Live data from Hacker News

Blogging can just be stating the obvious

blog.jim-nielsen.com

111–120 of 138 posts

Re: Blogging can just be stating the obvious

#111

Most search results nowadays are SEO farms. Posts I read are also mostly just someone debugging a weird bug for endless hours only cause they were mad, just grep output and the fix. personal domain blogs survive faster than medium.

I'm looking forward to AI summaries killing SEO farms.

Re: Blogging can just be stating the obvious

#112
post #9

I was never a prolific blogger. I do write a LOT internally at work and I write very long messages in group chats. With the advent of LLMs, I've felt even less need to publish publicly. It's as if an LLM can either produce something higher-quality and more tailored to the reader's context in a shorter period of time. Or the topic I write would be so niche that it should just be in a group chat.

> if an LLM can either produce something higher-quality and more tailored LLMs won’t always do this well. The best ideas in my backlog are the ones where the LLMs won’t finish my thoughts because they’re contrary to what 1000 people said on a forum somewhere. Or because I’m relaying an original personal experience. But even if LLMs can finish your thoughts, it’s probably good to post anyway. Because in five years LLM…

s/LLMs, maybe two/LLMs may be too/

Text to speech, you're killing me!

Re: Blogging can just be stating the obvious

#113

Everyone learns different things at different phases of life. And when they do, they're excited to share. And if they have a website, they will write about it there. Think of this way. It doesn't matter if the message/info you are sharing is already written about. A ton of people didn't know about it. So when the message is written about again by YOU, more new people will know about it. And read it. Sucks for people…

As it was fortold in the prophecy:

Relevant xkcd https://xkcd.com/1053/>

Re: Blogging can just be stating the obvious

#115
I really constantly have to fight the urge to NOT say/write something because it might be obvious or someone might have said it before.

Just say it.

I recently gave a talk about lessons learned in the past, and it felt really awkward, like, "who am I to tell people what to do?". A few days later, a student walked up to me and thanked me for it, because he adopted a practice I had suggested and thought it was useful. And I had troubles sleeping before the talk because I kept thinking about how plainly obvious it was going to be.

I started blogging again when I discovered that indeed, even if it's only me who finds this useful, it makes sense to write about it. As an exercise in writing, or in case there's at least ONE person on the internet who finds it useful.

Re: Blogging can just be stating the obvious

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One way AI can help here is identifying prior art. Write a quick sketch of you idea, and ask an LLM with uncapped long-running web search capability to find if any prior art exists!

Sorry, I don't mean to single you out in any way, but why does AI/LLMs have to get shoehorned into every discussion here? It's getting exhausting.

I think GP found it useful for this particular use case, as did I and my coworker who is even more enthusiastic about it (he calls it compressed human culture).

And no, Google search (or Wikipedia) won't come close to capacity of LLMs to find similar things.

Re: Blogging can just be stating the obvious

#117

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry, I don't mean to single you out in any way, but why does AI/LLMs have to get shoehorned into every discussion here? It's getting exhausting.

I understand this sentiment but also society as a whole is grappling with how AI will change everything so it kinda makes sense that peoples first reaction to anything is "will this hold in the new age". Doesn't make it non exhausting, just understandable

Definitely. Despite the wording of my question, which I intended to be rhetorical, I understand why people are doing it. While I think that is one explanation, I think it's mostly hype or optimism. In other words, not so much grappling, but rather hoping and wanting AI to do anything and everything.

I just don't personally get why people want that. This endemic force feeding of AI down everyone's throats at every corner is just amplifying people's worst tendencies: greed, laziness, apathy, cognitive disengagement, etc. It's especially apparent when people suggest AI automating activities that have always largely been about personal gratification, growth, and/or expressions of thoughts to share with fellow humans.

I won't deny the benefits that some people get from LLMs (primarily experienced senior developers), but I feel those benefits are far and away outweighed by costs that it's already having on everyone else, both individually and societally.

Sorry for the rant.

Re: Blogging can just be stating the obvious

#118
As for those popups, I get enraged at the "subscribe to our newsletter" screen-grabbing dialog within seconds of going to a webpage. I really wish there was a good extension for automatically getting rid of them without me having to ever see them. I don't care that a certain percentage of people sign up.

Anyway, there's another side to "stating the obvious" that really annoys me. It's the "I have to post today" posts. People get advice that they need to post regularly, be it a blog or Tiktok or Youtube or whatever. "Post once a day at a fixed time" is common advice. What this leads to is posts without content. It can be "thank you for 275,000 followers" posts or something that's obviously so low-effort and uninteresting I just immediately skip. And then you have to ask what does that do to that person's metrics if they have a low-engagement post? Is it better to have that and post regularly? I'm not convinced it is.

I also feel like eventually people run out of things to say. That's OK. But maybe just stop clinging on for dear life to this audience you've built while having nothing to say.

Anyway, if you post something obvious and long-standing like "popups suck", that's fine... unless it's the only thing you're saying.

Re: Blogging can just be stating the obvious

#119

Everyone learns different things at different phases of life. And when they do, they're excited to share. And if they have a website, they will write about it there. Think of this way. It doesn't matter if the message/info you are sharing is already written about. A ton of people didn't know about it. So when the message is written about again by YOU, more new people will know about it. And read it. Sucks for people…

As it was fortold in the prophecy: Relevant xkcd https://xkcd.com/1053/ >

He is the Messiah!!

Re: Blogging can just be stating the obvious

#120

Everyone learns different things at different phases of life. And when they do, they're excited to share. And if they have a website, they will write about it there. Think of this way. It doesn't matter if the message/info you are sharing is already written about. A ton of people didn't know about it. So when the message is written about again by YOU, more new people will know about it. And read it. Sucks for people…

https://xkcd.com/1053/

For every thing "everyone knows", there are ten thousand people learning about it for the first time, every day.

Post reply on HN