Live data from Hacker News

People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

medium.com

111–120 of 122 posts

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#111
post #70

Clicks are a bit of a weird metric in my opinion. It encourages optimisation for single instances of ad views, whereas what makes ads effective is the cumulative effect of multiple viewings. This may not even lead to a click, but to someone feeling more inclined to go a certain way when making decisions.

That is called awareness, the 1st step in the marketing (purchase) funnel.

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#112
post #27

Also interesting is the skew in visiting Facebook via desktop computers vs. mobile in tech-centric areas vs. non-tech-centric areas. In addition, it was interesting the see the difference in usage patterns between Denver and Boulder, given that they are so close geographically.

Boulder is comparable to SV, hippy start-up whatnot. Denver, not so much.

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#113
Does Ads need to be clicked for it to become good ads? What has happen to display ads? I personally think some ads are like reminder, remind be of a brand, remind me of something i know, reiterate, stating the obvious, all these are marketing, and what ads should be.

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#114
post #24

Ad clicks are studied pretty extensively. A good search term is "compulsive clickers." The cariacature-with-a-bit-of-truth version is less-educated older white woman in Iowa. The heavy clicking user population, roughly 4% of users, is generally believed to contribute more than a majority of total clicks. This is as well-studied as you'd expect of clearly quantifiable data worth billions of dollars, and remains social…

Not forgetting massive variations across nations. A company I used to work with did some FB advertising, targeting nations they did good business with via Adwords.

UK and USA were the worst for clicks, the rest of Europe a little higher, and apparently in the Far East everyone clicks everything multiple times. Click through rates were ridiculous.

Also interesting to note that despite being online and profitable for yearss they never did find a way of making Facebook pay, in any nation.

We never did make sense of it!

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#115
post #24

Ad clicks are studied pretty extensively. A good search term is "compulsive clickers." The cariacature-with-a-bit-of-truth version is less-educated older white woman in Iowa. The heavy clicking user population, roughly 4% of users, is generally believed to contribute more than a majority of total clicks. This is as well-studied as you'd expect of clearly quantifiable data worth billions of dollars, and remains social…

Not forgetting massive variations across nations. A company I used to work with did some FB advertising, targeting nations they did good business with via Adwords. UK and USA were the worst for clicks, the rest of Europe a little higher, and apparently in the Far East everyone clicks everything multiple times. Click through rates were ridiculous. Also interesting to note that despite being online and profitable for y…

Perhaps they were automated click-throughs? Asian browsers are different technology (every page needs automatic translation) - perhaps that tech was doing the clicking?

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#116
post #24

Ad clicks are studied pretty extensively. A good search term is "compulsive clickers." The cariacature-with-a-bit-of-truth version is less-educated older white woman in Iowa. The heavy clicking user population, roughly 4% of users, is generally believed to contribute more than a majority of total clicks. This is as well-studied as you'd expect of clearly quantifiable data worth billions of dollars, and remains social…

Hey! I've got three Aunts in that category!

But, to be honest, they're always Likeing some junk they found in an ad or a survey or "10 ways to do something" junk article. So, fair enough.

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#117

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not forgetting massive variations across nations. A company I used to work with did some FB advertising, targeting nations they did good business with via Adwords. UK and USA were the worst for clicks, the rest of Europe a little higher, and apparently in the Far East everyone clicks everything multiple times. Click through rates were ridiculous. Also interesting to note that despite being online and profitable for y…

Perhaps they were automated click-throughs? Asian browsers are different technology (every page needs automatic translation) - perhaps that tech was doing the clicking?

That's possible I guess. They were gaining page likes and post likes pretty well off the back of it, it just in no way compared with Adwords click through rates.

It was killed off fairly quickly outside US and Europe as it was just burning money.

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#118
post #105
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, people click on ads. I click, on average, when not using an ad blocker, accidentally around 200 ads a day on mobile. I've now made it a sport to click, after I accidentally clicked, another few dozen times. Kinda like Cookie Clicker. Most clicks are accidental, or people doing fraud (for business or fun reasons)

Just so you know, Google very easily identifies your clicks as fake or accidental so they are just thrown in the trash, nobody pays for them.

Well, it’s not about money.

More: I accidentally click an ad, get angry, click it another 100 times, and end up laughing about it.

Next week, when I have time, I’ll just root my device again and install AdAway and XPosed with YouTube-AdBlock and YouTube-Background-Playback, and the issue is resolved.

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#119
post #21

I really wish there was a service which would let me gripe about my problems and it would email me 10 Ads a month of products trying to solve those problems.

You mean like some sort of text box, where you type in your problem, and get results, perhaps augmented with some paid advertising from folks that know their offering would solve your problem? :-)

Google works for more immediate problems, but not for longstanding ones.

Re: People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads

#120
post #83

I'm glad there is real data on this. I kept explaining to people that our email and social habits in SV are a complete outlier vs. the rest of the world.

So, before knowing there was reliable data, you constantly made unfounded claims? You made a good guess. Is that something to brag about? An opinion that you feel the need to "constantly explain to people" borders on ranting... (an embarassing past-time of my own)

Let's say it was strong empiric evidence (e.g. on event invites, I always saw this, SV event invitation emails had the lowest open/clicks vs. other parts of the country) Same email, different regions. Same result. I also get the regular 'I hate emails, I don't click or read them' from a lot of coworkers, despite being the main revenue channel. Yeah, it's fun to be right. I'm bragging about it.
Post reply on HN