Live data from Hacker News

Dropbox for Business

dropboxatwork.com

111–120 of 129 posts

Re: Dropbox for Business

#111
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I believe Google pools the storage. Office 365 does the same thing. My org manages many thousands of people each with 10GB of OneDrive space. We allocate big users as much as 200GB of space without even looking at the allocation ,because most user needs are very light.

Google does not currently pool the storage, but will move to that model in coming quarters.

How do you know this. Have they announced pooled storage?

Re: Dropbox for Business

#112
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So, to all intents and purposes versions appear to act as backups, but you read a Web site a few years ago that said they aren't so that's what you tell people?

Not really. The concept of version works like backup for full fledge systems (SVN, git), but not what Dropbox exposes. Dropbox keeps version of _existing_ files. You won't get back the files deleted and synched by mistake/misbehavior of some script. A backup would keep the files. You'll also have different behaviors if you need to bring back a set of data (i.e. all your files as they were two days ago). You'll be in…

> Dropbox keeps version of _existing_ files. You won't get back the files deleted and synched by mistake/misbehavior of some script

Err, that is exactly what they provide. You do have to use the web interface to see them, and it is trivial to restore directories and files. (A bit painful if you want to only restore some of the files in a directory.)

Re: Dropbox for Business

#113
post #99
post #17

Unless they drop the price soon we're going to move away from them. It sounds silly to argue over $15/user/month, but in comparison to Google Drive it's just started feeling too expensive. I really like the product, but I don't know if any product in a commoditized space can sustain such a price premium.

We tried to move to Google Drive but are about to go all in for Dropbox for Business. The Google Drive desktop sync client (for Mac at least) is just not reliable enough. Make sure you trial Google Drive first.

The Google Drive sync client is lacking features for business. But third party Google Drive sync clients like Syncdocs http://syncdocs.com make it better than Dropbox.

Re: Dropbox for Business

#114

I lost trust in Dropbox when it comes to the quality of their client and I would therefore not use it for business purposes. * I've had two instances of near data loss where I could only recover data from the local hidden cache folder that gets deleted after a week. It had to do with a user error with moving out files from the Dropbox directory when the client was off - previous versions in the webapp can easily beco…

It's not just their Mac one. The one on Windows for me kills it, it just seems to make the machine really slow (only whilst it is syncing). Seems as if it is a bit of "the nature of the beast" as it's a similar story with other desktop clients. Great apps otherwise!

A lot depends on how many files you are syncing, and how often these files change and need re-syncing.

Re: Dropbox for Business

#115
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree that the killer feature with Dropbox is that it "just works". I jumped on the 50GB Mac mobile app special from Box.net a few months ago and upon trying to use their Box Sync desktop client I found that it just doesn't work. Bogged the machine down, was never able to properly sync files. I've got 50GB at Box.net that I don't know what to do with and I definitely wasn't moved to the category of a prospective co…

It really frustrates me that there are separate clients that do the same thing, but talk to a different domain. If these companies cared about their customers they would be putting together an open source spec for cloud syncing so that we could just pick our favorite clients and tie them to the individual accounts.

That would be in conflict with a freemium model. People would make a client that ties together dozens of free accounts.

Re: Dropbox for Business

#116

Hmmm, I already had two dropboxes running on my computer (one personal and one business) using Dropbox Encore and I have my work Dropbox (much bigger than personal Dropbox) to sync to another folder on my regular hard drive -- personal syncs to my smaller SSD. Linking my accounts (which obviates the need for Dropbox Encore) seems to want to create a new Dropbox folder to download all my work things and not give me a…

Seems like symlinks could solve your problem in the mean time.

Re: Dropbox for Business

#117
post #36

give users one Dropbox for personal stuff and another for work stuff. Users can easily access both Dropboxes from any of their devices. Sounds awesome! Minimum 5 users Well, phooey. This seems...arbitrary. Do they enforce this limit just to reduce support queries from low-profit customers?

> Do they enforce this limit just to reduce support queries from low-profit customers? Almost certainly. To quote patio11: "Pathological customers: they get things for free and then ask for their money back." The more money a business has, the more professional it can afford to be (literally) in dealing with you. If you want 80% of the money with 20% of the effort, draw a line between the head of your profit distribu…

[deleted]

Re: Dropbox for Business

#118
I am a big fan of Dropbox. I have tried other cloud storage/sync providers at various points of time and had a sour experience - Box: couldn't figure out how to sync, SkyDrive/OneDrive: refused to sync, Google Drive: was so slow that I tried to speed it up by copying over existing data from another machine and it created two copies of everything! In over 3 years I haven't faced a single problem with Dropbox.

Selling to the enterprise is a very different thing though. Quality comes way down in their priority list. The bureaucratic strongholds in enterprises require compromised quality at every level in order to maintain their fiefdom. I know Dropbox needs to make more money, but maybe this is not the right direction in which to probe?

Re: Dropbox for Business

#119
Sync and share is commodity. The trick is to add value and create APIs that unlock the value of having all your data in the cloud. Right now, the whole space is just a big land grab with many entrants and many different strategies. My money is on Box. They have realized that the dollars are in enterprise and that enterprise customers have a few needs around security and control that frankly noone else can offer.

Re: Dropbox for Business

#120
It's all very nice, but there's a very large elephant conspicuously absent from the room: encryption.

Not present in any of the 114 comments here so far, either.

Might be a problem.

Post reply on HN