Live data from Hacker News

Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

fly.io

101–110 of 283 posts

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#101

Phoenix creator here. I'm happy to answer any questions about this! Also worth noting that phoenix.new is a global Elixir cluster that spans the planet. If you sign up in Australia, you get an IDE and agent placed in Sydney.

Hi just to confirm as I cannot find anything related to security or your use of using submitted code for training purposes. Where is your security policies with regards to that.

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#102
post #81

I've wasted a lot of time and energy on stuff that doesn't matter, so I can hardly judge anyone else on what they focus on, but man does it feel bad to have community leaders actively focus on building out tooling that is anti-worker. I think the only way I'd feel more conflicted is if Fly.io started building weapons systems for the military. I guess that wouldn't be shocking considering some of their lead's beliefs.

It's safe to say that if either Chris or I believed this to be anti worker, we wouldn't be working on it. He's spent the last 10+ years working on Phoenix specifically to improve the lives of the people doing the work. My experience with software development is maybe different than yours. There's a massive amount of not-yet-built software that can improve peoples' lives, even in teeny tiny ways. Like 99.999% of what…

> There's a massive amount of not-yet-built software that can improve peoples' lives, even in teeny tiny ways. Like 99.999% of what should exist, doesn't.

We agree on this completely, however you and I know there are plenty of people without jobs in the world who could be employed to do this work. You are spending your finite amount of time on earth working with services that are trying to squeeze the job market (they've said this openly) rather than spending it increasing the welfare of workers by giving them work.

> Automation is disruptive to peoples' lives.

You know the difference between automation and the goals of these companies. You know that they don't want to make looms that increase the productivity of workers, they want to replace the worker so they never have to pay wages again.

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#103

I've wasted a lot of time and energy on stuff that doesn't matter, so I can hardly judge anyone else on what they focus on, but man does it feel bad to have community leaders actively focus on building out tooling that is anti-worker. I think the only way I'd feel more conflicted is if Fly.io started building weapons systems for the military. I guess that wouldn't be shocking considering some of their lead's beliefs.

The same logic that would lead one to believe that AI is anti-worker should also lead one to believe that software as a whole is anti-worker.

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#104
post #95

I've wasted a lot of time and energy on stuff that doesn't matter, so I can hardly judge anyone else on what they focus on, but man does it feel bad to have community leaders actively focus on building out tooling that is anti-worker. I think the only way I'd feel more conflicted is if Fly.io started building weapons systems for the military. I guess that wouldn't be shocking considering some of their lead's beliefs.

You can think of it as just automating the boring tedious stuff so us humans can focus on the harder problems like strategy, direction, design, GTM, etc. The days are numbered where humans are sitting typing out code themselves. It's akin to the numbered days of type writer secretaries of the 20th century.

I know what stories workers in the industry are using to cope with working with capitalists that have explicit goals of eliminating workers.

I'm sure your poor understanding of the history of improved tooling, like "type writer secretaries", will be a soft comfort in the future.

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#105

I've wasted a lot of time and energy on stuff that doesn't matter, so I can hardly judge anyone else on what they focus on, but man does it feel bad to have community leaders actively focus on building out tooling that is anti-worker. I think the only way I'd feel more conflicted is if Fly.io started building weapons systems for the military. I guess that wouldn't be shocking considering some of their lead's beliefs.

Do you believe making things easier and more accessible is bad for workers? I don't think it inherently is or isn't, it just depends on who benefits from the increased efficiency. I think that's more of a problem with your economic system, or wealth distribution. Overall I think we would all be happier if efficient machines take away the drudgery of our daily work and allow us to focus on things that really matter to…

> Do you believe making things easier and more accessible is bad for workers?

Nope, I've been doing it for 16 years.

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#106
post #103

I've wasted a lot of time and energy on stuff that doesn't matter, so I can hardly judge anyone else on what they focus on, but man does it feel bad to have community leaders actively focus on building out tooling that is anti-worker. I think the only way I'd feel more conflicted is if Fly.io started building weapons systems for the military. I guess that wouldn't be shocking considering some of their lead's beliefs.

The same logic that would lead one to believe that AI is anti-worker should also lead one to believe that software as a whole is anti-worker.

Sure, if you don't think about it at all.

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#107
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's safe to say that if either Chris or I believed this to be anti worker, we wouldn't be working on it. He's spent the last 10+ years working on Phoenix specifically to improve the lives of the people doing the work. My experience with software development is maybe different than yours. There's a massive amount of not-yet-built software that can improve peoples' lives, even in teeny tiny ways. Like 99.999% of what…

> There's a massive amount of not-yet-built software that can improve peoples' lives, even in teeny tiny ways. Like 99.999% of what should exist, doesn't. We agree on this completely, however you and I know there are plenty of people without jobs in the world who could be employed to do this work. You are spending your finite amount of time on earth working with services that are trying to squeeze the job market (the…

rather than spending it increasing the welfare of workers by giving them work.

Saying the quiet part loud here.

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#108
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have a package for calling LLM services we can use? This service is neat, but I don't need another LLM IDE built in Elixir but I COULD really use a way to call LLMs from Elixir.

Req.post to /chat/completions, streaming the tokens through a parser and doing regular elixir messages. It's really not more complicated than that :)

even less complicated, just set stream: false in your json :)

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#109

I've wasted a lot of time and energy on stuff that doesn't matter, so I can hardly judge anyone else on what they focus on, but man does it feel bad to have community leaders actively focus on building out tooling that is anti-worker. I think the only way I'd feel more conflicted is if Fly.io started building weapons systems for the military. I guess that wouldn't be shocking considering some of their lead's beliefs.

Most tech isn't "Anti worker". What determines pro/anti worker are laws and government policies that reciprocate with the cultural norms we adopt. At the moment, money in U.S. politics is the most anti-worker phenomena I can think of. The ultra wealthy have a monopoly on the incentives that create policy and how our lives are ordered. The only power working people seem to have is the ability to impose consequences via rogue guerilla acts of protest and violence (Luigi Mangion) . Hopefully, AI is a Frankenstein monster the public learns to wield to facilitate more of these "consequences" and upend the monopoly the super wealthy have on policy incentives and change the way politics is funded for good. It's a new world and a Hawaiian or New Zealand doomsday bunker isn't going make a difference.

Re: Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix

#110

Phoenix creator here. I'm happy to answer any questions about this! Also worth noting that phoenix.new is a global Elixir cluster that spans the planet. If you sign up in Australia, you get an IDE and agent placed in Sydney.

Hi just to confirm as I cannot find anything related to security or your use of using submitted code for training purposes. Where is your security policies with regards to that.

Ask some security questions, I'll get you security answers. We're not a model company; we don't "train" anything.
Post reply on HN