Live data from Hacker News

Why we’ve decided to decommission Gov.uk PaaS

gds.blog.gov.uk

111–120 of 163 posts

Re: Why we’ve decided to decommission Gov.uk PaaS

#111
post #87

The June 2021 assessment [0] of the service notes that "the team will never be able to fully recoup their cost through a recharge model so will need to rely on centrally provided funding. This poses an important risk to the longevity of the product, as it is *dependent on political buy-in and budget from the Treasury*". [0] https://www.gov.uk/service-standard-reports/gov-dot-uk-platf...

A pathetic example of the ideological myopia that plagues Europe these days. States have provided services to their inhabitants since prehistory, and the notion that this infrastructure does not need financing is as healthy as a corporation that thinks it does not need to invest to succeed. At best, this strategy of living off of investments made by previous generations is doomed to underperform compared to states that take an active role in their own development.

Re: Why we’ve decided to decommission Gov.uk PaaS

#114
post #111
post #87

The June 2021 assessment [0] of the service notes that "the team will never be able to fully recoup their cost through a recharge model so will need to rely on centrally provided funding. This poses an important risk to the longevity of the product, as it is *dependent on political buy-in and budget from the Treasury*". [0] https://www.gov.uk/service-standard-reports/gov-dot-uk-platf...

A pathetic example of the ideological myopia that plagues Europe these days. States have provided services to their inhabitants since prehistory, and the notion that this infrastructure does not need financing is as healthy as a corporation that thinks it does not need to invest to succeed. At best, this strategy of living off of investments made by previous generations is doomed to underperform compared to states th…

I don't know if this is a European wide problem or just a UK one.

Re: Why we’ve decided to decommission Gov.uk PaaS

#115

I don't get it, are they saying that public organizations should move to using AWS/Azure/GCP?

Well they sort of do already. There are armies of consultancies queuing up to provide packaged solutions far above the cloud infra level solutions abstractions that GDS offer. Those guys use commercial clouds.

Re: Why we’ve decided to decommission Gov.uk PaaS

#116
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Namely, when people work less, less innovation happens, which means less productivity growth happens, which means less innovation happens, and so on. That's quite a stretch. Ask any engineer about having that a-ha moment in the shower, or when out for a walk. Downtime is incredibly important for mentally intense work. Work smarter, not harder and all that. Productivity isn't tied to time spent in office - my experi…

> That's quite a stretch. Ask any engineer about having that a-ha moment in the shower, or when out for a walk. Downtime is incredibly important for mentally intense work. I agree but I think you’ll find that working usually contributes economic value. Not working usually doesn’t. The key word being usually. if you’re in doubt, just try to record the economic value delivered by your downtime. How many hours are idled…

> I agree but I think you’ll find that working usually contributes economic value.

That's unimportant, though.

Re: Why we’ve decided to decommission Gov.uk PaaS

#117
post #114
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A pathetic example of the ideological myopia that plagues Europe these days. States have provided services to their inhabitants since prehistory, and the notion that this infrastructure does not need financing is as healthy as a corporation that thinks it does not need to invest to succeed. At best, this strategy of living off of investments made by previous generations is doomed to underperform compared to states th…

I don't know if this is a European wide problem or just a UK one.

It certainly seems worst in the UK.

Re: Why we’ve decided to decommission Gov.uk PaaS

#118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't feel bad. Europeans have a much better work-life balance. Plenty of parental leave. A culture that prioritizes life outside the office. Six weeks of guaranteed vacation that people actually take. Etc. Those things have a price. Namely, when people work less, less innovation happens, which means less productivity growth happens, which means less innovation happens, and so on. I lived in Germany for two years. I…

>Europeans have [...] Six weeks of guaranteed vacation that people actually take. That is false. EU mandates minimum 4 weeks of PTO across all members but varies wildly according to country, sector and company. In most EU countries I've seen the average tends to hover around 5 weeks while 6 weeks or more is usually for very generous employers trying to attract top applicants in employee friendly countries. I get you'…

Six days PTO would still be a jab at Americans.

Re: Why we’ve decided to decommission Gov.uk PaaS

#119
post #108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there any Europe-based PaaS currently operating, that are noteworthy? Most companies seems to be US-based.

I understand the intent of the question, but in this case a UK-based alternative would be preferable, not just a European alternative. The UK is more likely to find itself at odds with France than the U.S. That thought reminds me of a conversation in an episode of Yes Prime Minister: > Hacker: I sometimes wonder why we need the [nuclear] weapons. > Sir Humphrey: Minister! You're not a unilateralist? > Hacker: I somet…

> but in this case a UK-based alternative would be preferable

For you maybe, but not for me :) I just took advantage of the threat to ask a slightly unrelated question (although parent mentioned Ireland as well, so maybe slightly on topic at least)

Re: Why we’ve decided to decommission Gov.uk PaaS

#120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there any Europe-based PaaS currently operating, that are noteworthy? Most companies seems to be US-based.

"Europe based": yes, we are french. "Currently operating": yes, steadily, for seven years now. "Noteworthy": yes, I really hope we are, at least, we have been quite newsworthy recently "Most companies seems to be US-based": well, we have US employees and we are running on top of US based companies infrastructure, amongst others. o/ -- platform.sh

"If I sign up to your service and deploy stuff to one of your Europe-based data centers, will my data ever land on a US-based company's servers?" [______]

Edit: Apparently not! Didn't even have to sign up to the service (just loaded the landing page) and my data ended up on some US-based (Google) entity's servers (fonts.googleapis.com).

Looks like a nice platform, unfortunately doesn't seem too privacy-aware so gonna have to find something else.

Post reply on HN