Live data from Hacker News

Meet the Apple Watch

techcrunch.com

111–120 of 174 posts

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#111

Don't see how this fits with Apple's core competency—creating a hardware device in a category where competitive devices have poor usability and limited function. This is Apple's first "me too" mobile product, as far as I can see.

The iPod was a "me too" product.

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#112
post #76

The marketing hype is ridiculous and the fanboys are going to be unbearable: Ion strengthened glass. 18K Gold developed to be twice as hard as standard gold.

"18K Gold developed to be twice as hard as standard gold." Did they really say that? Ha! Who knew my 9K gold stuff was vastly superior to higher grades.

18K just means "75% pure gold", it doesn't say what the other 25% is and there are a lot of different alloys. Most commonly it's mostly copper, which ironically is what gives it the standard "gold" tint (white gold uses metals like silver instead). I assume they mean "we picked an alloy that's harder than most".

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#113

This watch looks like it was designed by a committee: Two ways to navigate the interface (wheel for zooming, to avoid touching the screen, and panning by...touching the screen). Tasteless misfeatures like customisable emoji [1] and drawing your own fail whale on a tiny screen [2], and most inexplicable of all for an expensive watch - very little attention paid to the actual watch face designs, which are not even adap…

[deleted]

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#114
Anyone else have or remember the universal HomeLink transmitters that came in cars? Your car had a button that could "learn" the sequence from most garage door openers, apartment gate clickers, and the like.

I would love for this watch to be able to be able to clone all the various NFC-type items and building access cards people carry around. I suspect there are considerable technical and legal obstacles to this, but hey, there's an API!

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#115
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most activity in a gym benefits from a watch. I weight train and I already know the app I want for this. ps -- I don't bring my phone because (1) the gym is gross, (2) I sweat like a pig, (3) I don't want to kill it; I bruise myself enough that between bars, plates, dumbbells, kettlebells, etc, there is 0% chance I wouldn't smash it. My wrist just doesn't get smacked as much as my pocket / upper thighs.

What's the advantage of this over an arm sleeve that your phone sits in for your specific use case though? Also, will you still have to have your iPhone on you or in your bag to use it at the gym? What tech is being used to communicate between the two devices and is it strong enough that you can wear the watch and have your iPhone at home? Sorry if they have answered these questions.

The benefit for something like a rest timer is you have to interact with it all the time so it's a giant pain to get your phone in and out of a sleeve repeatedly. Plus, again, I sweat like a pig when I lift heavy or run and the phones don't seem particularly waterproof. Plus my hands sweat too and I will drop it.

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's the advantage of this over an arm sleeve that your phone sits in for your specific use case though? Also, will you still have to have your iPhone on you or in your bag to use it at the gym? What tech is being used to communicate between the two devices and is it strong enough that you can wear the watch and have your iPhone at home? Sorry if they have answered these questions.

I've tried to use iPhone with arm sleeves in gym and when jogging. It's really inconvenient and I usually resort to using just earbud controls. We will see if Apple Watch is any better, but based on the announcement demos, it looks promising on that front.

Still doesn't solve the problem of needing the iPhone on you for the watch to connect, if that is indeed the case. Is there any info on the tech used to connect the devices besides a single mention of wifi on the site?

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#117

This watch looks like it was designed by a committee: Two ways to navigate the interface (wheel for zooming, to avoid touching the screen, and panning by...touching the screen). Tasteless misfeatures like customisable emoji [1] and drawing your own fail whale on a tiny screen [2], and most inexplicable of all for an expensive watch - very little attention paid to the actual watch face designs, which are not even adap…

I'm not sure how I feel about those Mario 64-esque emoji, but to the extent they become popular and don't work so well cross platform, it helps lock people in to the Apple ecosystem. I know many people who were hesitant to switch from Blackberry because they would lose BBM (I still miss those BBM emoji actually...), and many people who were hesitant to switch away from iPhone because Emoji didn't always work as seamlessly on Android. Perhaps a sad fact of today's world, but true.

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#118

I just don't think the watch market is really there. I feel like its shrinking steadily among younger people as the need for a time teller is replaced by the modern cell phone. I believe people have convinced themselves into convincing companies that they actually want a high tech wrist watch when, in reality, the market isn't that big and it is shrinking. I believe this whole craze started with the pebble. People se…

I can't live without my Pebble and I'm definitely not a jogger. Just a normal consumer. For me, it's revolutionary.

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#119
At the end of the announcement they mentioned using it for NFC payments. But anyone have an idea how that would work without the thumbprint scanner of the iPhone? It seemed like that was one of the key features of the Apple Pay announcement earlier in the keynote.

Re: Meet the Apple Watch

#120
post #38

I rather prefer the Garmin Fit. Battery life is almost a year. It does only 2 things: whether I am active enough and sleeping enough. Do we really need to have notifications on the watch. Not sure. May be i am too old.

You can now get the vivosmart instead of the vivofit if you want notifications. The tradeoff is your battery life drops to something like 7 days. That's still pretty good though.

(Full disclosure, I'm a current Garmin employee but I don't work in the fitness area)

Post reply on HN