Live data from Hacker News

Interview with Bob Odenkirk

nytimes.com

111–120 of 153 posts

Re: Interview with Bob Odenkirk

#111
post #21

This was an interesting interview. Like a lot of great comedians, Odenkirk has a very grounded and bleak view of the world. I suppose a lot of art, comedy included, is a way of coping with their perspective, for themselves and for the audience.

I think it has more to do with Comedians having to work their way up the chain.

Re: Interview with Bob Odenkirk

#112
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On the contrary, read the piece. He's not saying it from comfort, he's saying it after a heart attack, after his kids grew up, after the form he loved became a young man's game. The farce isn't a punchline delivered from above; it's what's left when the registers that used to hold you don't anymore. And his answer isn't despair, it's "we've got to keep trying… there's a breeze beneath my wings." That's not whimsy. Th…

A triple "It's not this... it's that"...

[deleted]

Re: Interview with Bob Odenkirk

#114
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On the contrary, read the piece. He's not saying it from comfort, he's saying it after a heart attack, after his kids grew up, after the form he loved became a young man's game. The farce isn't a punchline delivered from above; it's what's left when the registers that used to hold you don't anymore. And his answer isn't despair, it's "we've got to keep trying… there's a breeze beneath my wings." That's not whimsy. Th…

A triple "It's not this... it's that"...

Triples is best.

Re: Interview with Bob Odenkirk

#116
post #85
post #144

[stub for offtopicness] [article authors don't write these headlines, you guys - let alone interview subjects]

Easy to be philosopher when you are millionaire.

he didn't get to millionaire without doing comedy for a while, lot of digging into the human condition there.

easy to be a philosopher when you're forced to portray pathos and bathos, on camera, for years

Re: Interview with Bob Odenkirk

#117
post #93
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When you're successful and rich (enough, at least), this is a nice whimsical thing to say. When you're suffering in the trenches, this isn't very helpful.

Did you read the interview? He basically says as much. >There’s no question that the security that you feel from not being afraid of a health issue or housing is a great comfort and helps you to be more at peace with life. It’s just not as much help as you think it should be.

I’ll disagree with Odenkirk there. Not having to try to decide if you think one of your kids should be taken to the ER at the expense of the other kid for what is probably not an emergency infection, but maybe there’s a chance it could spread and cause real damage so antibiotics now would help, but then the other kid won’t be able to do xyz due to not having a spare $2,000 is a pretty shitty experience.

Security of housing and healthcare is an enormous boost in life. I avoided playing sports when I was a kid because my dad told me a broken arm would set the family back (there were no out of pocket maximums back then).

The government paid if you were dirt poor and had no prospects, or employer or government paid if you were a white collar/union or government employee, but for immigrants invested into their 24/7 small business, they had assets that could be seized but very little cash flow to be able to pay unexpected bills.

Re: Interview with Bob Odenkirk

#118
post #18
post #144

[stub for offtopicness] [article authors don't write these headlines, you guys - let alone interview subjects]

When you're successful and rich (enough, at least), this is a nice whimsical thing to say. When you're suffering in the trenches, this isn't very helpful.

I agree. I'm quite sure even Bob would agree. He never even used the words "farce" or "meaning(less)". He just agreed to "life is a farce" in a context that mostly reflected on his work as a comedian. Also the entire interview reads quite performative. This whole emotions-are-just-molecules, life-is-just-a-game etc perspectives fall flat as soon as the doctor tells the armchair-nihilist he has cancer ... suddenly life feels like something more important than a game and the feelings are no longer just molecules.

Re: Interview with Bob Odenkirk

#120
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The world is like a ride in an amusement park. And when you choose to go on it you think it's real because that's how powerful our minds are. And the ride goes up and down and round and round. It has thrills and chills and it's very brightly colored and it's very loud and it's fun, for a while. Some people have been on the ride for a long time and they begin to question: "Is this real, or is this just a ride?" And…

> The world is like a ride in an amusement park only difference is, in real world there may be consequences that you may not be able to undo so you may have to be little careful while riding.

Well, and some people are able to buy nicer seats on the ride with plush seats and air conditioning, and some people have to sit on hard backed plastic that hurts, and some people around you don’t get a seat at all and fall off and die routinely, and the ride keeps moving.
Post reply on HN