Live data from Hacker News

Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

answer.ai

101–109 of 109 posts

Re: Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

#101
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

@dang Looks like astroturfing. There are several comments by users with very little history, all mentioning that they took the course before. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45456502 (0 karma) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45460800 (1 karma) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45456941 (4 karma) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45459683 (3 karma) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45460321 (1 karma…

OK thanks. We've moved those comments (and this one) to a hidden "stub" subthread. A reminder to everyone that the FAQ includes this: Can I ask people to comment on my submission? No, for the same reason. It's also not in your interest: HN readers are sensitive to this and will detect it, flag it, and use unkind words like 'spam'. == For all we know the Solveit guys didn't ask anyone to come and comment here, so we d…

Thanks for the assumption of good faith. We had no intent to astroturf. Some of the students from cohort one were discussing the negativity of the HN thread on the course discord server. It seems that several took it upon themselves to come share their experience. From the comments whose names I recognize, I can assure that these are all real people who have first-hand knowledge of what they're posting about.

Re: Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

#102
I participated in the first cohort in January 2025 and have been using SolveIt ever since. I would like to share some thoughts about my experience of the course, platform and the community of makers & users.

Explaining SolveIt is hard

How do you explain to someone who's never written a line of code what programming feels like? When I'd visit my father-in-law, he'd ask me at breakfast what I was going to do that day. Every time I would give him the same answer: I will stare at the same blue screen all day long like I have been doing on every average workday since I started programming ~15 years ago. It's become our little family joke, but it's also true - it's difficult to explain to someone who has never done it.

The question is what does that blue screen work actually involve? What does programming feel like? How do you live through it? What is your experience when you solve problems - is it painful or agreeable? Do you finish knowing more about the domain of a problem you tackled, or did you just get something working fast and hope it wouldn't collapse on you later?

The SolveIt experience is similarly hard to explain to someone who hasn't tried it. What's interesting is that using the SolveIt method has had positive effects on all these areas - how my work feels, how well I understand what I build, and the quality of what I produce.

For my first bigger, work related project in SolveIt I built an annotation interface for YouTube dialogue transcripts for documentary movie footage classification. I'd used Angular before but not FastHTML and HTMX. I had a working app in production within two weeks going from 0->users annotating, which might not sound very impressive in this new agentic era. But when using SolveIt right, the result isn't just working code, it's code that you know, and most importantly it's a much better understanding of your initial problem and the potential solutions/technologies to solve it.

Plus, the SolveIt approach made me examine each component individually - what it represents, what it means for my system, how it could integrate more broadly into our organization. That exploration led to something far more general than my initial annotation app: now we are using it for browsing/editing dataframes through a UI, where columns and cells can have different templates/layout, edit history and several other features I hadn't even thought of initially. The exploration phase took longer, but I gained a foundation I understand deeply and can build on. For core business problems, that knowledge living in your head matters a lot.

My only problem at the time was git integration - I wanted my work synced with my codebase and manual copy pasting was too much friction. This has been resolved since: I have my git repos accessible from SolveIt and AFAIK you can serve apps directly from the platform without needing to deploy it (though I haven't tested this functionality yet).

Cult disclaimer

I was surprised reading through this thread by comments about religious cults, paid marketing campaigns, and fake testimonials. It's true that I registered to Hacker News today just to share my experience with SolveIt. I am a real person though and have not received any money for writing this post.

Instead, for several years now I've been learning from Jeremy Howard and the answer.ai team through their free resources - the fast.ai courses, talks, podcasts, and open source projects. Hamel Husain's work on nbdev also had a huge impact on how I work. All of this is available for free to anyone interested in learning. I hope that many others will discover them and SolveIt. I believe many successful projects, businesses and open source solutions will grow on the SolveIt ground, the same way it happened with fast.ai courses.

On $$$ concerns: I paid $200 for the first prototype cohort. I thought it was worth much more than that - the course itself, plus unlimited 11+ month platform access (included Claude most recent model), plus the community discussions where I learned from other practitioners how they tackled specific problems from very diverse domains. When cohort 2 was announced, I knew I was gonna sign up even before I knew the price. The ideas you take and friends you make in these communities are priceless.

Re: Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

#103
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As the post mentions, a year ago we did a trial of it, and have been working with that group of 1000 users since then. The course is about a methodology, not a product. It's the ideas Eric Ries and I have been working on for decades. 5 weeks is a crash course that can only touch on the ideas. And it covers learning data structures and algorithms, foundations of web programming, system administration, startup creating…

You obviously see a ton of value here, but a bunch of industry professionals still aren’t getting it. This is a communication problem. Y’all probably should consider investing in a (different?) marketing or communications consultant.

