Live data from Hacker News

Self-help gets philosophical

thedriftmag.com

111–112 of 112 posts

Re: Self-help gets philosophical

#111
post #30

I have a particular disdain for the profanity-laden slop that is works penned by Mark Manson. He's not alone as most "self-help" books are trash reads that only serve as some form of cathartic release to their readers. That's not to say all books in the genre are useless. I have recommended Cal Newport's works before but they very much suffer from "this 300 page book could have been a blog post" levels of verbosity.

A huge amount of nonfiction work is overlong. Many nonfiction works could be condensed to an essay or even just a blurb.

A wasted opportunity to explore related ideas.

Re: Self-help gets philosophical

#112
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You will never have as much power as Aurelius. Why was he nevertheless a stoic?

He studied the greek classics with a mentor before he became Emperor. His Meditations reflect his study. He didn’t want to become Emperor because he viewed it as a life of strict duty and tasks that he didn’t want to do, like going on military campaigns.

Sure but why was he attracted to this philosophy, even though he had lots of power? It directly contradicts the OPs argument.

Nothing has changed in this since his time - humans will always have things they cannot change and things they can change.

Post reply on HN