Live data from Hacker News

Open Letter from Gilead CEO: Remdesivir Pricing

stories.gilead.com

111–114 of 114 posts

Re: Open Letter from Gilead CEO: Remdesivir Pricing

#111
post #110
post #109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is private/semi-private in that phrase is the hospital room that the insurance covers, not the insurance itself.

Not just the room, also better treatment more expensive medication etc That is whats called private, if you never heard the phrase private krankenkasse...well everyone uses it, it's also the first (maybe second) question when you go into any hospital.

Not just the kind of hospital room, but I'd say it's the main difference (there are many different supplemental insurance products anyway). And I don't thing "semi-private insurance" is a thing anywhere else.

Even if you're right and the term is used more generally than I thought, my main point stands: it's quite different from what people in other countries call "private health insurance" so in the context of the discussion here the distinction is relevant.

Re: Open Letter from Gilead CEO: Remdesivir Pricing

#112
post #111
post #110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not just the room, also better treatment more expensive medication etc That is whats called private, if you never heard the phrase private krankenkasse...well everyone uses it, it's also the first (maybe second) question when you go into any hospital.

Not just the kind of hospital room, but I'd say it's the main difference (there are many different supplemental insurance products anyway). And I don't thing "semi-private insurance" is a thing anywhere else. Even if you're right and the term is used more generally than I thought, my main point stands: it's quite different from what people in other countries call "private health insurance" so in the context of the di…

>my main point stands: it's quite different from what people in other countries call

You never made that point...sorry

Re: Open Letter from Gilead CEO: Remdesivir Pricing

#113
post #112
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not just the kind of hospital room, but I'd say it's the main difference (there are many different supplemental insurance products anyway). And I don't thing "semi-private insurance" is a thing anywhere else. Even if you're right and the term is used more generally than I thought, my main point stands: it's quite different from what people in other countries call "private health insurance" so in the context of the di…

>my main point stands: it's quite different from what people in other countries call You never made that point...sorry

[deleted]

Re: Open Letter from Gilead CEO: Remdesivir Pricing

#114
post #112
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not just the kind of hospital room, but I'd say it's the main difference (there are many different supplemental insurance products anyway). And I don't thing "semi-private insurance" is a thing anywhere else. Even if you're right and the term is used more generally than I thought, my main point stands: it's quite different from what people in other countries call "private health insurance" so in the context of the di…

>my main point stands: it's quite different from what people in other countries call You never made that point...sorry

I got slightly side-tracked when you said "we mean" and I wanted to clarify if you meant "the people having this discussion in this thread".

But I actually made the point:

    Supplementary insurance is conceptually different, by definition, from comprehensive private health insurance which provides alternative coverage for what is already covered within the public healthcare system.
Maybe I could have added for more clarity:

  And that's what the person you replied to means with "very few people have private health care in Europe, at least in the UK".
Post reply on HN