Live data from Hacker News

In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary cyberwarriors

navytimes.com

101–103 of 103 posts

Re: In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary cyberwarriors

#101
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes. http://www.military.com/join-armed-forces/air-force-bmt-boot... How much of that is really necessary to be in IT security though? I'm sure it makes you a better person, but when you have highly skilled individuals and show them that kind of requirement, the majority of them would rather stay in the private sector. The exception is if you have a specialized degree there is officers school for the branches, but ba…

Huh. I mean, I knew that pilots need to be fit, I just didn't think they'd be crawling through the mud and such.

My dad was a helicopter pilot for the marine corps for 20 years and flew in desert storm and Iraq in the early 2000s. Growing up he was always in insane physical shape and actively participated and taught in Crucible[0] trainings. Part of it was certainly the 'culture' that surrounds the squadrons, but one day I asked him why he stays in shape when in war he'd never had to stand up to do his job? He told me the only thing separating him from a 'grunt' (ground soldier) was his helicopter, which the enemy could take away in an instant. The moral was you always train for the worst possible situation (being grounded behind enemy lines) and hope for the best (never having to stand up).

[0] - http://www.team-crucible.com/

Re: In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary cyberwarriors

#102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>That does describe what is expected of military members in combat operations Isn't the tactical playbook set On High? Obviously you need to react to a changing situation in combat, but wouldn't the standard responses to various situations be planned/tested/approved and then turned into training material by some central authority? Or is that sort of thing more up to officers in the field?

No. There are tactical principles that are taught, and basic tactical approaches, but a "tactical playbook" would be completely unwieldy. The Soviet military used that system, including algorithms to determine which tactical approach to apply. Western military's have long focused on small unit initiative and rewarding novel tactics. A wartime military is the ultimate meritocracy. Even in WWI, which is often stereotyp…

Thank you, I honestly didn't know that. Interesting.

Re: In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary cyberwarriors

#103
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

After allowances, they are making about 52-70k depending on which rank they hold. That's not bad for what they do, but if they were actual doctors it would be terrible. Its also not a technical job in the traditional sense, 70Ds typically spend 8 years as a 70B (Even though a lot of them will be slotted as 70Ds much earlier than this) which is essentially a management position at a medical facility. From the descript…

if you're a military doctor not only do you save approximately $200k on the cost of your schooling you also far outearn civilian doctors over med school and residency. even top residency programs pay very little. until you make attending (or possibly fellow) you are probably making half of what your peers in the military are making. military doctors earn less for the last 4-6 years of their service but they more than…

Good point. I had forgotten about the massive amount of debt most doctors find themselves in.
Post reply on HN