Live data from Hacker News

12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit

github.com

101–110 of 167 posts

Re: 12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit

#101
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's kinda exciting. The social media status quo has its upsides but a lot of downsides. I'm hopeful that the change will be good. We'll have to figure out a way to authenticate the people we're talking to, which will encourage tighter-knit communities.

This will end with the only way to authenticate the people we're talking to is meeting them at the coffeeshop in the morning.

Until the humanoid robots gain the ability to process caffeine, then we’re all hosed.

Re: 12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit

#103
post #43
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ironically this post is doing wonders for its page rank, as people are linking to it in the comments

Now that we have better ML, maybe we could take "link sentiment" into account too.

I don't know how good it was, but sentiment analysis was definitely a thing pre-ChatGPT.

Re: 12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit

#104
post #6

I've seen this blog slop on Google for the last month or so, no action taken whatsoever. it's mostly bullshit or regurgitated info from docs. like Google or their Search team really doesn't seem to care at all. all of a sudden a random blog website just happens to rank first page on every topic

Sounds like a good argument for using Kagi.

Re: 12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit

#105
Ironic, considering the README:

--- start quote ---

These blog posts are written by the OneUptime team and open source contributors. We write about our experiences, our learnings, and our thoughts on the world of software development, Kubernetes, Ceph, SRE, DevOps, Cloud and more. We hope you find our posts helpful and insightful.

--- end quote ---

Re: 12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit

#106

It's becoming much harder to determine on a daily basis what content is original, thought-out by a person, and trustworthy. Ironically, verifiably-old content is easier to trust now. Examples from recent personal experience: 1) Some time ago I was searching for growing information about a specific and uncommonly-grown plant, and was led to a top-ranked website with long pages containing everything about it, including…

Something I've recently started seeing, maybe even an emerging #4 is AI generated translations. You could have someone very intelligent, making well written subject matter expertise. Or just someone who has valid thoughts they wish to express to the world in a language more of a common tongue than their own.

Or on the other end you could have someone who wrote a sentance or two in their language and had some combination of AI generation and translation algorithm bloat it out.

In both cases you will get something that can look right and well thought out or explained, but probably will have at least some of the AI slop signs present. I don't know what the solution is for this type given claims Google Translate has started to do this kind of translation for people. An AI translation is probably just as prone to hallucinations as any other AI, but it probably will look more natural to readers than a direct translation.

Re: 12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit

#107
There doesn't seem to be a workable plan for how to cope with the onslaught of AI output, and it's going to get much worse.

The sentinel servers, meta/google/ms/etc. just seem to be largely ignoring it, or even supporting it.

It's already nauseatingly common on all major platforms.

Re: 12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit

#108
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Now that we have better ML, maybe we could take "link sentiment" into account too.

I don't know how good it was, but sentiment analysis was definitely a thing pre-ChatGPT.

It was pretty basic though, and even a frontier LLM might struggle to infer that OP is a negative-sentiment link, without sufficient context.

Re: 12k AI-generated blog posts added in a single commit

#109
post #61

Ironically due to slop I feel like we are regressing as a civilization 2020, want to know how to use Redix for Redis connections in Elixir? Google it and the results were most likely high quality, written by senior engineers who knew what they were doing Today google that, and it will be endless amounts of slop

> Redix for Redis connections in Elixir I googled this exact sentence, and the third result was a link to the blog this post is about. Grim.

I'm guessing there is a bit of a feedback loop now since people try this, search for the slopsite and click it, boosting it higher. For me it was top result (in incognito, not personalized).

Two things you can do:

- Navigate back and open another link. This signal is used to downrank for given query (google assumes the site did no provide satisfying answer)

- Explicitly provide result feedback. Unfortunately there isn't a category for "this is slop" but "inaccurate" works.

Post reply on HN