Live data from Hacker News

My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

old.reddit.com

101–103 of 103 posts

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#101
post #55

I'm surprised we haven't seen the "AI-powered" uBlock Origin of video yet. Not blocking by the web request but rather by analyzing the video signal itself. Or even a nice appliance-tier solution. I want to buy an HDMI splitter that when it sees an ad coming through Input 1, switches to Input 2. Switches back to Input 1 when its over. For folks still stuck with cable TV this is Nobel Prize territory.

I've looked multiple times for something like this that I could load onto my nvidia shield, but nothing seems to exist. There is a tool available for chromecast that works very well, but my ideal solution would be an app I can load onto the shield that auto-mutes during ads and un-mutes when the ads are finished. If I didn't already have my hands full with side projects, I'd dig into this on my own time.

Can you point me to that chromecast tool or tell how it worked?

I'm in the process of releasing a video player with adblocker for live IPTV on android that can definitely auto-mute the whole adbreak for you if you watch the stream in the player (see my previous comment for link).

But if you are suggesting a system-wide mute triggered by a dormant app as another live broadcast plays in some official app then that's easier in some respects and harder in others because people need to trust the data is accurate. Once we have enough users sharing accurate adbreak data (powered by accurate software with human corrections) we can offer a system-wide mute for ads in any other app playing those known broadcasts.

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not a libertarian by any means, nor do I think of tax as theft. But if someone can legitimately take away property because you don't pay them, I don't think it's yours.

Which is why that’s an extremely simplistic view. It’s literally the simplest possible idea of ownership.

Well, it's certainly less simplistic than "I claim I own it therefore I do"

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which is why that’s an extremely simplistic view. It’s literally the simplest possible idea of ownership.

Well, it's certainly less simplistic than "I claim I own it therefore I do"

And if that was an actual statement people made, then you'd be right to say that. However, I think we can dispense with the strawman. Ownership exists in the real world, which means it necessarily conforms to the laws of the society in which it resides. Your view is a child's perspective on ownership.
Post reply on HN