Live data from Hacker News

I'd not buy a LG monitor

beko.famkos.net

101–110 of 112 posts

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#101
post #5

Whilst it's preaching to the choir, I would attribute 50% of the blame to Microsoft. Loading any old thing and running it is not very responsible.

Microsoft doesn't police IHVs -> Geeks: " MS is negligent! " Microsoft does police IHVs -> Geeks: " MS is an evil monopolist! "

Strawman

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#102
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's also the option of "MS asks you if you want to run stuff your monitor wants to run". It's not that hard. The fault here is definitely LG's, though.

[x] Yes [ ] Remind me later

You mean [Agree] ₘₒᵣₑ ₒₚₜᵢₒₙₛ

Where more options plus a couple more clicks eventually leads you to the remind me later equivalent.

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#103
post #9
post #5

Whilst it's preaching to the choir, I would attribute 50% of the blame to Microsoft. Loading any old thing and running it is not very responsible.

It’s as if nothing was learned from AutoRun CDs and the like.

On the contrary, they learned to make malware authors pay them first before getting access.

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#104
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, this is LG making a choice to abuse an OS feature in order to shove ads down people's throats and spy on them. What a dirty, scummy move. Never buying an LG product again. (Also a Linux user, so this doesn't affect me, but this is gross.) I have an LG TV that I've never allowed to connect to a network, and I'm definitely keeping it that way.

>I have an LG TV that I've never allowed to connect to a network, and I'm definitely keeping it that way. I'm starting to think that is what I need to do with my computers.

It's what you need to do to all devices whose software doesn't respect your freedoms. Whether or not your computer is part of those is a choice.

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#105
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I decided I would never buy an LG monitor after mine broke ... Sheesh it's bad luck. I've got an ultra-wide 38" LG monitor since 2017. Nearly 10 years and that thing is used daily and still running strong.

10 years is a long time to enshittify.

However an anecdote of one doesn't say much about the current quality either, even if the support experience after problems turned up was particularly shitty.

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#106
post #93

I never liked LG, but I had to buy from them. They're the only ones that make (made) monitors in this format. 2560x2880 (16:18) LG 28MQ780 https://image.coolblue.nl/624x351/content/8841411d2a3b31f142...

Huh, why not just rotate a normal 16:9 monitor? Not quite the same but do you really need exactly that aspect?

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#107

Is there any hdmi dongle that can be used to mitigate this?

There's this: https://goldilocklabs.com/products/silentglass And this: https://git.cuvoodoo.info/kingkevin/board/src/branch/hdmi_fi... But I'm not sure they would block it, and the latter is not plug-and-play. I expect it wouldn't be especially hard to make one though.

The issue here isn't unwanted communication between the monitor and PC but rather the PC doing unwanted things in response to a specific model/brand of monitor. To work around this you would have to change what model the PC thinks the monitor is.

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#108
post #24

Choosing wisely doesn't prevent any given manufacturer from adding crap like this in the future. They might not push out adware today, but nothing seems to stop them from doing so in the future. That's what makes the LG controversy uncomfortable to me: the McAfee ads were pushed out years after some owners purchased their monitors.

Which is something that should just be jail-time-for-decision-makers illegal. That tech companies think they retain some kind of ownership over things they have sold needs to end.

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#109
post #20

Why analog monitors is better. Harder to install spyware. So called by the industry "Smart devices" are dumb for privacy reasons.

Misplaced rant. The monitor isn't installing anything, the PC is based on the monitors EDID - and analogue ones also have an EDID.

Re: I'd not buy a LG monitor

#110

> In what timeline is this acceptable behaviour by a fucking monitor to tell it’s manufacturer what [naughty] video you’re currently watching? But LG already did that 10 years ago. If you didn't care then, why do you care now? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6778397

This is such a bad faith argument.
Post reply on HN