Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: You are not alone this Christmas

news.ycombinator.com

111–120 of 326 posts

Re: Tell HN: You are not alone this Christmas

#112
post #20

Thank you for this gesture. I lost almost everything. Job, 7-year relationship, my mental health. Feeling that I'm not only alone but inadequate to have a life like anybody else. I'm still alive, so there's that.

Going by your username, are you German as well? I'm also going through a breakup right now, albeit from a shorter relationship. I was happy to spend Christmas with my sister to have some illusion of a functional family, it was nice. It feels unbearable at times but I try to find solace in the fact the world is so vast and full of opportunity and so much more than what you're (I am) able to see in the current moment.…

Not german, just love the Kraftwerk song.

Re: Tell HN: You are not alone this Christmas

#113

XMass is just an artificially distinctive day designed to sell more stuff to people. Why do guys even care about being or not being alone?

Christmas is ancient . As long as there has been winter, people have had a festival during its deepest depths, to remind them that the spring will come.

Much of the Christmas tradition is pagan/roman:

https://www.britannica.com/story/why-is-christmas-in-decembe...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturnalia

Re: Tell HN: You are not alone this Christmas

#114
This Christmas is significantly different for me. Normally it would be filled with friends and family, but not this year.

I succeeded in hiking >10 miles yesterday and today, legs willing, I'll be at least spending part of the day in the PacNW forests to keep the depression at bay.

JWST was my Christmas present. I'm happy to see we've got final separation and the last view of the telescope. If anything, it's the best thing I could ask for today.

Re: Tell HN: You are not alone this Christmas

#115

Thanks. You too. I lost my partner of 3.5 years recently and this will be my first Christmas since it happened. I'm with family but it doesn't come anywhere close to filling the hole they left. Merry christmas.

Each Christmas Eve, I watch The Muppet Christmas Carol as a personal tradition. This year, this exchange with the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come stood out to me:

>Scrooge: Oh, Spirit. Must there be a Christmas that brings this awful scene? How can they endure it?

>Bob Crachit: It's all right, children. Life is made up of meetings and partings. That is the way of it. I am sure we shall never forget Tiny Tim or this first parting that there was among us.

I don't know how you can endure it, and I don't know how you can fill that hole. I'm sorry you have to go through this.

Re: Tell HN: You are not alone this Christmas

#117
Yes I am. I am alone.

I am disabled, and homeless living in my van. I have a family history of mental illness and even they abandoned me. My friends, I get it, they just did not understand what happened to me. I make $1600 on disability but I still cannot find housing. Even when people

I love your sentiment but virtual hugs do not do it for me, nor for most people in my position.

What do we need? An understanding of Mental Illness stigma, housing for the 60% of us homeless who have a serious mood disorder, lower cost housing for the disabled. All of these would give me stability and a community again where I can feel like I am part of something instead of being an outsider.

There have been great people that helped me, and I hold no regrets because it reduces the stress and that helps me deal with my mental illness, but all the suffering comes right back, because here I am, alone again, in my van, in a vacant public park, on Christmas morning.

You want to really hug me? Start a revolution.

Re: Tell HN: You are not alone this Christmas

#118

This Christmas is significantly different for me. Normally it would be filled with friends and family, but not this year. I succeeded in hiking >10 miles yesterday and today, legs willing, I'll be at least spending part of the day in the PacNW forests to keep the depression at bay. JWST was my Christmas present. I'm happy to see we've got final separation and the last view of the telescope. If anything, it's the best…

aren't there snow storms out here in PacNW? do you have a blog where you document your journey through the forests?

Re: Tell HN: You are not alone this Christmas

#119

I think this whole christmas thing makes a lot of people feel alone and depressed. I hate that. Posts like these make me think this even more. I am alone, and I like it. I can play Warzone and code some stuff I wanted to finish. I can do things I like. I know this may sound stupid, but if you feel alone, don't. There is no reason to. It's just a day like many others. There is really nothing to it. And we don't need "…

It's a weird feeling. I like to be alone but I don't know, this Christmas I have the weird feeling of mix of sadness and loneliness. Usually I don't care, but somehow this stuff comes to me. Even that those are not my first, second or even third Christmas alone, I don't celebrate them, and I'm atheist.

I have the weird feeling of mix of sadness and loneliness

I think everyone has that to a different extent during the holidays.

I am very much not alone but for many of us this time of year made quite a positive impression on us when we were a kid. It’s hard not to yearn for those days especially if we’ve lost a parent or other family member in the interim.

Re: Tell HN: You are not alone this Christmas

#120
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're reading this don't take this advice, its really bad. Unless you don't believe in anything, you have to believe in something. If you can't believe in yourself, mythical beings isn't a terrible place to start.

Yikes

Yeah, telling someone to believe in themselves instead of higher dimensional beings is such a terrible thing.
Post reply on HN