Live data from Hacker News

Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

fi.google.com

111–120 of 221 posts

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#111
post #71

10$/GB is way too expensive Compare: - ATT unlocked pay as you go you get 8GB with ROLLOVER for 40$ a month (autopay) - TMobile for 40$ per month you get 10GB (not sure about rollover) This service seems very niche and only for international travellers.

You can currently get unlimited data for $40/month on T-Mobile if you can bring 4 lines.

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#112
post #42
post #16

Canada has the most expensive plans in the first world and we don't have access to Google Fi yet. It's ridiculous how expensive it can be to have data here.

Looks like it has international support for roaming at the same price though, I wonder if we (Canadians) could just use it anyways...

Look into getting an AT&T Prepaid plan: https://www.reddit.com/r/PersonalFinanceCanada/comments/98wa....

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#113

If the non-supported phones are stuck on T-Mobile's network and don't support the seamless WiFi/Cell switching, what advantage is there to picking Fi over regular T-Mobile service? Price-wise Fi only wins if you use very little data.

Fi also wins over T-Mobile for international data, where they give you 4G instead of 3G. (Unless things have changed—when I had T-Mobile, you had to pay extra for international 4G)

This is correct. Out of curiosity, have you required 4G while roaming?

For maps, music and Uber 3G worked just fine for me in the UK and India.

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#114

Is 10$/GB a reasonable price in the US? It seems completely out of whack to me. For comparison, I have 20GB + unlimited call/texts for 10e/month, with optional 2e/GB recharges, and that's not even the cheapest available offer

US has one of the worst mobile data in the world. I remember having to pay around $30 for ~3 - 5 GB of mobile data the last time I visited US. Worst of all the connection speed was pathetic. And it was not even 4G. When I visited Thailand recently I got unlimited 6 mbps 4G mobile data for a week for around 8 dollars. India on the other hand have carriers offering 4G data at around $0.08 per GB. US definitely have to…

You should be getting LTE and decent connection speeds in most metro areas of the US. What carrier were you using, and what part of the country were you in?

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#115

Is 10$/GB a reasonable price in the US? It seems completely out of whack to me. For comparison, I have 20GB + unlimited call/texts for 10e/month, with optional 2e/GB recharges, and that's not even the cheapest available offer

It's not normal, $10/GB for -overage- is normal.

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#116
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Man, that's amazing. Here in the US, I have 5 GB / "unlimited" low-speed data, for $70/month.

FWIW I have a T-Mobile prepaid plan, and it's 10GB for $50/month. (Obviously T-Mobile's coverage is not as good as, say, Verizon's.)

Verizon prepaid is also not a bad deal. 8GB for $50/month. You can get $5/mo off if you auto pay and $15 off for multi-line. It's going to be very hard for Fi to be anything other than a niche provider unless they improve their data pricing.

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#117

I want to jump to Fi but is just super expensive for families. I have 4 lines. With Mint I can get unlimited talk, text and 2GB/per line for $15. So a family of 4 = $60. With Fi it would be $145. The difference is more than double. ATT offers 4 lines for $120 with 3GB per line. I remember when it was launched the price advantage was big. But since then the carriers came down and Fi did not (barring that $15 vs $20 pe…

Hope they will offer a family plan in the future. The roaming is definitely tempting...

Actually, they have discounted rate for additional users:

Does Google Fi offer plans for groups or families?

Yes. If you’re new to Google Fi, you can set up a group plan during your checkout process. Just have the intended plan owner click “Join Fi” to get started.

Just like an individual plan, each month you’ll pay $20 for unlimited talk and text, then add $15 for each additional person. Data costs the same at $10 for each GB used.

If you’re already a part of Google Fi you can invite people to your plan here. You can have up to six people, including the group owner, in a group.

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#118

Is 10$/GB a reasonable price in the US? It seems completely out of whack to me. For comparison, I have 20GB + unlimited call/texts for 10e/month, with optional 2e/GB recharges, and that's not even the cheapest available offer

No, it's not reasonable. T Mobile is at $70 for 50gb, $1.4 per (at 50gb they change your priority; on the surface they claim unlimited data of course). To make proper comparisons on prices paid between countries, you need to consider income levels in the country in question, not just the price unto itself.

I think that calculation omits a critical number: how much data you actually use. If you pay for 50GB but only use 5GB, your price per GB is effectively 10x. With Fi you will never pay for more than 10 / GB used, but you will pay less if you exceed 6GB in a month.

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#119

HN screams bloody murder when Google grabs location data without being clear about it. But I see nothing critical iin this thread (yet) of the idea of Google providing this service? So confused.

It is an issue of active consent.

If Google grabs location data without clear warnings, explicit opt-ins, or an easily ability to opt-out that is immoral.

Contrast that with something like Fi where the fact it is a Google run cellphone network is front and center, so to sign up active consent is very much required.

People just want a choice. Nobody is forcing anyone to use Fi, but people feel like they cannot escape Google's privacy violations in other areas.

Re: Project Fi Is Now Google Fi

#120
post #71

10$/GB is way too expensive Compare: - ATT unlocked pay as you go you get 8GB with ROLLOVER for 40$ a month (autopay) - TMobile for 40$ per month you get 10GB (not sure about rollover) This service seems very niche and only for international travellers.

It is nice for international travelers though. For ATT pay as you go, you get free Mexico and Canada traveling but they don't offer any reasonable rates outside of those two countries (it's all pay-per-minute/text/MB at exorbitant prices). Their postpaid plans have some slightly better options outside of the country but wouldn't be called great by any stretch of the means, in almost all cases you're better off just getting a local prepaid SIM.
Post reply on HN