Live data from Hacker News

Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

sesame.com

111–120 of 231 posts

Re: Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

#111

Some comedy skilled guys made radio play like impro with this AI and it is beyond hilarious. Miles gets Arrested: Sesame.ai https://youtu.be/cGMO2hRNnv0

Martin Shkreli is "some comedy skilled guys", or is this a fake Shkreli satire account or something?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Shkreli

Re: Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

#112

This was already posted here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43221377 but I’m really surprised at the lack of attention this model is getting. The responsiveness and apparent personality are pretty mind blowing. It’s similar to what OpenAI had initially demoed for advanced voice mode, at least for the voice conversation portion. The demo interactions are recorded, which is mentioned in their disclaimer under th…

> 2. Calls are recorded for quality review but not used for ML training and are deleted within 30 days.

Sounds (pun intended) reasonable.

Re: Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

#113
post #70

It's good, but it still sounds fake to me, but in a different way. The voice itself sounds like a human, undoubtedly. But the cadence and the rhythm of speaking are off. It sounds like someone who isn't a podcaster trying to speak in the personality of a podcaster. It just sounds like someone trying too hard and speaking in an unnatural way.

I also think it didn't feel very "real". Trying too hard to sound upbeat and too eager to please, maybe it's just me being European but it makes me go "ewww, that's not how normal people speak".

It sounds like a "sales and marketing coordinator" for something very tech-bro adjacent after two strong cups of coffee.

Re: Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

#114

Still suffers the same problem that all Voice Recognition seems to suffer; cannot reliably detect that the speaker has finished speaking. This was almost worse though because it did feel like a rude person just interrupting instead of a dumb computer not being able to pick up normal social cues around when the person they're listening to has finished.

I think they need to implement the statistical bias where the longer a person talks, the less likely they are going to be stopping at any specific part of their speech. Sorta like the rising sun problem[0]

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunrise_problem

Re: Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

#115

I played with this last night with my four-year old daughter. We had fun with asking Miles to explain what bones are made of etc. Today, she asked "where has that robot guy gone?". Crying now because I won't let her talk to Miles anymore. She has already developed an emotional connection to it. Worrying indeed.

I would like to think the child is missing the bonding and fun the two of you enjoyed with the robot guy. The child may be missing the experience of being with you and the robot guy. I would look for more activities you can explore with the child.

Re: Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

#116
post #70

It's good, but it still sounds fake to me, but in a different way. The voice itself sounds like a human, undoubtedly. But the cadence and the rhythm of speaking are off. It sounds like someone who isn't a podcaster trying to speak in the personality of a podcaster. It just sounds like someone trying too hard and speaking in an unnatural way.

I also think it didn't feel very "real". Trying too hard to sound upbeat and too eager to please, maybe it's just me being European but it makes me go "ewww, that's not how normal people speak".

That's american office culture for you. If it was australian it'd be drab, boring, and self-flagellating

Re: Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

#117

Some comedy skilled guys made radio play like impro with this AI and it is beyond hilarious. Miles gets Arrested: Sesame.ai https://youtu.be/cGMO2hRNnv0

wtf.. is this the same Epipen-increasing-prices-by-5000% "Martin Shkreli" ? I thought the guy was just a greedy executive. Now, he appears like a real world Moriarty. Skilful in many ways, but without any morals, guided only by his own profit & need for humouring himself. Seriously wtf.

Re: Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

#118

While impressive, the paramount question stands: Why do we even need "emotional" voices? All that emotionality adds is that you get the illusion of a friend - a friend that can't help you in any way in the real world and who's confidentiality is as strong as the privacy policies & data security of the company running it - which often ultimately trends towards 0. Smart Neutral Voice Assistants could be a great help, b…

one thing: language learning

Re: Crossing the uncanny valley of conversational voice

#119
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe the ability to personalize the voice so it is more... robotic or based on a fictional thing like Knight Rider would help to change the attachment to something more... healthy?

Yeah this is straight up creepy, and I also can't stand chatgpt saying "Lmao" and "Yeah". Keep it formal & robotic.

What ever did you tell ChatGPT so it responded with "lmao"?

I told it that it should behave explicitly like a computer in the system prompt, sort of worked.

Post reply on HN