+1

and a product manager

Re: Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

#104
Ok so after watching the latent space pod and going through their docs my understanding of what they are doing:

- solve it is mostly an approach less so an app they also build some Jp notebook style ide with branching and deep chat integration + a stateful vm which looks neat though

- my definition of the philosophical approach is: don’t let ai ever generate code you don’t understand be there every step of the way and build things “bottom up” in a very incremental way (basically exactly how Jp notebooks have always worked)

Now my view on the philosophy I actually don’t think I agree. With Claude code and codex I feel like my preferred development flow is “top down” to declare what you want on a high level and then let ai build some complete construct (making sure everything is type safe) and then dig in and understand this construct and iron out all of the details. I don’t think I need to understand fully each intermediate result.

I absolutely fundamentally agree that every line of the final output has to be fully understood and signed off by you.

Honestly, their videos and posts are very difficult to understand so if I misunderstood something I’m super happy to be corrected. I have high respect for the team and it’s nice to see theme excited.

Re: Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

#105

Speed reading, so I hope I have not missed existing answers to these questions: 1. Does the 400 cover access to the platform and if so, for what duration and what usage quotas, etc. 2. Can we purchase access to the platform without the course, e.g let us play with it for N months (course seems aimed at junior level devs)? 3. The tools and method, as described, don't mention any tools for minimizing divergence/conflat…

The 400 includes platform access from signup until a few weeks after course finishes. No quota - use whatever you need. You can't purchase access to the platform directly. It's not aimed at junior devs - e.g here's a post from a 25 year experience dev: https://christhomas.co.uk/blog/2025/09/24/the-human-is-the-a... . Alums from the preview course include professors, senior VPs, etc. Our approach to using AIs is very different to automated approaches like DSPy -- it is all about human-in-the-loop; the human is the agent. We do tackle head on the inherent limitations of LLMs, but not using anything like JEPA (LeCun's approach).

Re: Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

#106

Ok so after watching the latent space pod and going through their docs my understanding of what they are doing: - solve it is mostly an approach less so an app they also build some Jp notebook style ide with branching and deep chat integration + a stateful vm which looks neat though - my definition of the philosophical approach is: don’t let ai ever generate code you don’t understand be there every step of the way an…

Yes I think you've done a good job of capturing the key ideas. Thank you for taking the time to look into it!

I think you might be somewhat under-estimating the amount of novel ideas in, and the significance of, the solveit platform. But "chatgpt + vscode editor + jupyter + a persistent Linux server" is a reasonable starting point for thinking about what it consists of.

It's totally fine to disagree on the philosophy. I suspect it'll turn out that both the approach you describe and our very different approach can both work, and are probably suited for different kinds of people and tasks.

It's very early days and there's no established methodologies for AI-assisted software dev. I know our approach works and scales across a team of 10 and over a period of >1 year (and across multiple connected projects), since that's what we do in-house.

Re: Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

#107
post #3

Hey everyone, Eric Ries here. solveit is the AI environment I personally have been using every day for months, not just for code but for writing and research, too. it’s solved all the problems and frustrations I’ve had with both vibecoding and the limitations of the chatbot interface for doing deep work that requires concentration + the ability to understand the artifacts you are producing and, as a special bonus, pe…

Thanks Eric (and Jeremy and Johno). The course details are a bit sparse on the sign-up site. What's the expected time commitment for the course over the 5 weeks? And how useful would the course be if you missed a few of the courses and had to catch up later?

Everything is recorded so it doesn't matter at all if you catch up later. Some people in the preview course didn't start until we finished! Obviously you'll get better interaction with the community if you're following along at the same time, but that's the only real issue.

I'd say budget a minimum 4 hours homework + 3-4 hours lesson watching time.

Re: Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

#108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

do you have a video of someone using it?

And this prompted me to record a video showing some of my random non-work usage recently, to give a feeling for what the app looks like :) https://youtu.be/Y2B27hdKMMA

Cool tool. I think I'm seasick now from all the scrolling. But cool tool.

Re: Solveit – A course and platform for solving problems with code

#109
post #105

Speed reading, so I hope I have not missed existing answers to these questions: 1. Does the 400 cover access to the platform and if so, for what duration and what usage quotas, etc. 2. Can we purchase access to the platform without the course, e.g let us play with it for N months (course seems aimed at junior level devs)? 3. The tools and method, as described, don't mention any tools for minimizing divergence/conflat…

The 400 includes platform access from signup until a few weeks after course finishes. No quota - use whatever you need. You can't purchase access to the platform directly. It's not aimed at junior devs - e.g here's a post from a 25 year experience dev: https://christhomas.co.uk/blog/2025/09/24/the-human-is-the-a... . Alums from the preview course include professors, senior VPs, etc. Our approach to using AIs is very…

What's the subscription fee(s) like after the course's access ends?
Post reply on HN