Live data from Hacker News

Pocket Casts goes open source

ma.tt

111–120 of 154 posts

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#111
post #26

Best part of PocketCast is the stats. It can tell me that since 2016 I've listened to 135 days worth of podcasts and apparently I've "saved" 46 days by increasing the playback speed and 3 days from trimming silence. (I also have 350 hours in my "up next" queue ...)

Imagine how much time we can save by skipping ads and sponsors.

[deleted]

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#112
post #26

Best part of PocketCast is the stats. It can tell me that since 2016 I've listened to 135 days worth of podcasts and apparently I've "saved" 46 days by increasing the playback speed and 3 days from trimming silence. (I also have 350 hours in my "up next" queue ...)

I like Pocket Casts and I’m not knocking the fact that they have them or that other people like them, but stats like these make me feel existential dread.

yea... reminds me of seeing the number of hours a friend had put into EverQuest. I'm sure I'd be appalled at many of my own stats for my own activities

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#113

After being a user for many many years, I just recently tested out to Snipd [1] and have not looked back since. Pocket Cast were great but I don't see them innovating. With Snipd there is almost always a full text transcript available including a surprisingly accurate AI generated Table of Contents to cue through. Then I can easily save a transcribed clip of some section I am listening to for export to a TfT program…

wow, to each their own... I just installed spind based on this but it wanted me to pick categories so it could spam me with suggestions. There's no skipping it so I uninstalled. I have zero desire for a podcast app to suggest podcasts to me period. I get plenty of recommendations from the podcasters I listen to. I don't need more even more ads in my life.

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#114
post #28

After being a user for many many years, I just recently tested out to Snipd [1] and have not looked back since. Pocket Cast were great but I don't see them innovating. With Snipd there is almost always a full text transcript available including a surprisingly accurate AI generated Table of Contents to cue through. Then I can easily save a transcribed clip of some section I am listening to for export to a TfT program…

> I don't see them innovating For a podcast app that's a feature, not a bug.

People say this all the time in all kinds of product categories. They are nearly always wrong. There's always some feature you didn't think of.

Plenty of good and useful features have been added to podcast apps since the first one shipped.

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#115
I just went to check it on the iPhone App store. I know that ratings might not mean anything? but, I noticed it was rated 3.9 of 5 stars vs several other podcasts with up to 6x to 90x more votes and 4.5 to 5 stars.

Is it just a popularity contest or are those other apps better?

Podcast App (4.8, 228k votes)

Google Podcasts (4.7, 10k votes)

Overcast (4.7, 33k votes)

Podcast Player - Castbox (4.8, 98k votes)

Pocket Casts (3.9, 2.8k votes)

Stitcher (4.8, 4.7k votes)

Discounting the apple podcast app (4.9, 973k votes) since it's built in and therefore has an unfair advantage.

Might explain why it was sold if it was clear it wasn't winning. I certainly like the idea of a player that doesn't report to someone my interests.

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#116
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless Spotify adds support for adding podcasts via RSS Feed URL, I don't think there will be major risk of a large scale move.

I imagine very few people care about that. I can’t remember the last time I had to paste in a podcast url anywhere. I just search for a podcast in-app and click “Subscribe”.

Most of my subscriptions are like that too. But there are a few creators who I support on Patreon, and they provide special feeds with extra content, etc. These paid subscriptions are a small % of my overall lineup, but not coincidentally, they're my "essentials". I don't think I'm alone!

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#117
post #26

Best part of PocketCast is the stats. It can tell me that since 2016 I've listened to 135 days worth of podcasts and apparently I've "saved" 46 days by increasing the playback speed and 3 days from trimming silence. (I also have 350 hours in my "up next" queue ...)

Imagine how much time we can save by skipping ads and sponsors.

Maybe someone can make a SponsorBlock fork now that it's open source.

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#118
post #21
post #3

Reading this made me grin. Pocket Casts is one of the only applications that's survived me bouncing between iOS and Android and back again over the last who-knows-how-many years and I paid for their web player a long time ago, too. I've tried other players and none of them stick; the differences in affordances in something like Castro or Overcast send me back to Pocket Casts every time. They seem to have had a rough…

Spot on: “the land of the misfit web toys” or “this would have been killed at Google”.

I kind of dislike the "Google graveyard" discourse, but ... I started using Pocketcasts after the demise of Google Listen.

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#119
post #115

I just went to check it on the iPhone App store. I know that ratings might not mean anything? but, I noticed it was rated 3.9 of 5 stars vs several other podcasts with up to 6x to 90x more votes and 4.5 to 5 stars. Is it just a popularity contest or are those other apps better? Podcast App (4.8, 228k votes) Google Podcasts (4.7, 10k votes) Overcast (4.7, 33k votes) Podcast Player - Castbox (4.8, 98k votes) Pocket Cas…

A decent portion of those negative reviews stem from various controversies the app has gone through over the years combined with a passionate and easily angered user base.

The main two being:

- The 7.0 UI update in which certain features such as playlists were removed & the UX streamlined.

- The move from a paid app to free with subscription.

It’s an excellent app for the most part, certainly on par with others in that list.

Re: Pocket Casts goes open source

#120

After being a user for many many years, I just recently tested out to Snipd [1] and have not looked back since. Pocket Cast were great but I don't see them innovating. With Snipd there is almost always a full text transcript available including a surprisingly accurate AI generated Table of Contents to cue through. Then I can easily save a transcribed clip of some section I am listening to for export to a TfT program…

No desktop app, no thanks.
Post reply on HN