Live data from Hacker News

My new medical research startup launches today: let me know what you think

metamed.com

101–103 of 103 posts

Re: My new medical research startup launches today: let me know what you think

#101
post #13

This is the sort of service that a general practitioner should be providing. The vast majority of patients have routine problems. Though these might be distressing to the individuals, the "standard of care" (assuming correct diagnosis) is established practice, and this service would not affect that. For the few with very rare conditions, or with useless primary care physicians, this service might be useful, however t…

There are many conditions which are extremely common, but for which more effective treatments don't propagate to patients. About 5% of the US population has clinical depression, for example, and writing gratitude letters has been shown in studies to be quite effective at treating depression (more so than drugs or therapy). Yet, most patients don't know about it.

The rate of propagation of new treatments is an issue, certainly. However, it is something that a good primary care physician is able to (or rather, should) look-up in an instant if the first line treatment isn't effective. There are no secret treatments being withheld from anyone. Any really cutting-edge research is also of uncertain benefit, simply because it hasn't been tested often enough.

Re: My new medical research startup launches today: let me know what you think

#102
post #33

Excellent idea, great concept!!! It's not everyday medicine where you work on simple problems following a statistical approach - an appendicitis is more likely than a Meckel diverticulum, and a simple overeating is even more likely than both. But there are complicated cases - not very often, but that's the one I like, and that most of the passionated doctors do too. Hell - I love such cases. A quick story - I once ha…

This just might be one of my favorite responses on HN. Thanks for your share. I agree, Vassar, Alyssa Vance, and the others at MetaMed truly want to make a difference in the current health system.

Re: My new medical research startup launches today: let me know what you think

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> writing gratitude letters has been shown in studies to be quite effective at treating depression (more so than drugs or therapy) I could not find a publication supporting that assertion after a brief pubmed search. Can you provide one?

A quick Google search turns this up: http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs10902-011-9257-7

I sincerely hope his scientific evidence of the efficacy of letters of gratitude does not come from this reference within the "Journal of Happiness Studies" with a whopping sample size of 219.
Post reply on HN