Live data from Hacker News

People Hate AI Art

mccue.dev

101–110 of 190 posts

Re: People Hate AI Art

#101

It's a fascinating article and trend to me. I've been rather obsessed with the amazing technology of text-to-image generation since 2017, when state of the art was an LSTM+GAN and resulted in a blurry image. Now that the technology basically works great, it's just upsetting to a lot of people. I kind of think of AI like making things out of plastic - works pretty well, but basically always resented. Notice that the a…

I mean isn't it like the uncanny valley? it's sort of like "the real thing" aka human created artworks that we traditionally love and connect with, but just far enough that it gives us even more disgust that something completely not human created(like an inanimate object) would.

Re: People Hate AI Art

#102
post #23

I don't always hate AI products, I do hate an economy with no work for creative people.

Why? Do you think that artists would mind if there are no programming jobs out there? I expect no because I know much artistic people that now just say 'Cool, AI can now program my website or some other stuff for me'.

people have needed art as long as there have been people. it's hard to argue that websites are equally important.

Re: People Hate AI Art

#103
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah so, tech people tend to be in a bubble with regards to AI perception. I implore you to just ask around outside of your immediate sphere. Bring it up, let them talk.

[dead]

I think I compelled a lot of emotions with a relatively short one here. (Not that I'm one to defend myself generally; this was just something I felt like I was taking crazy pills on because how can folks not see it?)

> But maybe I’m just one of those people with “minor cases of major brain damage”.

Hey, you said it not me

Re: People Hate AI Art

#105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

the post was not written by human :) “humans, on average…” lol (hallucinated) ai hard at work

Is that an AI tell? I'm only familiar with em dashes and "it's not X, it's Y." I promise I'm a human being.

Re: People Hate AI Art

#106
(Disclaimer: I'm working on AI related stuff, so I'm not exactly impartial.)

Not saying AI is blameless, but I'm seeing a trend where the problem is clearly more about social media and how it enables every one of us to live in our own algorithmically fed bubble. Like, look at this:

> If your initial reaction to reading that and seeing [an AI image] is some variation of "ughhh" or rolling your eyes or "fuck this guy" congrats. You are normal.

> If it wasn't I cannot stress to you enough that you are an outlier. Whenever you pick key art for a presentation or blog, your business, or whatever - if you use AI art you give a clear signal that you have low social literacy. You immediately associate yourself with a huge bundle of negative emotions because people, largely, hate this shit.

See how confident the author is that their own view is the normal, socially acceptable one, and they "cannot stress enough" that any other view is a social outlier. This has all the same "If you don't care about what's happening in Gaza you're not normal and nobody likes you" energy, except at least people are actually dying in Gaza.

And of course it should make perfect sense for the author because, unironically, everywhere they go online they will see people talking and thinking like that! Largely thanks to those profit-driven corporations and their massive data centers.

I don't know what's the solution but this can't go on forever ...

Re: People Hate AI Art

#107
post #17

I think the AI Dino is fine. Just don’t claim it as anything but AI.

Note that you don't think its awesome. The best case scenario for someone normal is for them to be totally neutral. To think "its fine." The worst case is they think less of you and anything associated.

That is not a worthwhile risk - and thats the thing I am super confused more people don't have an intuitive sense of.

Re: People Hate AI Art

#108
post #20

Let me propose another alternative. People generally hate low effort AI slop. Irrational people hate art made with AI as a tool. "By invading the territories of art, photography has become art's most mortal enemy." - Said someone who nobody knows because it's a long and dead opinion.

>Irrational people hate art made with AI as a tool. No, it's OK to care about the source/process. It is not irrational. You may disagree, but it is utterly human - as rational as things get.

And to emphasize: I am fully aware that there are people who don't care. Of course there are people who see no issue with it.

But there aren't people for whom it is a positive, just those for which it fails to be a negative. It creates a severe negative impression or a neutral one.

That is a terrible tradeoff!

Re: People Hate AI Art

#109
post #19

Most “AI art” is art like “clip art” is art. This is a phase that will pass. There will be (and already are) legitimate artists who leverage AI as a creative tool like any other medium/tool (Photoshop, cameras, paint brushes, etc). I respect them even if others immediately dismiss anything AI related.

Clip art is actual art, unlike AI “art”.

Re: People Hate AI Art

#110
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Demanding a rational explanation for why something is considered tacky is a tacky look

This community is mostly based around sharing ideas, not feelings.

The fact (not feeling) is that most people feel a certain way about AI slop.
Post reply on HN