Live data from Hacker News

Figma's woes compound with Claude Design

martinalderson.com

101–106 of 106 posts

Re: Figma's woes compound with Claude Design

#101
post #40

Not sure Claude Design really competes with Figma. While it has a strong potential to let people iterate on using a design without the nuts and bolts of going back and forth with a designer, CD operates at the "leaf-node" level, where the output is generated. However, a lot of design has a deeper life-cycle than that. There's the collaboration, pitching, review, iteration, asset management, etc. In fact, the first st…

> However, a lot of design has a deeper life-cycle than that. There's the collaboration, pitching, review, iteration, asset management, etc.

Sometimes people want some graphics without it being like they're planning a wedding

Re: Figma's woes compound with Claude Design

#103
post #40

Not sure Claude Design really competes with Figma. While it has a strong potential to let people iterate on using a design without the nuts and bolts of going back and forth with a designer, CD operates at the "leaf-node" level, where the output is generated. However, a lot of design has a deeper life-cycle than that. There's the collaboration, pitching, review, iteration, asset management, etc. In fact, the first st…

I agree (at least for now) that Claude Design doesn't directly compete with the core Figma tool. It does directly compete with Figma Make - which is also an LLM-powered tool that generates HTML/CSS/JS output (not a canvas of components, like Figma's core product).

I do think Figma will have a problem that people with think Claude Design competes with Figma directly.

I expect people in leadership positions aren't comparing "Claude Design vs. Figma", but area comparing "Me and my product manager using Claude Design vs. A designer using Figma."

Re: Figma's woes compound with Claude Design

#105
post #80
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It still produces subpar code, with horrendous data access patterns, endless duplication of fucntionality etc Not really. 2024 called.

Just because you don't look at the code, doesn't mean it doesn't produce subpar code constantly . Opus 4.7, high effort. Literally 30 minutes ago. There's a `const UNMATCHED_MARKER = " "` that we want to remove from a file. Behold (the first version was a full on AST walk for absolutely no reason whatsoever, by the way): function restoreUnmatchedSelectors(cssPath) { const cssContent = readFileSync(cssPath, "utf-8");…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN