Live data from Hacker News

Ha-ha wall

en.wikipedia.org

111–115 of 115 posts

Re: Ha-ha wall

#111
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a moat interrupts the view No, it doesn't: it's just a ditch. (But it's not very effective as a defensive element if not combined with a wall).

Skimming through the first hundred or so hits on “moat” on images.google.com shows that pretty much every single one does in fact interrupt the view. So at the very least, keeping a clean view isn’t a fundamental property of moats. But keeping a clean view is the raison d’etre for haha’s. In fact that’s how they get their name.

Moats do in fact provide a very clear view of whatever is on the other side (often a castle or a wall). But of course that's not why they are built, nobody disputes that.

Re: Ha-ha wall

#112
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Skimming through the first hundred or so hits on “moat” on images.google.com shows that pretty much every single one does in fact interrupt the view. So at the very least, keeping a clean view isn’t a fundamental property of moats. But keeping a clean view is the raison d’etre for haha’s. In fact that’s how they get their name.

Moats do in fact provide a very clear view of whatever is on the other side (often a castle or a wall). But of course that's not why they are built, nobody disputes that.

The key here is “uninterrupted” and “clean”. with a well done haha, you can’t tell that anything is there at all. With most moats, you can.

Re: Ha-ha wall

#113
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Moats do in fact provide a very clear view of whatever is on the other side (often a castle or a wall). But of course that's not why they are built, nobody disputes that.

The key here is “uninterrupted” and “clean”. with a well done haha, you can’t tell that anything is there at all. With most moats, you can.

[deleted]

Re: Ha-ha wall

#114
When I read "Ha ha Wall" and saw the picture, I instantly assumed that it meant the people on the "safe" side of the wall could tease/taunt the people on the "difficult" side of the wall - like Nelson in the Simpsons, "Ha ha!"

Guess I was wrong. Maybe less than 100% convinced I'm wrong, but I probably just fell in love with my own explanation & I'm unwilling to fully concede.

Re: Ha-ha wall

#115
post #4

And in Ankh Morpork, there's the hoho: A cunningly designed ditch like a Haha, only the Hoho is 50 feet deep. Has claimed three Palace gardeners. Also once trapped Dr. Cruces, then head of the Assassins' Guild.

Designed by, of course, Bergholt Stuttley "Bloody Stupid" Johnson!

Who is based on Lancelot "Capability" Brown who really brought the ha-ha to its fore in England.

God I miss Pratchett's satire.

Post reply on HN