Live data from Hacker News

The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

bbc.com

111–120 of 138 posts

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For a while there was a solution involving “hoop” bins with clear plastic bags so you could see what was inside them. But recent terror attacks (which used knives and vehicles, not bins) prompted their removal again.

Wait, that doesn't make any sense. If the see-through bins solved a problem, why would they be removed when a different problem appears? They're independent problems, removing the bins when they're not involved in the new kind of attacks seems just random.

Yep, pretty much. I live not-in-London and during one of the heightened periods of security last year (armed police everywhere) all clear bag bins were removed from the metro and bus stations. This of course led to littering. It didn't make any sense.

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#112
post #2

Singapore is an interesting case study how a well-run government that restricts a lot of freedoms can work remarkably well. I wonder if this model is sustainable long term.

> Singapore is an interesting case study how a well-run government that restricts a lot of freedoms can work remarkably well. I wonder if this model is sustainable long term. To me it sounds like the worst kind of dystopia possible. The wrong mix of medieval and futuristic: you get flogged or killed for silly things, the economy is effectively feudal, and if you are ever somewhat happy about something (wow! no mosqui…

"Disneyland with the death penalty" is how William Burroughs phrased it

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#113

In London, the “war on litter bins” (removal of litter bins from train stations and central areas, supposedly to prevent them being misused by terrorists) has created a culture of simply leaving litter on the floor or in the street because there are no bins to put it in. Perhaps that’s ok in busy central locations where a street cleaner will be along shortly to pick it up, but the problem is that people are now accus…

The bin removal was actually prompted by a period when the IRA would put bombs into bins in train stations etc., see eg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warrington_bomb_attacks So not a completely idiotic policy.

I cant speak for London, but the bin clampdown was definitely post 11/7(there may have been a clamp down with the IRA that I'm too young to remember with a bin liberalisation in the 90s?). I also don't get the unattended luggage announcements. Because suicide bombers leave their bombs unattended? They should be searching everyone with bags /rant

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#114
I worked in Singapore in 2016 for a few weeks and loved the place. Being ‘cleaned’ was only part of it: people seemed happy there, I got the impression that people had jobs and were enjoying their lives.

After working there, I briefly tried to get a full time job there but ended up accepting a job in the US. Singapore rocks!

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#115
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had one metallic straw in a fancy cocktail bar. The rest were plastic. Not to say, that I get a plastic cup full of ice with a plastic straw when I order a green tea, which comes in a can and is already ice cold. For the litter I see the most: part of plastic bags and Dasani water bottles. I hope the change in trash management, recycling and maybe trash separation does not only start with the rich people here, but…

Metallic straw? Like, reusable? Fairly sure that wouldn't fly anywhere else, I mean, even plastic straws are individually packaged right now due to hygiene considerations. Disposable plastic > poorly cleaned reusables.

Metal straws are very popular in upscale bars in financial cities such as New York, London and Hong Kong. It’s usually a sign you’re paying way too much for your drink!

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#116
went to visit Singapore for a week. Some friends told me it was one of the best places to see in Asia.

Coming back from it, it looks to me as one of the most boring places on earth. Everything is indeed crazy clean and it reinforce to the fact that it looks as a place with no soul.

There is almost nothing to do beside working, going to the Casino or the mall. People like Singapore because it is clean and everyone speaks English

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#117
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But...but freedom. It's aggravating to see how many Americans think individual freedom should absolutely and automatically trump every other concern.

I lived in Singapore for six years and then San Francisco for almost six years now, but seriously, I don’t feel US is any more “free” in any tangible ways. Maybe there are more “freedom” defined by laws in US but certainly not something that normal people will miss in daily lives. Also over focusing on “individual” freedom apparently won’t always align with the interest of the entire society and could eventually brin…

I agree. It's usually conservatives who use freedom as an excuse to argue against universal health care or to keep their guns. Instead, you're free to be bankrupted by medical bills, which I don't think is a better state of things.

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But...but freedom. It's aggravating to see how many Americans think individual freedom should absolutely and automatically trump every other concern.

It's aggravating to see how many people regardless of nationality would willingly trade away their freedom for some temporary gain and encourage others to do likewise. The next government can lay off all the litter picker-uppers but you won't get your freedom back in return.

Temporary gain? You mean improved quality of life? Hmmm. Let's see where the US ranks on any relevant metric compared to Singapore.

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#119
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had one metallic straw in a fancy cocktail bar. The rest were plastic. Not to say, that I get a plastic cup full of ice with a plastic straw when I order a green tea, which comes in a can and is already ice cold. For the litter I see the most: part of plastic bags and Dasani water bottles. I hope the change in trash management, recycling and maybe trash separation does not only start with the rich people here, but…

Metallic straw? Like, reusable? Fairly sure that wouldn't fly anywhere else, I mean, even plastic straws are individually packaged right now due to hygiene considerations. Disposable plastic > poorly cleaned reusables.

I ate street food, while sitting on rickety plastic chairs on small metal tables, covered in noise and moped fumes in Penang, Bangkok and Ha Noi among other places.

I ate a lot of it and never, ever got sick.

Here's my golden rule from which I never deviate:

  Make sure that you see how they cook the food on premises 
  It needs to be well visited, preferably by locals
As I said I never got sick (or even felt slight discomfort) and I had a number of memorable meals under such conditions.

Would a western health inspector tolerate the setup? Hell; no!

But, so what?

Sure, you can stick to the hotel restaurant of The Intercontinental in Bangkok, but you'll be hardly any safer than eating on a wobbly table in some small soi in the area.

But man, will you be missing out...

Re: The cost of keeping Singapore squeaky clean

#120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Singapore is an interesting case study how a well-run government that restricts a lot of freedoms can work remarkably well. I wonder if this model is sustainable long term. To me it sounds like the worst kind of dystopia possible. The wrong mix of medieval and futuristic: you get flogged or killed for silly things, the economy is effectively feudal, and if you are ever somewhat happy about something (wow! no mosqui…

"Disneyland with the death penalty" is how William Burroughs phrased it

William Gibson, not Burroughs

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disneyland_with_the_Death_Pena...

Post reply on HN