Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

news.ycombinator.com

111–120 of 141 posts

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#111
For the last time: NO.

Most of the articles on TC are boring, so I don't subscribe to their RSS feed. The few interesting ones do get posted to Hacker News.

So instead of banning this site or that site, just focus on making sure good articles get the to front page, and flag the TC articles that you feel aren't worthy.

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#113
post #94

Andr, what site do you think is a better source of news about startups?

It's not so much that there is or isn't a better source of news about startups. It's that the stories from TechCrunch that make it over here and get voted up have a high probability of being linkbait ("X Will Kill Y!") or about some Arrington-induced/centric drama. That they're allowed to persist here goes against the Broken Windows strategy of preventing social decay.

Is banning TC necessarily the best solution? Maybe not, but we don't have another solution available that's doing the job. There might also be some throwing the baby out with the bathwater here, which seriously depends on how much TC is a source of news (for HN, specifically) that can't be had anywhere else. I'm not inclined to say that they are a significant source of such news for HN.

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#114
post #110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're equating a physical reality with a virtual one. The whole of the Internet is about filtration. There's no "real" location that grows worse or that requires effort. Besides, a per-site filter won't stop offtopic posts from being flagged, or debates from starting. They'll only allow certain people to ignore certain posts, which those people want to do anyway. I for one wouldn't block TechCrunch, and I'm certain…

A place doesn't have to be physical to be a community.

But a community doesn't suffer when it lets its more extreme members ignore the things that would provoke them.

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#115
The prevalence of linkbait Coding Horror, TechCrunch, and Rails-Drama articles has resulted in a significant reduction in my daily reading of HN. I'm interested in reading and commenting on informed, insightful articles.

TechCrunch, Coding Horror, and Rails-Drama are not insightful, often factually incorrect, always incendiary -- linkbait flytraps for junior technologists.

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#116
post #48
post #31

I think we should ban polls about banning TechCrunch.

Lets go the whole hog and ban comments suggesting we ban polls about banning TechCrunch.

Let's get crazy and ban comments that suggests we ban comments suggesting we ban polls about banning TechCrunch. -> not funny anymore I guess :-)

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#117
post #93
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

samson, As we all know, if your startup plan relies on getting a review on TC, you're going to fail. Some people are living in a bubble, so they think a review on TC matters. My gripe with TC is that lately, most of their articles have been based on "anonymous sources" or gossip. Having said that, I don't really mind too much either way if they're banned or not. I'd much rather they started reporting unbiased facts a…

Real estate is important and for every link to techcrunch, and for that matter, cnn, nytimes, washingtonpost, and all the other mainstream sources there is less room for somethign outside the mainstream and finding that stuff outside the mainstream is why I have liked HN so much in the past. The lack of that kind of watered-down-for-the-masses content is why I found HN so appealing. I would much rather read hacked to…

Agreed, but I actually would rather have 2 links to TechCrunch than one to NYT. At least, TC is about technology and start-ups. Should we ban NYT?

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

threads like these are why polls like these are bad. I'm serious, this is a reddit thread.

Worse yet, it made me laugh.

I love pun threads, and iterative permutations, and trite references to internet memes. I just don't like them here.

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#119
post #104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Different sense of "source." We're the table of contents, not the articles. I meant source in the sense TC is.

Hacker News + Primary Sources > TechCrunch.

TC's stories often are the primary sources, especially for news about new startups.
Post reply on HN