Live data from Hacker News

Berlin public transport in real time

fahrinfo.vbb.de

111–120 of 143 posts

Re: Berlin public transport in real time

#112
post #109

Looks like they are just interpolating the location between two stations using the expected arrival times. If no expected arrival times are available, they simply simulate the location to match the planned arrival times. So this is not really "live". > VBB-Livekarte zeigt berechnete Positionen der Fahrzeuge zwischen zwei Stationen; falls kein Live-Fahrplan vorhanden, dann Position gemäß geplanten Fahrzeiten

That shouldn't be a problem if the trains are on time.

even if they're running late it should be fairly accurate; there are no express trains here in Berlin so it's never very long since a train has been in a station for a positional fix.

Re: Berlin public transport in real time

#113

Amtrak (USA) has a static visualization of its active trains. Unfortunately you can't click to it, so here's a screenshot: http://imgur.com/TJwTBAY To get to it, go to http://www.amtrak.com/find-train-bus-stations-train-routes then click on the "Check Train Status" image near the top right of the page. The difference in train presence between USA and elsewhere is staggering (and embarrassing).

To be fair, you're comparing the Berlin metro system with a national rail system. http://www.livetrain.nyc is an example of live tracking on the NYC subway (though not on all lines).

Re: Berlin public transport in real time

#114
post #112
post #109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That shouldn't be a problem if the trains are on time.

even if they're running late it should be fairly accurate; there are no express trains here in Berlin so it's never very long since a train has been in a station for a positional fix.

Thats funny because I feel like I waited less time for trains to arrive in Berlin than I do in NYC (including express trains...)

Re: Berlin public transport in real time

#115
post #109

Looks like they are just interpolating the location between two stations using the expected arrival times. If no expected arrival times are available, they simply simulate the location to match the planned arrival times. So this is not really "live". > VBB-Livekarte zeigt berechnete Positionen der Fahrzeuge zwischen zwei Stationen; falls kein Live-Fahrplan vorhanden, dann Position gemäß geplanten Fahrzeiten

That shouldn't be a problem if the trains are on time.

That was either the best joke ever, or you haven't used German S-Bahn yet. (The "S" is supposed to be short for the German word for "city" but we jokingly refer to them as "standing still-train" instead of "city-train")

Re: Berlin public transport in real time

#117

This appears to use the theoretical schedule, rather than real-time information. I live next to a busy tram line, and what I see through the window does not match what the site shows.

Totally, buses never seem to stop at traffic lights.

Public transport is often prioritized and they got green light using some kind of detectors or remote control.

Re: Berlin public transport in real time

#118
In Russia same thing works in real-time (interpolating anything based on schedule will not be the best idea for busses / trams I believe) Mobile app from Yandex (works in Moscow & Saint-Petersburg): https://itunes.apple.com/ru/app/andeks.transport/id826358136... Web version in Saint-Petersburg: http://transport.orgp.spb.ru/Portal/transport/main;jsessioni...

Re: Berlin public transport in real time

#119
post #115
post #109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That shouldn't be a problem if the trains are on time.

That was either the best joke ever, or you haven't used German S-Bahn yet. (The "S" is supposed to be short for the German word for "city" but we jokingly refer to them as "standing still-train" instead of "city-train")

At least when I was in Berlin this September the U-Bahn worked perfectly.

Re: Berlin public transport in real time

#120
post #114
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

even if they're running late it should be fairly accurate; there are no express trains here in Berlin so it's never very long since a train has been in a station for a positional fix.

Thats funny because I feel like I waited less time for trains to arrive in Berlin than I do in NYC (including express trains...)

Trains run every five minutes during normal business hours. It's great. Ten minutes at night, weekends, etc.
Post reply on HN