Live data from Hacker News

As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

voiceofsandiego.org

101–110 of 147 posts

Re: As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

#101
post #27
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If someone is able to first scam state and financial aid for a non existent student that seems more first issue to fix than at the point there's a bot/scammer in CC classes submitting AI homework.

You asked what the monetary scam was. I answered that. Don’t understand your response above.

I'm commenting on the gist of the article, not disagreeing with you.

Re: As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

#102
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How are they able to profit off that? Doesnt the school cost money which the aid would just reimburse?

The community college tuition is free but the state will give you some money to help cover living expenses while you study.

They should give you interest free loans with generous payment schedules starting one year after graduation.

Re: As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is your opinion and it is not a hypothetical scenario. Many people including myself received grant aid to attend classes both in person and virtual. If it wasn't for that flexibility I likely wouldn't have be able to go.

I’m glad it worked for you, however this is not an opinion, it’s a worldview, and it is unethical and unscrupulous to use government funding to pay people to remotely attend a community college course. This is several steps beyond the intent of a community college, which is simply to provide free education for working people in the community.

It is an opinion and one I disagree with.

Re: As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

#104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The second order effects of cheap education are immense, ranging from longer life span, better health, stronger economies, amongst just a few. The matter at hand, specifically, is one about how our ability to verify is overwhelmed by our ability to generate content. This is playing out with recruitment, bug reports, complaint forms - and going all the way up to sophisticated fraud.

The third order effect of handing out money for nothing, is the chicks coming home to roost as anti-education movements tear down the nation.

> The third order effect of handing out money for nothing, is the chicks coming home to roost as anti-education movements

Anti-education movements may be a third order effect for this, but it's a first order effect for other groups who are deliberately pushing anti-education efforts.

Re: As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

#105

Stop offering online classes and expect students to show up in person. Online education sucks, everyone knows this. Everyone knows that they are making some kind of compromise when teaching or taking an online course. And if people are too poor to drive themselves to college or have to work too much or whatever else, then the state should provide opportunities for them so that they can continue their education. Stop…

This kind of fraud existed even before online college became so popular.

Around 2014-2015 we had to start reporting the “last day of attendance” or participation for any student who failed a course. Kind of a pain when you prefer to treat your university students as adults and not take attendance.

Re: As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

#106
post #89
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Giving student aid beyond just free classes enables students who would otherwise need to spend time working to support themselves to instead attend school to get a better life. Generally that's considered a good thing, not worthy of the disdain you're displaying.

Not really. I worked various jobs in community college to support myself. Community college is designed around that fact with early morning and late night classes, but these are ONLINE classes. You can’t say that they have to work at that time because there is no time slot

"Online" doesn't mean "on-demand."

My wife got her Masters from Harvard recently through online classes, and every class had...I want to say about 4 hours a week of actual scheduled, synchronous class sessions over Zoom, in addition to the coursework required.

Re: As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

#107
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it is a solution. What points? You just insist that this is bad and that's the end of it.

hm. let’s start with how free isn’t free. you can then move on to incentives for fraud.

How about we start with knowing that it's not "free" as in "costs nothing to anybody", as UncleMeat has already acknowledged that it's being provided by the government through taxation, and actually address why you thin that it's bad, rather than just repeating "it's not free! it's not freeeeee!!!!" over and over again, as if we're idiots who don't understand how taxes and public funding work?

Re: As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

#109
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The community college tuition is free but the state will give you some money to help cover living expenses while you study.

So then anyone could do this even if they arent a bot?

Community college isn't free but it is much less than 4 year colleges. You can take out loans that will cover things like books and other expenses. I'm not in financial aid so I don't know exactly how it works. I assume they aren't really "bots" but are people in another country who have faked an identity. Anyone could do it but if they used their real name the government will find them eventually. As faculty I could look at the "student's" schedule and see they were taking multiple online classes from different campuses in our system. I called the number on their accounts and two of them were no answer and the third I called was someone else who didn't know that name.

I assume that one person is running accounts for multiple "students" and from the boiler plate that one person submitted I wouldn't be surprised if it was an organized business like many internet/phone scams.

Re: As 'Bot' Students Continue to Flood In, Community Colleges Struggle to Respond

#110
I wonder if there are perverse incentives preventing this from being fixed. The financial aid program looks like a success issuing more funds, the schools see increased enrollment, and the fraudsters go without saying. Seems like a win-win-win.
Post reply on HN