Earlier quoted context omitted.
This is a good example of movies using inaccurate depictions that audiences will easily understand instead of accurate depictions that may confuse them. Just think of it as a translation.
Alas, and a missed opportunity for education…
Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
111–120 of 122 posts
Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
#112One of the things about fiction is that it gets almost everything wrong. It isn’t just guns. It’s professions like spies and snipers, cars, boats, planes, programming/hacking, radios, technology, etc. And those are just the areas that I personally know they get wrong, because I know more than the average person in those areas. Some people judge fiction way too harshly for inconsequential but inaccurate details which…
Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
#113Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
#114Earlier quoted context omitted.
I was just watching Tom Scott's latest video, he mentioned firing a trebuchet and the guide pointed this out that you don't "fire" a trebuchet since it doesn't involve gunpowder, you launch it. Tom's commentary later was that he disagreed with that sentiment. "I disagree with those potential comments. Words change their meaning overtime. In modern English, you can fire an arrow, you can fire a torpedo, we were gonna…
In the US Navy at least, you don't "fire" a torpedo, you "shoot" it. The lore is that "fire" has a very specific, very urgent meaning on a warship and you don't use that word unless there actually is a fire.
Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
#115Earlier quoted context omitted.
Didn’t he piece rumors and made intelligent guesses so well that the government freaked out wondering where the leak was?
Possible he had a real source?
Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
#116One of the things about fiction is that it gets almost everything wrong. It isn’t just guns. It’s professions like spies and snipers, cars, boats, planes, programming/hacking, radios, technology, etc. And those are just the areas that I personally know they get wrong, because I know more than the average person in those areas. Some people judge fiction way too harshly for inconsequential but inaccurate details which…
Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
#117I'm not a handgun expert at all but I've caught a few of these, like the guy who racked the slide on his revolver. The author who really impressed me, although not with his handgun knowledge, was Tom Clancy. I was in the anti-submarine warfare business in the 1970s and some of what he wrote in Red October I only knew from classified sources.
There, that should do it.
Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
#118Earlier quoted context omitted.
Possible he had a real source?
sometimes, you just have to hang out in the right bar, and you will hear a multitude of secrets, this is why some projects had thier own towns so none of the inside would get out.
Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
#119 * Finger on the trigger. Very dangerous. Pulp Fiction showed the consequences
* Using ball ammo
I actually dislike the pistols without manual safety. CCW people always say: but the Glock/P365/P320/VP9/... have an internal safety, a trigger safety and a drop safety.But these safeties are not additive. If your trigger safety fails, the gun will go off. Same with the drop safety.
At least with a manual safety those are additional. It's not that because your car has an airbag that you stop wearing your seatbelt right?
Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition
#120One thing I have noticed messed up in a lot of fiction (written/tv/movies/etc) is how loud guns actually are. Scenes of multiple people without any hearing protection emptying their guns that doesn't have any kind of supressors/silencer multiple times in a closed space (usually a single room) and then just casually chatting with each 5 seconds later. In general the sounds of guns are very bad in most movies/tv shows…