Live data from Hacker News

Why Doesn't Anybody Realize We're Going Back to the Moon?

theatlantic.com

101–110 of 162 posts

Re: Why Doesn't Anybody Realize We're Going Back to the Moon?

#101

Probably because the first time we did it we were an optimistic country with a good economy and a bright future in front of us?

Hardly. Remembering the end of 1968, when Apollo 8 made the first manned voyage out of earth's orbit, and orbited the moon:

Newsman Walter Cronkite remembers the year of Apollo 8: "The whole 1960s really culminating in 1968 were the most terrible decade, undoubtedly, of the twentieth century and very possibly our entire history, even including the decade of the Civil War. America was divided as it never had been since the Civil War and by the Vietnam War, by the civil rights fight.

"Everything seemed to come to a head in '68. There were the assassinations of two of the leaders of the more liberal causes. Bobby Kennedy, shortly after winning that election in California that probably would have put him over the top as the presidential candidate that year, and Martin Luther King, of course, in Memphis, was a terrible blow to the entire cause of civil rights. By the summer of '68 the Democratic convention turned out to be a terrible shambles of violence and counter-violence by the Chicago police... By December the country was pretty far down."

Re: Why Doesn't Anybody Realize We're Going Back to the Moon?

#103
Humanity did something better (humans on the moon) decades ago and now we are struggling to fly around the moon.

This is not exciting, it‘s embarassing.

Besides that it‘s a massive waste of money and brings no value to humanity, the USA or science. Why is this done again?

I feel like anyone excited about this is weird.

Re: Why Doesn't Anybody Realize We're Going Back to the Moon?

#104
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most people don’t care about Apollo 11 period. They know it happened but they have zero interest in it or the history. That’s why the average person doesn’t cares now. They never actually did.

Well the comparison is not what people think about Apollo 11 right now , but what they thought back then . Back then, it was a big event that made the news worldwide. Artemis II launched yesterday, and my non-engineer relatives and friends don't even know it happened (they don't even know it was planned).

[deleted]

Re: Why Doesn't Anybody Realize We're Going Back to the Moon?

#106
Used to love space stuff, although some of it was horrible (old enough to remember watching the challenger blow up on TV as a pre-teen). Don't really understand this moon effort. Space is uniquely hostile to humans, our tech just isn't ready IMO and probably won't be for 100 years. Our personas certainly aren't ready - I can tolerate far more isolation than most people, I often go 1-2 weeks without any real human contact at all, routinely go days without speaking to anyone. And yet the idea of living on a moon or mars colony gives me serious pause for the isolation it would involve. Space station has a different problem in that i'd be wanting to push people out of the airlock after a few weeks, or eject myself that way.

Anyway this moon trip seems totally pointless. I can get why other countries want to land there but for the US, moon expeditions have zero value, especially when we are burning so much money on stupid wars and and the same time cutting healthcare and food support for citizens.

Re: Why Doesn't Anybody Realize We're Going Back to the Moon?

#107
post #22

Because we are not going back to the moon. A flyby is going to the moon in the same way that driving by the Anaheim exit on I-5 is going to Disneyland.

Did Apollo 8 go to the moon?

Nope. Came close, though Apollo 10 came closer. But there's a reason that Apollo 11 is the one everyone remembers.

Re: Why Doesn't Anybody Realize We're Going Back to the Moon?

#108
post #11

I grew up admiring the Apollo mission and the likes. Nowadays, I recognise that it is heavy engineering, but I am not so impressed by the fact that we are throwing so much resources at something that we already know we can do. In fact, we have had humans surviving in space for decades now. It's costing a lot, it's not bringing much. But more than that: we have much more important problems to solve, starting with our…

I’m not sure I’m following. Do most people not care because of the environment? Because that’s certainly not the case. Most people don’t care about the environment either. Plus, do you not have any other interests besides the state of the world? No interest in entertainment or sports or tech news at all? I doubt that if you’re on HN. My bet is that you wouldn’t care even if the world was objectively better than ever.…

>Most people don’t care about the environment either.

They will start caring when it stops feeding them.

Re: Why Doesn't Anybody Realize We're Going Back to the Moon?

#110
post #87

So we're re-creating the Apollo 8 Mission 60 years later. 60 years after swinging around the moon, we are going to attempt the feat again. I'm having a hard time getting excited... Especially when some say it may not survive reentry because of politics ( https://idlewords.com/2026/03/artemis_ii_is_not_safe_to_fly.... )

> So we're re-creating the Apollo 8 Mission 60 years later. Not even: Apollo 8[0] went into orbit around the moon (orbited 10 times), then left lunar orbit to return to Earth. This required mission-critical rocket burns both to enter (LOI) and exit (TEI) lunar orbit. Artemis II[1] is merely doing a "fly-by"; it'll never enter lunar orbit, a much less challenging/risky mission. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo…

LOI - lunar orbit insertion

TEI - trans-earth injection

For ill-informed people like me.

Post reply on HN