Live data from Hacker News

The Rise of the Bullshittery

xn--gckvb8fzb.com

111–120 of 128 posts

Re: The Rise of the Bullshittery

#111
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A reasonable approach is the one that was used in real life: friends of friends can be invited to the space for compatibility screening.

Yeah of course It makes it very, very hard to start from zero though. Like starting over in a new city

Shared hobbies and interests connect people, and you can use that to leverage into friendships.

Re: The Rise of the Bullshittery

#112
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I increasingly feel the same about the comment quality of HN in recent years. There are three topics that inevitably get injected into every discussion: AI, politics, and nostalgia. The thing is, I don't understand the goal. This isn't reddit. Few people on here are that broke, uneducated, or impressionable. This site is also deliberately designed to not reward any interaction.

HN has definitely experienced a marked decline in quality over the last 15 years, (since the account I am currently posting from has existed,) I know this sort of remark is discouraged by the guidelines, but the trend is substantial enough that it cannot be ignored. I don't think users have any specific goal, but they are indeed posting the same inane drivel and joke comments as Reddit, notably including the classic…

Even the fact that you can't criticize this site on this site is part of the problem.

Also think about the fact that you can't post "comments that are dismissive or without substance" but the titles are zero information basic clickbait from around the internet.

Re: The Rise of the Bullshittery

#113
post #88

Seen this a few months back. One of our "analysts" threw together a bunch of nonsensical shit and tried to pitch it as a product change to our management team. It was a powerpoint full of charts that made no sense populated by data that made no sense. After I bit I realised the text was so "normal" it was LLM generated. The guy had just made a pitch deck with an LLM after throwing some random numbers at it. Our manag…

Keep a journal. Think about a book deal.

Re: The Rise of the Bullshittery

#114

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Imagine that you decide that you would like to try farming, and you buy some geese. One of the geese, for whatever reason, begins to lay golden eggs. Your little farm is now unbelievably profitable. It is as profitable as your thousand closest neighboring farms combined. So naturally, you hire guards for the goose and experts on golden geese veterinary science to make sure that the goose is fed and healthy and is max…

> Not growing is completely unacceptable; it is anathema Succinctly put and so very both unfortunate and accurate. The only other thing I can think of that grows endlessly is cancer. There’s an analogy in there if you squint hard enough.

Cancer does not grow endlessly.

Re: The Rise of the Bullshittery

#115
post #88

Seen this a few months back. One of our "analysts" threw together a bunch of nonsensical shit and tried to pitch it as a product change to our management team. It was a powerpoint full of charts that made no sense populated by data that made no sense. After I bit I realised the text was so "normal" it was LLM generated. The guy had just made a pitch deck with an LLM after throwing some random numbers at it. Our manag…

Keep a journal. Think about a book deal.

I have been. I've got enough material from this place to outdo Scott Adams.

Re: The Rise of the Bullshittery

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Not growing is completely unacceptable; it is anathema Succinctly put and so very both unfortunate and accurate. The only other thing I can think of that grows endlessly is cancer. There’s an analogy in there if you squint hard enough.

Cancer does not grow endlessly.

Doesn't it?

Re: The Rise of the Bullshittery

#117
post #69

Using a throwaway for this comment, but my first experience with this kind of thing was in 2013 when I joined a major international company with over 100k employees worldwide and realized that there were entire departments and organizations dedicated to delivering no value at all. Departments with 100s of people, with middle managers making several times the average salary in my country, where after years of work not…

I was shocked by this as well. I think it's a natural property of large organizations and it takes great effort and great leaders to fight it. The way I think about it is that building something truly successful comes with a tremendous amount of momentum. So much momentum that growth for these companies still occurs. The people hired into a mature organization are literally there just to keep the lights on and let th…

This. Also sometimes the small thing is collateral damage from random reorganizations, nothing personal but you're now part of org Y which doesn't have budget for that.

Re: The Rise of the Bullshittery

#118

Using a throwaway for this comment, but my first experience with this kind of thing was in 2013 when I joined a major international company with over 100k employees worldwide and realized that there were entire departments and organizations dedicated to delivering no value at all. Departments with 100s of people, with middle managers making several times the average salary in my country, where after years of work not…

It's UBI man. All those jobs are essentially UBI. I've been thinking about this a lot, but basically, my old job was basically superfluous and we didn't accomplish anything important but I had to pretend that it was real, important, meaningful, and progressing. The truth is that most people's jobs are kind of unnecessary in the white collar world, and in some David Graber-esque hellscape we have to pretend that all t…

I am impressed that Graeber made his way into this conversation (and the author's article), and really appreciate your take.

I think about "Bullshit Jobs" every time I hear someone tell me how lean, efficient and rational the free-market private sector is compared to socialist central planning. In many senses, it is of course true, but it's not quite as true as one might believe at first glance.

Re: The Rise of the Bullshittery

#120
post #36

In "Failure Is Not an Option", Gene Kranz, who ran Apollo Mission Control in the 1960s, brings up tolerance for bullshit. Someone tried to bullshit him about something. He put his arm around them and walked them out of mission control. They were never in that room again. We need more leaders like that.

They need to get int positions of leadership first. In a typical corpo office, those people are not rewarded, they are pushed out.
Post reply on HN