Live data from Hacker News

A modular, extensible DIY NAS

blog.georgovassilis.com

111–113 of 113 posts

Re: A modular, extensible DIY NAS

#111
post #16

I’d urge anyone planning on building or buying a home server to try out Unraid. It’s not free or open source, but it’s only $130 iirc for the unlimited lifetime license and it Just Works^tm. You install it on a USB stick, and the web interface has you up and running within like 2 minutes. The only hard rule is that your parity drives must be as large as or the same size as your data drives, but other than that you’re…

Unraid is getting popular on some DIY space but I feel that it's hobby-ish product. I astonished that it won't set root password and able to login by default. Write performance is terrible (by design) and "SSD cache mechanism" is made by crappy shell script. I agree that it still worth for some use case.

Re: A modular, extensible DIY NAS

#112

What's the power use on this? I would have thought x86 is a terrible choice for a NAS, as it only does the one thing and you don't need much processing power to do it (and implicitly x86's advantage lays primarily in being 1: fast and 2: compatible with x86 binaries, not in being low-power).

Decent x86 desktop computer (or server that uses same platform like this Microserver) consumes around 10-20W at idle that isn't "terrible". It also provides great performance. Atom is better for power consumption. Arm isn't option now because there's no equivalent parts.
Post reply on HN