefer to read (and so do people at work, school, no sound etc), and it takes a lot les…

Their email sync is definitely superior to Google Apps, and now that they're adding DAV support the only thing really holding me back from switching my personal domain email over to Fastmail is email tagging. Gmail is, as far as I can tell, the only show in town for having email tags that sync across the server and client (unless you're in Exchange, but that's suboptimal for my personal use), and that's how I do pseudo-GTD to keep track of actions in my email.

Edit: I have a secondary email account through Fastmail where I don't need the tagging ability, and have been very pleased with the service. If you don't need tagging, I think it's worth the switch. They're clearly active in improving the service, while Gmail feels like it's moribund.

Re: JMAP – a better way to email

#112
post #48
post #28

Great job guys! Things like this together with CalDAV and CardDAV are reasons why I pay you guys for service. I just tried the following experiments with my Gmail and FastMail account. There's a reason why FastMail just feels faster! Try this: 1) While having the Gmail iOS app open, mark an email as read on the web 2) See how long it takes for Gmail to reflect the change 3) Now try with FastMail iOS app, see that it'…

Thank you for this comment. I do wonder why they simply didn't say this at the beginning of the article. I understood what they were up to purely because I'm a technical guy, but still I didn't want to actually have to watch the video -- namely because I'm deaf, and far too often there's no captions to explain what's going on so I prefer to read (and so do people at work, school, no sound etc), and it takes a lot les…

It would be cool to have a browser plugin that decorated youtube links with captions.

Re: JMAP – a better way to email

#113
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thank you for this comment. I do wonder why they simply didn't say this at the beginning of the article. I understood what they were up to purely because I'm a technical guy, but still I didn't want to actually have to watch the video -- namely because I'm deaf, and far too often there's no captions to explain what's going on so I prefer to read (and so do people at work, school, no sound etc), and it takes a lot les…

Their email sync is definitely superior to Google Apps, and now that they're adding DAV support the only thing really holding me back from switching my personal domain email over to Fastmail is email tagging. Gmail is, as far as I can tell, the only show in town for having email tags that sync across the server and client (unless you're in Exchange, but that's suboptimal for my personal use), and that's how I do pseu…

True 2FA is holding me back. Alternative logins are great but I'd prefer to force 2FA on the account.

Re: JMAP – a better way to email

#114
post #113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Their email sync is definitely superior to Google Apps, and now that they're adding DAV support the only thing really holding me back from switching my personal domain email over to Fastmail is email tagging. Gmail is, as far as I can tell, the only show in town for having email tags that sync across the server and client (unless you're in Exchange, but that's suboptimal for my personal use), and that's how I do pseu…

True 2FA is holding me back. Alternative logins are great but I'd prefer to force 2FA on the account.

They've got "enhanced multi-factor authentication" on their roadmap for 2015. Not sure if that's "true" 2FA, but it's on the way, FYI.

Re: JMAP – a better way to email

#115

I' m interested in this from a security perspective. What does this new protocol offer in terms of better control around what makes it to the inbox? Would IMAP>JMAP translation before hitting the user give us better ability to filter out malicious items/spam?

I think the only thing this particular protocol should be concerned with is reliably providing a method for communicating between client and server. Most spam and malicious mail filtering should happen as early in the process as possible, hopefully during the initial connection. There is a a protocol named Sieve ( http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc5228.txt ) which provides for delivery stage filtering rules. It is similar i…

Sieve is the native filtering engine used by FastMail, so I'd say it integrates quite well with JMAP, from my experience. :)

Re: JMAP – a better way to email

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don't need to trust the keyservers since you verify the fingerprints of downloaded keys against the fingerprints given to you in person. The keyserver protocol includes commands to include keys in the keyserver network. How you send keys depends on the UI of the tool you use, geeks will do this: gpg --keyserver --send-keys

Right. I'm a little rusty on the details. My point stands - key distribution is not a solved problem for the average user.

It is solved for some specific platforms, GNOME for example:

https://mail.gnome.org/archives/gnome-announce-list/2014-Nov...

The average user doesn't use GNOME or Linux though :(

Post reply on HN