Live data from Hacker News

Quebec town recognizes trees as living beings with rights

cbc.ca

101–104 of 104 posts

Re: Quebec town recognizes trees as living beings with rights

#102
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I studied an ancient form of communing with trees, through treediets ( https://sacredtreekeepers.com ) where I had a ~10 day fast with tree bark tea. there's certainly sentience and life form in them, unlike ours and also able to be connected to, if we have the right modulation of our awareness and sensory experience. it doesn't just take a psychedelic experience to see this though. Just because you haven't experienc…

If you consumed treebark, then according to your own world view, you willingly tore off pieces of a living, sentient being just in order to see what it feels like. There is simply no way to live, as an animal at least, without doing harm to other living, possibly sentient, beings - and certainly not without killing such. Any moral position that holds that all living beings have an equal right to life is untenable.

Do you think that having an equal right to live as any other being must be true in all scenarios, in all cases, and all experiences? i.e. if a tree has that right to equal life, its true all the time through every possibility space of its existence? (same for humans)

Or can it be conditionally true in some cases, in some living experiences, and not others?

Re: Quebec town recognizes trees as living beings with rights

#103
post #5

Finally! Trees are fantastic creatures. (I'd happily go as far as calling them Beings, but I'm afraid it would sound like some kind of a new age esoteric bullshit, even so I'm borderline convinced they are sentient.) The important thing that fascinates me is how Tree actually work. They are generally perceived as growing from the soil to the atmosphere. However, the opposite is true. About 98% of the material of a tr…

I seem to remember kinda recently-ish reading about a discovery that trees also rely on an extensive sub-surface (underground) mycelium network for "communication" of a sort. Let's hope they never become actually sentient and decide humanity's a threat (like in a certain Stephen King movie I watched once). :grin:

Re: Quebec town recognizes trees as living beings with rights

#104
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Montreal is in Quebec. None of your random statements apply to the province or the city.

[flagged]

Stories and anecdotes are so hot right now! I'm an anglophone who is welcomed in Quebec. Update your opinion.

Doubt seeding like yours is certainly a barrier to our (North) American society.

Post reply on HN