Live data from Hacker News

Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

theguardian.com

101–110 of 192 posts

Re: Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

#101
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> outside of the West you probably mean outside of the USA, it's huge in Europe/UK (which doesn't contradict your main point)

I’m not sure that’s true. I’m fairly certain UK, France, AU, Canada WhatsApp is not vastly more popular than the blue bubble alternative. At least I believe this was the case a few years ago, based on data I’d seen.

I'm in the UK, I don't even know what 'the blue bubble alternative' is (Signal? Telegram?), everyone's on WhatsApp.

Re: Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

#102
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not sure this is correct - alaq said the messages are e2e, so not visible at all by anyone other that the participants of the conversation. The meta->data<- however IS visible by them and can and is likely to be used for advertising.

Of course the meta data is visible. Its probably more useful than the actual content of the conversation too. I mean from an ML perspective how would you even make features out of conversation that help with CTR ? That too without creeping the users out. I'd imagine its the same reason why meta doesnt (likely) listen in on mobile mics. Why go through the whole shebang of running always on transcription when simple fe…

I'm not making a stance on things, just clarifying the previous comment

Re: Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

#104
> Attaullah Baig, who served as head of security for WhatsApp from 2021 to 2025, claims that approximately 1,500 engineers had unrestricted access to user data without proper oversight, potentially violating a US government order that imposed a $5bn penalty on the company in 2020.

If it results in a new billion-dollar penalty, maybe it would've saved money to move him quietly to a cushy rest-and-vest advisory position, in which he's not allowed to see, do, or say anything.

> In his whistleblower complaint, Baig is requesting reinstatement, [...]

I don't understand the "reinstatement" part. Does he actually want to go back, and think that it wouldn't be a toxic dynamic?

(He already talked about retaliation. And then by going public the way he did, I'd think he burned that bridge, salted the earth for a mile around bridge, and then nuked the entire metro area from orbit.)

Or is "reinstatement" simply something the lawyers just have to ask for, to ostensibly make him whole, but they actually neither want nor expect that?

Re: Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

#105
post #75
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is huge in Latin America. USA is special because it is the (only?) country where iPhone has more users than Android.

Yeah, huge in Latin America in the sense that a lot (most?) business only have a number that they use with Whatsapp (you can't call or even text them). Is it the same in Europe? Since I am from Latin America I never know if people from other continents use Whatsapp as much as we do, and if when I ask them to use Whatsapp I am imposing a new app or it's what they regularly use.

No. Here in Germany WhatsApp is not even that widespread for businesses. But WA is very big here for personal communication, though Signal comes in second (at least amongst older people, and amongst my circle)

Re: Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

#106
post #101
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m not sure that’s true. I’m fairly certain UK, France, AU, Canada WhatsApp is not vastly more popular than the blue bubble alternative. At least I believe this was the case a few years ago, based on data I’d seen.

I'm in the UK, I don't even know what 'the blue bubble alternative' is (Signal? Telegram?), everyone's on WhatsApp.

I guess that it’s the iPhone’s messenger app? I heard that in that app, fellow iOS users have blue bubble messages and Android / other users have green bubble messages, and all the teens in the US /maybe Canada think it’s lame if you don’t have blue bubbles.

Re: Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

#107
post #23

What a trash company Meta has consistently been. From enabling genocide in Myanmar, to interfering with elections, to giving user data to third parties in violation of its own daya policies, to straight up weird stuff like pirating/torrening books to train their steaming pile of garbage called llama, to having sex chatbots be weird to children. And then there is the even weirder decisions of zuck, the biggest loser o…

>the metaverse is a giant smelly pile of poo and he sunk millions in it

He sunk tens of billions.

Estimates (because we don't have "Reality Labs" broken out before 2019) put Zuck's Metaverse Misadventure & Boondoggle about $75B in the hole ($10B revenue on $85B spend) with no signs of a turnaround in revenue.

There are plans to turn things around with AR spectacles but decent ones are years off and will require entirely new investment with little re-use of that $75B Metaverse nonsense (Oculus acquisition, 5 generations of Quest R&D, Horizon Worlds, partnered and sponsored games and content, etc.)

The only real ROI will be the experience and staff gained. The rest will almost certainly land in the dustbin.

Re: Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

#108

That's rather surprising about the accessing user data bit. When I was at Meta, the quickest way to get fired as an engineer was to access user data/accounts without permission or business reason. Everything was logged/audited down to the database level. Can't imagine that changing and the rules are taught very early on in the onboarding/bootcamp process.

Whatever Meta says publicly about this topic, and whatever its internal policies may be, directly contradicts its behavior. So any attempt to excuse this is nothing but virtue signalling and marketing.

The privacy violations and complete disregard for user data are too numerous to mention. There's a Wikipedia article that summarizes the ones we publicly know about.

Based on incentives alone, when the company's primary business model is exploiting user data, it's easy to see these events as simple side effects. When the CEO considers users of his products to be "dumb fucks", that culture can only permeate throughout the companies he runs.

Re: Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

#109
I never trusted fecebook which is why I never created an account or used any of its products (old Instagram placeholder only), except last year, I made a small startup and wanted to use Instagram to promote it. Despite using the other old account to avoid potential false flagging as spam, immediately after creating it I got banned and had to submit a personal picture holding a book or whatever to verify I am real. I did that although it's not a personal account. Regardless, a few seconds after submitting the picture and verifying my number it got permanently banned. So far this is understandable, maybe it's all an automated process which is expected. However, I wanted to get in touch with support, in any form or shape, only to find out that there's none, and apparently the only way to actually fix something within fecebook is knowing someone who knows someone who works there. LOL, really big LOL!! A company that size operating like an underground syndicate is a total joke and totally untrustworthy. Bottom line: Never trust anything from fecebook, no matter what they say, do not.

Re: Ex-WhatsApp cybersecurity head says Meta endangered billions of users

#110
post #4

So much for that e2e encryption that HN claimed was so good and that META couldn’t possibly use what’s app messages to do advertising from.

HN isn’t monolith, I personally never said WhatsApp is good, and I’m telling you from now avoid Signal too till they remove the phone number requirement AND you can deploy your own server.
Post reply on HN