Live data from Hacker News

“This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

wired.com

111–120 of 241 posts

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#111
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quora requires registration to simply read it. That's at least going to lose them viewers who don't want to bother.

Pinterest is probably the worst offender for that. You get progressively blocked the more you try to read.

i stopped using them because of that, and i even have an account; i just can't be bothered logging in to it everywhere.

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#112
post #92

I have a silly question: If the conspiracy theorists are right, the whole ad-blocking on ios is a ploy to get the ad-starved publishers, and thus the masses, off the web-based internet and onto in-app content silos such as Apple News. If they're wildly successful, the only ones left on the traditional internet would be those not producing content for money. Does that mean I'll be able to experience the internet the w…

Conspiracy?

Apple and others are entitled to keep their strategies unsaid, unconfirmed. Which leaves only speculation, which turns into observation when we see Wired's lead website story is nothing but a signpost to Apple native land. A happy land with double rainbows, shooting stars and perfectly trimmed hedges.

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#113

This could backfire. Surely this should result in a Google penalty against Wired.com for publishing thin content? https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/2604719?hl=en If Wired wants the article to be exclusive on Apple News, fine, but in that case it should not be on the website. Keep it exclusively on Apple News. There is no content on this page beyond a headline.

While I agree that this is annoying, but how is this different from pay walls that vary from 1-2 sentences to blurred out sentences?

And what about sites that show content when the referrer is Google but show paywall otherwise?

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#114

Apple News isn't available in a lot of countries for whatever reason. So this not only means its inaccessible to non-iOS9 devices, but it's also inaccessible to, eg., all of New Zealand.

I'm in NZ, you can change your region to US to get the new Apple News

Worth trying only for short term curiosity. Beyond that it's a clumsy workaround with consequences for other apps and services that depend on the region being true.

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#115
post #46
post #16

I'm an Apple user, but I have no interest in Apple curated news via a dedicated app. I can't believe there's a significant market there.

But it's a default auto-installed app (on iOS9) and the headlines are on the search / Siri Suggestions screen. I'd be surprised if it doesn't already have a huge market...

It doesn't.

So very few of those auto-installed apps ever see any use. iTunes (or "Apple Music", or whatever it's called now) might be the only exception.

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#116
This is disappointing. It's a move against the open Internet than Wired helped to popularize (I previously worked at Wired). It also is a slap in the face to Android and other non-iOS users.

Disclaimer: My own startup released iOS and Android news apps this month that are in the same space as Apple News: https://recent.io/

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#117

Additional fun fact: Publishers can't opt out of having their RSS feeds included in Apple News without signing up for an Apple ID. I wonder if that means Apple News will ignore robots.txt.

Why would a publisher opt out of having their feeds visible to any particular platform? The whole point of making an RSS feed available is so that it's *available" to any client that can read it.

As much as I don't like what Wired and Apple are doing in terms of using the web to promote native exclusivity, RSS should be open to all by default.

As for robots.txt in web pages, I agree that Apple News should be respecting those.

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#118
post #56

Wired will be losing ad revenue due to Apple adding ad blocking abilities to mobile Safari. So, Wired moves content to Apple News which has ads that can't be blocked (and Apple conveniently takes a nice juicy cut of).

It's almost certain that Apple's long game is to make this the norm. If there's one surefire way to get people addicted to ad blockers, it's to make them available on mobile devices. Once enough content creators start moving content behind News-walls, then Apple can roll out desktop versions of News. And as people then start asking each other "how do I get ad blocking in my browser as well," Apple's well positioned t…

What makes you think Apple is interested to be the advertising platform?

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#119

This reminds me of the early days of CompuServe and Prodigy, which had exclusive content*. It worked for a while until the open web became the bigger audience that dwarfed all others. I think the big players now may be repeating patterns of the past. Open standards tend to trump closed platforms over time. If this is the case it presents an opportunity to create a new open version of what Apple is doing now. Web 4.0?…

>Open standards tend to trump closed platforms over time. The opposite is true, and what is happening to the Internet is another example. Telephone, Radio, and Film used to be open but they have since been cornered by cartels. Tim Wu explains this excellently in his book, "The Master Switch."

https://www.fourmilab.ch/documents/digital-imprimatur/

John Walker (founder of Autodesk) called it the Digital Imprimatur over a decade ago. The scenario he predicted was off a bit in a few areas, but the general problem he describes - of rent seekers trying to turn the internet back into something closer to cable TV - is frighteningly close to what has been happening in the tech industry.

Re: “This story is being previewed exclusively on Apple News until Tuesday”

#120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It should be fine if they add it to their robots.txt file. It could alongside the other interesting exclusions: http://www.wired.com/robots.txt

Some interesting disallows there such as Disallow: /topics/Brooklyn_Police_Department. Can anyone comment on why this is?

And /topics/Advil? Wha?
Post reply on HN