Live data from Hacker News

New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

dailydot.com

101–110 of 203 posts

Re: New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

#101
This strikes me as a scary first step. The whole "re-education" spin is extra-scary; if I had a kid who downloaded something and was exposed to this kind of treatment, I'd be pretty loudly wondering who Comcast thinks it is to be "educating" my child with its propaganda.

What can we as techies do to combat this? How can we add a layer of encryption and anonymity that's so dead easy that it becomes ubiquitous?

Re: New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

#102
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unacceptable. If my friends/family are watching some awesome show like say, LOST, I'm not waiting for TV companies/netflix/whoever to get their act together. The moment people around me want to discuss the show is the moment I want it and not a second later. I will pirate it if need be. I won't "wait a few months". I'm not here trying to justify piracy either; think whatever you want of me - I'm not waiting, that's a…

I've also had no problem talking to people about it when I've waited to watch it. Your attitude is over the top self-entitled.

  I'm over the top self-entitled? Because I don't think it's reasonable to discuss a TVshow with people who have probably forgotten the details months after they saw it?
  I don't think it's fair for you to reach that conclusion. What's okay for you isn't okay for everyone. I think you're the one who's failing to see things from other people's view.
  But again, I'm not here to debate. I'm just 1 tiny data-point. Provide me streamable/downloadable content the same time the CableTV gets it. That's what I need. That's all I came in this thread to say.

Re: New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

#103
post #73

This violates my perception of my ISP as a dumb pipe. I want to pay a fair price (whatever that may be) for an internet service provider that exists only to connect subscribers to the internet, at reasonable speeds near their advertised rates.

Try business class service.

...and at a reasonable price? Too much to ask?

Re: New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

#104
post #101

This strikes me as a scary first step. The whole "re-education" spin is extra-scary; if I had a kid who downloaded something and was exposed to this kind of treatment, I'd be pretty loudly wondering who Comcast thinks it is to be "educating" my child with its propaganda. What can we as techies do to combat this? How can we add a layer of encryption and anonymity that's so dead easy that it becomes ubiquitous?

VPN software, even setting up tunnelbrick on OSX is pretty easy for techies, but I imagine it can be pretty tough for newbs.

It'd be nice if there was a one-click type of process. Maybe where the credentials are transferred via web service using a login auth from the desktop client?

The technology for anonymity is there and adequate, just needs some proper UX design and user education.

Re: New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

#105
I have to say after using other ISPs, I'm quite happy with Cox Communications in the Midwest. It wasn't always great, but the reliability of service is much better than the others I've had the displeasure of using. It's a bit pricey, but they have a monopoly here so it could be worse. Other than frying my modem once (it was documented and others had the exact same problems on the same date), it's been good. With other ISPs I've had to lease their hardware that inevitability has fundamentally-broken Wifi functionality.

And, more relevantly, they've stood up for consumers in these cases and their name is notably absent from the list of participants.

Re: New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

#106

Well, here come the Dark Nets: "The RetroShare network allows people to create a private and encrypted file-sharing network. Users add friends by exchanging PGP certificates with people they trust. All the communication is encrypted using OpenSSL and files that are downloaded from strangers always go through a trusted friend. In other words, it’s a true Darknet and virtually impossible to monitor by outsiders. http:/…

How does this compare with Tor network?

Re: New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

#107
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Try business class service.

...and at a reasonable price? Too much to ask?

Business prices seem to vary a lot. I've heard $20/month more in some cases and 4x more in others.

Also, once consumer broadband becomes capped, business service will probably be cheaper than paying overages.

Re: New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

#109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

HBO knows it's 2013. It's built a Netflix competitor. They have the whole tech stack for subscription internet streaming running and proven. They're signing 10-year content deals with exclusivity agreements that simultaneously give them a future catalog to rival Netflix while locking Netflix out of acquiring the same top-quality content. HBO has all its ducks in a row, it's playing the long game. All they're waiting…

HBO knows it's 2013. It's built a Netflix competitor. They have the whole tech stack for subscription internet streaming running and proven. I guess (failed to find how I can check it so far) that this is again US only. Of course we're talking about a US anti 'piracy' law, so that kind of makes sense. But the GP still has a point: Making content available, in a reasonable way, would make people like me shell out a go…

Unblock-us and similar services are quite nice for watching all of Netflix.

Re: New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday

#110

This violates my perception of my ISP as a dumb pipe. I want to pay a fair price (whatever that may be) for an internet service provider that exists only to connect subscribers to the internet, at reasonable speeds near their advertised rates.

The entire telecoms industry is digging everything it can into absolutely not being that. It's entirely not a market they want to be any, as it's a commodity service and therefore yields poor profit.
Post reply on HN