Live data from Hacker News

The New Airbnb

airbnb.com

111–120 of 134 posts

Re: The New Airbnb

#111

I'm not sure I've ever met an opinion on a logo, name, or anything creative less than a month old that was worth a damn. When faced with something new, the tendency is to focus on the superficial, the easy joke, and it's too easy to let other opinions steer your own; they're momentarily on equal footing, you see. But the work will last longer than this moment. Your own opinion will evolve. The crowd will move on to t…

You are correct because first impressions don't matter.

Re: The New Airbnb

#112

I'm not sure I've ever met an opinion on a logo, name, or anything creative less than a month old that was worth a damn. When faced with something new, the tendency is to focus on the superficial, the easy joke, and it's too easy to let other opinions steer your own; they're momentarily on equal footing, you see. But the work will last longer than this moment. Your own opinion will evolve. The crowd will move on to t…

This is on-point for most logo designs, if not all. You can only really see the bad ones in retrospect (the London 2012 Olympics logo comes to mind [1]).

That said, I think the motion-picture used as the background to the call to action is going to be very short-lived on basic UI principles. It's distracting, low-contrast, and pulls people away from the text, button, etc. I'm sure A/B testing will resolve the issue pretty quickly, but it's very trendy right now - Paypal is doing it too. [2]

[1] http://www.adweek.com/adfreak/london-2012-olympic-logo-was-i... [2] https://www.paypal.com/

Re: The New Airbnb

#113
post #62

Logo similarity: https://www.automationanywhere.com/ They've had this re-design at least since March (based on their Facebook page).

Seeing the favicons while having both sites open in different tabs drives the point home even more. They're even using a very similar shade of orange. I do wonder if I was making a logo how hard it would be to search for similar ones though. It seems like it would be harder to google than a name.

you could try image search. Image search based on an existing image is fairly easy with google image search.

https://images.google.com/

Re: The New Airbnb

#114
post #62

Logo similarity: https://www.automationanywhere.com/ They've had this re-design at least since March (based on their Facebook page).

That is nearly identical. Would anyone with legal experience like to chime in about trademarks or something? I don't have much knowledge of it.

Not a lawyer, but I do have a long-standing interest in trademark law and know a good deal about it.

Courts look at the potential for confusion, which is often avoided if the two companies are in completely different markets, eg Apple Computer complaining about a store that specializes in apple pie and uses the word 'apple' in their business name. Trademark owners essentially have to make a showing of defending their mark or risk being accused of abandonment by someone else who wants to appropriate it, so typically they write a huffy letter, the small business with a vaguely-similar mark protests, and a court or national trademark arbitrator says 'there there, your businesses are totally different and it's OK to have slightly similar names because consumers will be able to tell them apart.'

However it's quite unusual to see two logos that are virtually identical as in this case, and arguably AirBNB is in the business of automating short term lets so there's a possibility of confusion with this firm that offers automation services. The automation firm might have a legitimate complaint for having been using their logo first, but it also depends on which company filed the mark with the USPTO first (which I haven't checked). I'd guess a likely outcome is that AirBnB pays the automation firm some cash to avoid a dispute.

Re: The New Airbnb

#115
post #34

For so long, people thought Airbnb was about renting houses. But really, we’re about home. You see, a house is just a space, but a home is where you belong. I hope they didn't pay very much for this, it's nauseating.

It has that "Like a chair" feel to it.

Re: The New Airbnb

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is nearly identical. Would anyone with legal experience like to chime in about trademarks or something? I don't have much knowledge of it.

Not a lawyer, but I do have a long-standing interest in trademark law and know a good deal about it. Courts look at the potential for confusion, which is often avoided if the two companies are in completely different markets, eg Apple Computer complaining about a store that specializes in apple pie and uses the word 'apple' in their business name. Trademark owners essentially have to make a showing of defending their…

Looks like Airbnb and Automation Anywhere are already working together on this.

http://venturebeat.com/2014/07/16/airbnbs-new-logo-looks-a-l...

Re: The New Airbnb

#117

Well, this should go down in the annals of logos which should have gotten some wider impressions before launching. Since nobody else on HN has mentioned it, all of twitter thinks the new logo looks like a vagina. It's hard to unsee.

Certainly that's only good for AirBNB. They'll get free press out of a otherwise non-newsworthy event.

Re: The New Airbnb

#118
I think this is a step in the right direction for Airbnb. It has more warmth and personality, feels more accessible and less like a website created in 2005 (the existing button styles always irked me). A minor nitpick I have with the design is that video background header, on my desktop Mac with a screen resolution of 2560 x 1440 viewing in Chrome at maximum width and height the scaling bugs up and the heads of everyone are being cut off. As I drag the sides of my browser in, the heads come into view and looks much better. It looks a little strange with the cut off heads, perhaps centring the video would be the most ideal fix. The video content seems a little strange as well (especially the one of the woman sleeping).

I am loving that explore view and the subsequent single listing pages with the sticky quick book form. Definitely leaps and bounds better over the existing site. I don't know how I feel about that logo though. I love the story behind its creation, I love the versatility of it as a brand mark, but it kind of looks like a vagina/rocket ship. Hate to be crude, but once you see it, there is no unseeing it. Based on Tweets I've seen about it, I am not alone in thinking that.

Another thing that surprised me is the fact the site is only responsive to an extent. If you shrink your browser down small to that of an iPad mini, it kind of breaks. Surprised the site doesn't work at all resolutions considering the great teams they'd have to make it happen.

Re: The New Airbnb

#119

Is the new symbol an attempt at some contrived post-millenial hobo code? "Look, honey! The Bélo! We've found a safe-house!"

I actually was thinking this, because of a Mad Men episode[1] and came here to mention it.

Overall I like the logo, but the idea of something akin to the Hobo Code in particular is pretty brilliant IMHO. It's a very Don Draper idea :)

1: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1097128/

Re: The New Airbnb

#120

I'm not sure I've ever met an opinion on a logo, name, or anything creative less than a month old that was worth a damn. When faced with something new, the tendency is to focus on the superficial, the easy joke, and it's too easy to let other opinions steer your own; they're momentarily on equal footing, you see. But the work will last longer than this moment. Your own opinion will evolve. The crowd will move on to t…

I clicked on this thread wondering: 1) why is this news?; and 2) why are there so many comments? I'm not sure I learned the answer to either one...
Post reply on HN