Live data from Hacker News

The greatest Google Mail feature you may not be using

blog.jgc.org

101–110 of 179 posts

Re: The greatest Google Mail feature you may not be using

#101

In a related note, I hate how Google promotes top posting even when I select a specific quote.

Seriously... even if they feel they need to do top-posting by default to satisfy the drooling masses trained on outlook, maybe they could use this "selected text" feature as an indication the user is more careful about their reply quoting, and position the cursor below the quotation in that case...

Re: The greatest Google Mail feature you may not be using

#102

This is a horrible misfeature. Often, I select bits of an email, to copy and paste elsewhere to check things. Then I hit reply, and wonder why only the currently selected text is there. There should be a way to turn this "feature" off.

At the very least, when you select text it should allow you to "Reply to Selection" as an option in the reply button (perhaps as default). I leave it to the UI experts to determine what's default and wording/icon changes. This meta-mode shouldn't reuse the reply keybinding either, and use a new one.

This would be far more discoverable and only minor changes to documentation over the current approach.

Re: The greatest Google Mail feature you may not be using

#103
post #10
post #8

Most mail clients seem to do this (maybe not so many web-based ones). Gmail has the problem of creating Tofu: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top-posting#Top-posting

Does anyone care about top posting any more? I feel like I haven't heard the term since my newsgroup days.

The thing that's made it easiest for me to embrace the top-posting worldview is to remove all redundant fluff from e-mails, including the quote when not forwarding.

That said, it looks like the world is converging around the idea that down maps to past (inboxes, browser history, Twitter, Facebook timeline).

I wonder if anyone has made a top-posting-style shell? It'd be like using less as a shell...

Re: The greatest Google Mail feature you may not be using

#105
post #5

I do use this feature -- I often select random blocks of text while reading. This feature means I often (5-10% of the time) have to click discard and then reply again to get my desired behavior. In related news nytimes.com used to have a similar feature where the definition of words would pop up when you selected them. It basically caused me to stop reading their site.

Quora has a very similar annoying behavior. Every time you select some text, it asks if you want to "Embed Quote". I select text just to get some focus.

Re: The greatest Google Mail feature you may not be using

#106
post #45
post #5

I do use this feature -- I often select random blocks of text while reading. This feature means I often (5-10% of the time) have to click discard and then reply again to get my desired behavior. In related news nytimes.com used to have a similar feature where the definition of words would pop up when you selected them. It basically caused me to stop reading their site.

So happy to see that others have this habit of selecting and highlighting bits of text as they read. I've been ridiculed for it, but I'm not the only one!

I'm a clicky-reader too and I'm not ashamed to say it!

Re: The greatest Google Mail feature you may not be using

#107
That's all nice and dandy, but check this out. For a few months now I've been noticing that emails from my inbox were being moved after a few days into spam, without any kind of warning. This happens once every two weeks, more or less.

We're not talking about false positives, these are emails that stay in my inbox for days before being moved to the spam folder. Which basically means I need to check my spam folder every day. Trust forever lost.

Re: The greatest Google Mail feature you may not be using

#108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> habitual selectors Ah, my condition has a name. All it needs now is a support group. My case become terminal when I discovered three finger drag on OSX. HN is a particularly good site to do it on because of the little lines and gaps that appear between selected blocks of comments. You can get a very satisfying 'pop' of a multi-comment selection springing from a single one if you move your mouse just a bit while dra…

Curious... Why are you selecting? Is it to assist in reading, or some other reason?

I often select text so that I have an easy visual reference when I'm scrolling down. I don't want to scroll too far!

Re: The greatest Google Mail feature you may not be using

#110
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes he is.

Thanks! It's actually pretty amazing that in this day and age you interact quite closely to a lot of pretty influential people that some years ago, the equivalent would have been completely un-reachable.

Indeed. HN is surprisingly full of important hackers. The "Internet famous."
Post reply on HN