Live data from Hacker News

Re: My AI skeptic friends are all nuts

skarlso.github.io

111–116 of 116 posts

Re: Re: My AI skeptic friends are all nuts

#111
post #74

I can't shake the belief that the more one finds LLMs useful, the less valuable their work already is. Something that has no guarantee,not even a reassurance of being correct should not be trusted with any meaningful work

I need you to understand that software development with LLMs isnt about writing a prompt to spit out your entire app.

[dead]

Re: Re: My AI skeptic friends are all nuts

#112
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Fear of AI is universal but skepticism is not. It's a (primarily) far left meme that AI is just hype and should be compared to scams like cryptocurrencies.

I linked you research showing the opposite of what you claim. I'd recommend not looking at topics through this culture war lens, it tends to corrupts people's ability to be objective and thoughtful.

I'd recommend understanding the point before missing it so entirely and repeatedly.

You claimed that "concern about AI is much higher than 5%" which has nothing to do with the point about AI skepticism I'm talking about.

In fact, having concerns about AI implies a lack of skepticism about its power (although people are often hold incoherent views).

Re: Re: My AI skeptic friends are all nuts

#113
Just chiming in to say that this piece's summary of my argument about "hallucinations" is incorrect; it is not my claim that "reading the code" solves hallucinations.

(You have to read the code anyways, but by the time you're reading it, there shouldn't be hallucinations, in a modern workflow.)

Re: Re: My AI skeptic friends are all nuts

#114
post #26

I feel like this article makes the same tired point I see every time a new technology comes alone: "but if we don't know how to shoe our own horses any more because we got cars, soon nobody will know how to shoe horses!" Yeah. And that's OK. Because nobody will need to shoe horses any more! If I forget how to write tests, what's the problem? It means that I never need to write tests any more. If I do need to write te…

Had to drop in here to call you out for completely missing the point of the article.

The whole point is that these LLMs build up a dependence because your critical thinking skills need not apply when a data center can average together passable answer for you.

Re: Re: My AI skeptic friends are all nuts

#116
post #26

I feel like this article makes the same tired point I see every time a new technology comes alone: "but if we don't know how to shoe our own horses any more because we got cars, soon nobody will know how to shoe horses!" Yeah. And that's OK. Because nobody will need to shoe horses any more! If I forget how to write tests, what's the problem? It means that I never need to write tests any more. If I do need to write te…

Had to drop in here to call you out for completely missing the point of the article. The whole point is that these LLMs build up a dependence because your critical thinking skills need not apply when a data center can average together passable answer for you.

Again, as I've said many times in the comments here, if you need something, you'll keep it. If you don't keep it, it means you don't need it. If your critical skills atrophy, it's because you never need to use them, and if you never need to use them, what's the problem?
Post reply on HN