Live data from Hacker News

AMA: Bill Gates

reddit.com

111–120 of 178 posts

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#111

I wonder, if Gates was still driving Windows development would Windows 10 still spy on users and restrict their ability to control updates like it does with Nadella at the helm?

Gates would be just as ruthless, if not more. Don't let his shift in focus to humanitarian issues fool you. Microsoft can't rely on its consumer brand prestige like Apple can (thus selling orders of magnitudes more devices), so it needs to extract as much revenue as it can from consumer machines.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#112
post #19
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I skimmed the AMA for a few minutes, and saw him say that: - He thought nuclear weapons, bioterrorism, and climate change were the biggest threats to humanity. - He thought paying $10B in capital gains taxes was not enough and he should have paid more. Maybe those are platitudes but it's real enough for me.

in other words, war is dangerous and he pays too little tax. i think too they are platitudes.

The idea that billionaires pay too little tax is considered a radical idea in mainstream media, so that doesn't seem like a platitude.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That seems like a straw man to me - they’re saying the tax should be higher for people in their class generally, not that they individually wish to pay more.

Then they should say what they mean instead of being, as I mentioned, all passive aggressive about it.

I don't think they are - I think it's just a misunderstanding of phrasing maybe?

I interpret "I should have paid more" as I should be compelled to pay more, not "I wish I could pay more". The distinction being they'd rather not pay additional tax, but they probably should have to. I think the language is just somewhat ambiguous (specifically the word 'should').

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#114
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And yet... how many other billionaires do you see going out and saying that the capital gains tax rate is too low and climate change is the biggest threat to humanity.

A lot? I know Warren Buffett has similar views, and I've seen other very wealthy liberals claim taxes and climate change were big concerns. When people get very wealthy, they seem to think less about their finances and more about their legacy and public perception, and honestly when you're that wealthy, you have so much that taxes don't really matter anymore. There are a lot of very wealthy philanthropists, and I thi…

I agree they probably stop caring about their tax bill because they are billionaires. I find it disingenuous however to then look down the income ladder to people earning more than $1 million and including them in your “we don’t pay enough taxes” bucket.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#115
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Automatic updates are a good thing, otherwise far too many machines would be lagging behind on security fixes.

Can we stop this tired rhetoric? Yes ideally everyone would keep their system up to date 100% of the time, however it is not a good thing that users have that control stripped away from them, especially when these updates can actually have _adverse_ effects on their systems cough randomly deleting files cough . I may disapprove of users not updating their systems, but I'll defend to the death their right to not do so…

No.

We cannot rely on people to keep their systems updated, and this behavior costs society billions of dollars annually. Because of this people need to either accept automated patching, or stay off of the public internet.

This is an entrenched aspect of our society: you're free to do what you want, until your behavior causes negative ramifications to the rest of us, at which point, we as a society reserve the right to regulate poor behavior.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#116
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Automatic updates are a good thing, otherwise far too many machines would be lagging behind on security fixes.

Can we stop this tired rhetoric? Yes ideally everyone would keep their system up to date 100% of the time, however it is not a good thing that users have that control stripped away from them, especially when these updates can actually have _adverse_ effects on their systems cough randomly deleting files cough . I may disapprove of users not updating their systems, but I'll defend to the death their right to not do so…

You can already do that. Buy the business edition. Or use Linux and run windows in a VM. Or block the windows update system in one of a million ways including firewalling it. If you are really such a power user, you can do what you want already.

For the millions of others people who don't know how to find facebook without putting it into google search... yeah the automatic updates are good for them, and I'm tired of power users thinking their opinions are the only ones that matter.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#117
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Automatic updates are a good thing, otherwise far too many machines would be lagging behind on security fixes.

Can we stop this tired rhetoric? Yes ideally everyone would keep their system up to date 100% of the time, however it is not a good thing that users have that control stripped away from them, especially when these updates can actually have _adverse_ effects on their systems cough randomly deleting files cough . I may disapprove of users not updating their systems, but I'll defend to the death their right to not do so…

Are you willing to accept responsibility for the breach then?

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Here is a link to a Google calendar created by the IAmA team. Not sure how often it's updated, I assume as they get arranged https://calendar.google.com/calendar/embed?src=amaverify@gma...

IAmA mod here - we have a bot that updates it every time a guest schedules a new AMA, so it should always be up to date. We also manually add events in as they come from other sources. Bill likes to do his AmA's as "surprises", though, so we don't usually schedule those!

thank you guys

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#119
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I skimmed the AMA for a few minutes, and saw him say that: - He thought nuclear weapons, bioterrorism, and climate change were the biggest threats to humanity. - He thought paying $10B in capital gains taxes was not enough and he should have paid more. Maybe those are platitudes but it's real enough for me.

He was asked how much he should pay though. He didn't give an actual answer and only said he didn't pay enough. Surely, he has an idea of an actual rate, but doesn't want to disclose it for whatever reason.

> A key element is making capital gains taxation more like ordinary income (some have suggested making them the same) and having an estate tax more like we had in the past (55% above $3.5M)

From the exact same answer.

Re: AMA: Bill Gates

#120

I wonder, if Gates was still driving Windows development would Windows 10 still spy on users and restrict their ability to control updates like it does with Nadella at the helm?

Automatic updates are a good thing, otherwise far too many machines would be lagging behind on security fixes.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN