Live data from Hacker News

The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

writingruxandrabio.com

111–120 of 192 posts

Re: The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

#111

There’s a lot to be said about the seemingly overbearing nature of the majority of FDA/ISO standards that result in the mass amount of hurdles that need to be jumped before a treatment is available, but that’s mainly due to institutional trauma from past events (thalidomide, primarily) as well as the fact that treatments are not simply binary. The options are not just “does not work” and “makes patient better,” there…

During covid, the FDA testified to congress that they were putting the vaccines on an approval fast track that would not reduce safety or efficacy. Why is this not the standard approval track?

Everything not mRNA failed. Sometimes miserably with bad effects, and those effects have all been swept under the rug. Some of the vaccines gave people lifelong sensitivities to the adenovirus vectors. I can go on and on.

We got damned lucky that mRNA vaccines against Covid work as well as they do. Nobody new a priori (go look at Derek Lowe's writing from "In the Pipeline" during it all) and "everything would strike out" was not off the table.

And the mRNA stuff only worked because people already had been working on mRNA vaccines for other things slowly over decades. We got "lucky" that Covid appeared when we had all the pieces in places (liposome encapsulation, alternate amino acid replacement, etc.)

Before advocating for "fast track", advocate for better and more stable funding on the "slow track" pure research that takes decades but feeds into this kind of thing. The work of Katalin Karikó was instrumental in this stuff and yet she had to swim through mountains of shit to do the research and was denied tenure. With better funding, this stuff could have been done a decade earlier.

Re: The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

#112
The Pharmachy cartel will never let things like this happen.

Search for Barbara O'Nell, if I remember her surname right, she is Australian and was banned from practicing anything medicine related because she was using natural resources to help threat people that would otherwise, spend thousands of Australian dollars buying medicine. Her videos are awesome btw.

Re: The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

#113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please show me the blood that zoning regulations are written in

The context is medical regulations.

What blood is the regulation that doctors can't see patients in other states written in?

Re: The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

#115
post #107

For those of modest means there is also the "fail first" insurance process where you need to use less expensive therapies before a more appropriate therapy is approved. Each failure can be costly to a patient's health, often exacting irreversible comorbidities, not even considering lost work, family wellbeing, and pain/suffering. For those with rare diseases, insurance also doesn't help with "N of 1" efforts. A case…

Imagine if we let doctors do medicine instead of letting profiteering beancounters optimize for number go up.

I can see why some things landed here. Medicine is expensive. Desperate people are more susceptible to fraud. Yet things are improving: someone like me would be long dead a generation ago.

We should look at these challenges holistically and think about better fiscal/social engineering of our marketplaces. Alvin Roth's book, "Who Gets What and Why", is a good introduction to identifying market failures and thinking about how to address them.

Re: The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

#116
post #40
post #30

> More and more promising treatments are accumulating in the pipeline, fueled by an explosion of new therapeutic modalities, ranging from mRNA to better peptides and more recently, by AI. If the pipeline is backed up you put a bigger pipe in place, not get rid of it and hope some of the resulting flood goes where you want.

It’s less of a pipeline and more like a rocket engine. The exhaust gas (clinical data) spins the pump. We’ve put restrictors on that flow, and it’s taking a lot of fuel to get off the ground.

> The exhaust gas (clinical data) spins the pump

Not really. Real-world data is used very heavily already and is far less helpful than we'd hope for in drug development.

It's much more like a pipeline.

Re: The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

#117

The Pharmachy cartel will never let things like this happen. Search for Barbara O'Nell, if I remember her surname right, she is Australian and was banned from practicing anything medicine related because she was using natural resources to help threat people that would otherwise, spend thousands of Australian dollars buying medicine. Her videos are awesome btw.

Barbara O’Neill promotes baking soda injections as a cancer cure and encourages people not to use antibiotics because she thinks they cause cancer. She’s a dimwit.

Re: The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

#118

There’s a lot to be said about the seemingly overbearing nature of the majority of FDA/ISO standards that result in the mass amount of hurdles that need to be jumped before a treatment is available, but that’s mainly due to institutional trauma from past events (thalidomide, primarily) as well as the fact that treatments are not simply binary. The options are not just “does not work” and “makes patient better,” there…

The FDA didn't approve thalidomide, though! That was Europe!

Re: The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

#119

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The UK is begging for people to build datacenters: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/mar/09/revealed-...

National governments maybe. Local ones aren’t, and it’s those that fill with nimbys and maintain the majority of control over planning

Everyone wants the datacenter somewhere in their country for sovereignty... just not next to them. Quelle surprise. At this point you may as well build supermarkets on top of them just to sell 'em to people.

Re: The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure

#120

The Pharmachy cartel will never let things like this happen. Search for Barbara O'Nell, if I remember her surname right, she is Australian and was banned from practicing anything medicine related because she was using natural resources to help threat people that would otherwise, spend thousands of Australian dollars buying medicine. Her videos are awesome btw.

Barbara O’Neill promotes baking soda injections as a cancer cure and encourages people not to use antibiotics because she thinks they cause cancer. She’s a dimwit.

[flagged]
Post reply on HN