Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

news.ycombinator.com

111–120 of 125 posts

Re: Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

#111
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Software also requires far more maintenance and modification. Whereas building a bridge takes more work than maintaining it software is often the opposite

While true, nobody asks you to turn a bridge into a tunnel the day after the first cars drive across it either.

Kayak => Ferry => Bridge => Tunnel

No you are not allowed to rewrite or refactor. Only add!

Re: Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

#112
post #29

Thanks and hats off to all people doing useful work everywhere. From store clerks to firefighters, from office administrators to CEOs of companies providing useful products/services at a large scale. We need each other. On the topic of engineering specifically, yes engineers build reliable complex systems that make the world livable. Software engineers also build the invisible bits that runs the digital infrastructur…

> From store clerks to firefighters, from office administrators to CEOs of companies providing useful products/services at a large scale. I run a small software business, but also work part-time as an EMT and volunteer as a SAR medic. I make approximately 12x more from my software business per hour worked (and I'm the lowest paid employee in the business) than I do working as an EMT (and obviously the volunteer isn't…

Wow, so is it like $40h vs $480/h?

Re: Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

#113

Over the past few years, I've been taking driving very seriously in terms of skill development and practice. One ritual I've started doing is thanking my car after every drive. For the privilege I'm afforded by being able to drive freely unlike most of the world. For the car itself for holding up so reliably. And for the hundred+ years of engineering man hours and passion given to get where we are today. In any popul…

You seem to suggest cars save more lives than they take. I am not sure that's the case. Especially knowing the car injury stats and secondary effects of different kinds of pollution.

Definitely not. But it's not just only optimizing for life, it's having flexible and reliable transportation while making sure as few injuries happen as possible in the process.

Motor travel let us distribute food, medicine, and specialized labor that would otherwise be impossible/impractical to do.

Sure you can argue that's not worth the non zero number of lives lost in the process, but we wouldn't be able to live the modern lifestyles we have today without it.

Like being able to go to a hospital filled with teams of experienced specialists to get better treatment.

Re: Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

#114

People would probably die if I was an actual engineer, so I'm deeply appreciative that I can enjoy infrastructure and whatnot without having to worry about it crumbling above/beneath me.

Most infrastructure relies on software as well. I mean just look at the Southwest kerfuffle for a current example

What a terrifying thought

Re: Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

#115
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, but you have patent protection. Software engineers don't have that in all parts of the world.

China doesn't care about patents and will manufacture your design for 1/3rd of the price.

Not to forget they will manufacture it for 1/3rd of the price, often with 1/4th of the quality of the original part but still will put your logo onto it. And you as the original part maker then to struggle with the damage to your reputation

Re: Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

#116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> From store clerks to firefighters, from office administrators to CEOs of companies providing useful products/services at a large scale. I run a small software business, but also work part-time as an EMT and volunteer as a SAR medic. I make approximately 12x more from my software business per hour worked (and I'm the lowest paid employee in the business) than I do working as an EMT (and obviously the volunteer isn't…

Wow, so is it like $40h vs $480/h?

€18 per hour versus ~€1,500 per day.

Re: Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

#117

Yes, but. Most real world engineers could also be software engineers too. I studied Mechanical Engineering and had to learn Fortran and Pascal as part of my undergrad. What I find strange is that some of the best software engineers are not as strong at Math as you would expect. Of course there are exceptions (and no doubt they are all here on HN!). So while real world engineers can cross the divide to become software…

Forget math, I shocked myself with wet fingers on a light switch when I was like 8, and have been afraid of electricity ever since.

Re: Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

#118

The reason software engineers make more money than other engineers is quite simple. Software scales a lot better than hardware, so a lot more money can be made with it. Thus more business are built on it, thus demand for those who can build software, thus higher pay. That software engineers be pampered or not is a result of demand being high for the skills. In the long term, it's not a matter of industry culture (as…

Software also requires far more maintenance and modification. Whereas building a bridge takes more work than maintaining it software is often the opposite

I don't think so. The factories building the hardware require much more maintenance than the software just to keep the lights on, not including growth. Solid state stuff is incredibly reliable in comparison. Then add growth, which I already explained is where software truly shines in how cheap it is to scale in comparison.

There's a reason software companies are making fortunes. The margins are incredibly high, high enough to more than compensate for inefficiencies such as lavish office spaces, low employee utilization, etc.

Re: Tell HN: Thanks and hats off to all the non software engineers

#119
post #101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Most people don't want to be stuck in frony of a computer working om intangible code either and that's why you get paid more. I feel like this hits the nail on the head. Neither me nor anyone else I know would work as a software engineer if the pay were significantly lower. I daydream of stacking shelves. If that paid half, I’d absolutely take it over software engineering. But it only pays 1/4, so I kill myself in…

FWIW, I would work in tech even if I won a huge lottery so it isn't none just not most. I did work physically demanding and outdoory jobs, not for me. I need constant cerebral engagement with little human drama. I spent many evenings and weekends doing techy stuff to be where i am. I spent and am spending all of my holiday season offtime learning/studying.

Yes to both. Changed careers to do this when I discovered I had both the aptitude and interest. I've only had the marginal success doing it that I've had a result of substantial time invested studying independently.

With that said, I'm absolutely burnt out on endless meetings, bs deliverables, mismanagement, and cargo-cult testing nonsense on Yet Another Crud App.

I too spend substantial time reading about build systems, programming languages, etc. I want nothing more to work on something at least marginally interesting with the opportunity to learn from my peers. That's not at all present in my current circumstances.

I wouldn't do _this_ given a hypothetical lottery windfall.

Post reply on HN