Live data from Hacker News

1D Chess

rowan441.github.io

101–110 of 192 posts

Re: 1D Chess

#102
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wait, how is the "put off checkmate" objective scored? Turns before checkmate? Or what? Is it just a joke?

The sibling comment proposed a possible scoring mechanism which might result in enjoyable gameplay, but I think the bigger point (for me, at least) is the Mind Chess represents a reducto ad absurdum of the strategy game genre. It eschews as many rules as possible, leaving you only with the goal of knowing your opponent's mind. So Mind Chess is more of a thought exercise.

It's similar to the 2-minute version of Diplomacy - get everyone together and the second sneakiest bastard wins; because nobody will let the sneakiest bastard win.

Re: 1D Chess

#103
I tried and failed a couple times before looking at the hint. And then I had to ask ChatGPT to explain the hint because I didn't understand chess notation. But with all of that out of the way, I am now winning 100% of my matches and feel it's not an overstatement to call myself a 1D chess grandmaster.

Re: 1D Chess

#104

I tried and failed a couple times before looking at the hint. And then I had to ask ChatGPT to explain the hint because I didn't understand chess notation. But with all of that out of the way, I am now winning 100% of my matches and feel it's not an overstatement to call myself a 1D chess grandmaster.

How often are you playing as black?

Re: 1D Chess

#105
post #63

If you enjoyed this, you might like Mind Chess, which can be played without a board and pieces [1]: Consider Mind Chess. Two players face each other. One says "Check." The other says "Check." The first says "Check." This continues until one of them says, instead, "Checkmate." That player wins -- superficially. In fact, the challenge is to put off checkmate for as long as possible, while still winning. This may be bet…

Which reminds me that I just lost the game. I also lost the game not too long ago, but before that, I think I didn't actually lose it for a decade of more? And losing it wasn't even because it was mentioned anywhere, I genuinely just thought of it by myself, after forgetting about it for so long. So my sincerest apologies if my comment just made any readers lose their long streak in the game.

Nah, I won't be fooled again. I won a long time ago and never looked back.

https://xkcd.com/391

Re: 1D Chess

#106
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wait, how is the "put off checkmate" objective scored? Turns before checkmate? Or what? Is it just a joke?

I have never played it, but I could imagine a scoring mechanism that would make it interesting, and perhaps is implied by the rules: The score value starts at 1. Every additional "check" multiplies the score value by 2 (so 2, 4, 8, 16...). The first player to say "checkmate" receives the score. Track your summed score between games; the player with the highest overall score at any given time is "winning."

Isn't the optimal strategy just to say "checkmate" immediately? That dominates anything else.

Re: 1D Chess

#107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have never played it, but I could imagine a scoring mechanism that would make it interesting, and perhaps is implied by the rules: The score value starts at 1. Every additional "check" multiplies the score value by 2 (so 2, 4, 8, 16...). The first player to say "checkmate" receives the score. Track your summed score between games; the player with the highest overall score at any given time is "winning."

Isn't the optimal strategy just to say "checkmate" immediately? That dominates anything else.

That would be the equivalent of spawn camping.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camping_(video_games)

Re: 1D Chess

#108
post #104

I tried and failed a couple times before looking at the hint. And then I had to ask ChatGPT to explain the hint because I didn't understand chess notation. But with all of that out of the way, I am now winning 100% of my matches and feel it's not an overstatement to call myself a 1D chess grandmaster.

How often are you playing as black?

As often as the system decides that I should play as black.

Re: 1D Chess

#110

I thought for sure this article was going to be political commentary! (I would pay a lot for some fat 1500 page, leather-bound tome of wisdom and anecdotes about historical foot guns, by Carl von Clausewitz, titled "1D Chess". And it's inevitable multi-authored, Harvard-published much thicker contemporary-world sequel.)

[deleted]
Post reply on HN