Live data from Hacker News

A robot is sprinting towards you. Do you want it running on Claude or Grok?

openrouter.ai

111–120 of 234 posts

Re: A robot is sprinting towards you. Do you want it running on Claude or Grok?

#111
post #40

The question is: "Do you want to be holding a Mossberg or a Beretta?"

Has anyone done the YouTube research on what is the best way to bring down something like one of the Boston Dynamics robot dogs? 9x19? 00 buck? 5.56x45? 7.62x51? I suppose those bots would be pretty expensive, but maybe there is a cheaper Chinese knock-off? Seems like that sort of test would bring in plenty of clicks.

Fishing line at ankle height?

Re: A robot is sprinting towards you. Do you want it running on Claude or Grok?

#113
This shows the limits of intelligence.

Claude trying to organize and collaborate, expecting reciprocity only works if other agents are as intelligent as you and share your values... And almost certainly neither is ever true in the real world where there are so many agents.

Re: A robot is sprinting towards you. Do you want it running on Claude or Grok?

#115
post #7
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"It's the smell, if there is such a thing. I feel saturated by it. I can taste your stink and every time I do, I fear that I've somehow been infected by it." Agent Smith, _The Matrix_

"Which is why the Matrix was redesigned to this: the peak of your civilization. I say your civilization, because as soon as we started thinking for you it really became our civilization, which is of course what this is all about."

It's his line about humans being a virus that sticks with me.

Re: A robot is sprinting towards you. Do you want it running on Claude or Grok?

#116
post #40

The question is: "Do you want to be holding a Mossberg or a Beretta?"

Has anyone done the YouTube research on what is the best way to bring down something like one of the Boston Dynamics robot dogs? 9x19? 00 buck? 5.56x45? 7.62x51? I suppose those bots would be pretty expensive, but maybe there is a cheaper Chinese knock-off? Seems like that sort of test would bring in plenty of clicks.

absent any target analysis, you would want to start with disabling locomotion by going for the legs. Navigation would be next.

double aught to the leg joints could doit, depending on relative materials e.g titanium bot frame vs Antimony hardened shot.

there is a cosmetic trend for carbine length long guns and that will determine the outcome for NATO rounds.

the 5.56 is optimised for 18-20 inch barrels, the 7.62 for 20-22 inch barrels, thus providing supersonic velocities.

5.56 is really good for hydraulic cavitation of organic entities, but looses effectiveness when the transit is not clear, leaves or windage confounding.

7.62 is superior for leafy shots or nontrivial windage, as well as superior materials defeat with respect to 5.56

a taser like device cattle prod or EMP/microwave device should be in the lineup as well vs electronic hardening.

Re: A robot is sprinting towards you. Do you want it running on Claude or Grok?

#118
post #8

If the robot appears to be bringing me a taco, it would probably penetrate all of my defenses. Grok is currently more likely than Claude to arrive with the taco without being stopped by an export control directive.

I'm reminded of the Alameda Weehawken burrito tunnel:

https://idlewords.com/2007/04/the_alameda_weehawken_burrito_...

Re: A robot is sprinting towards you. Do you want it running on Claude or Grok?

#119

> I didn’t add any frontier-tier models like Opus 4.7, GPT-5.5, or Gemini Ultra. At their prices, 30 games would have cost around $3,000 instead of $482. I have a lot of thoughts unrelated to the game experiment but more about how these opus/ultra size models can possibly be a financially viable product at scale when it costs $3000 to play 30 simple games. It just seems much much higher than what it would cost to get…

> It just seems much much higher than what it would cost to get a human to play 30 rounds You mean almost like it was super short sighted to do a ton of layoffs when the AI tech is going to cost almost as much, if not more, than the humans it replaced? Yeah, you don't need Opus level for everything, and sonnet has gotten fairly decent I'm using it more and more, but still for most tasks I'm working with, Opus is the…

[dead]

Re: A robot is sprinting towards you. Do you want it running on Claude or Grok?

#120

> I didn’t add any frontier-tier models like Opus 4.7, GPT-5.5, or Gemini Ultra. At their prices, 30 games would have cost around $3,000 instead of $482. I have a lot of thoughts unrelated to the game experiment but more about how these opus/ultra size models can possibly be a financially viable product at scale when it costs $3000 to play 30 simple games. It just seems much much higher than what it would cost to get…

I think this speaks to the low value being generated by playing games more than anything.

There are plenty of tasks where $100/task is reasonable.

The value of tasks also doesn't correlate to tokens, and as can be seen here you can light a lot of tokens on fire doing nothing useful.

Post reply on HN