Live data from Hacker News

The History of Karate

smithsonianmag.com

111–112 of 112 posts

Re: The History of Karate

#111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exactly. It is unclear to me however if anything I wrote contradict it or if you just wanted to stress it.

Just wanted to stress it because that quote contained the essence of what I was always taught in Karate.

Thanks!

Re: The History of Karate

#112

A general observation that explains a lot about most martial arts is that over time they all become "watered down" to mere exercise or a strange stylised dancing. That's because you can't have people permanently maiming each other during "friendly practice". If the village parents send their kids to the local monastery (or school, or wherever) for "training" and they come back with broken bones or just one of two eye…

Indeed. One theory of Taichi is that Taichi was invented as a military martial arts back in the early Ming dynasty. Eventually it degenerated to a physical exercise.
Post reply on HN