Live data from Hacker News

Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

apnews.com

101–110 of 163 posts

Re: Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

#101
post #48

This treatment does not in fact prevent HIV infection. It prevents infected cells from producing viable virus particles. Because of this, it seems very likely that if any patient being treated with this drug ever discontinued it, they could develop HIV quickly from cells that were already infected in their body that had been suppressed from producing virus particles but were no longer suppressed. I was not able to fi…

> This treatment does not in fact prevent HIV infection. It prevents infected cells from producing viable virus particles Lenacapavir interferes "with multiple essential steps of the viral lifecycle, including capsid-mediated nuclear uptake of HIV-1 proviral DNA (by blocking nuclear import proteins binding to capsid), virus assembly and release (by interfering with Gag/Gag-Pol functioning, reducing production of caps…

The references you provided are prescribing information and to other drugs which actually are anti-retroviral.

You did not provide any reference showing that cells that are actually infected but inhibited from producing virus through late stage assembly inhibitors are effectively eliminated by the immune system.

Re: Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

#102
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Do you have kids, if so how do you deal with frequent disruptions to the morning routine? Do you not have days where you just need to get up and go e.g. to catch a flight, get to a meeting, take a kid to school, or because you stayed up late and got drunk, etc... and taking vitamins took a back seat? This is crazy. You deal with the morning routine by taking your pills when the alarm goes off, because there's nothi…

> there's nothing the kids can be doing that won't wait for that There are plenty of things kids - especially young kids - will do that require you to push tasks back. Like a vomit, poo, or spillage situation needing immediate attention. Or throwing a tantrum if you try to bring them back upstairs where the pills are (thus waking everyone else up). Not to mention that it can be exhausting if they're not sleeping well…

As a diabetic that needs to take their insulin at the same time every day... set an alarm? It is inconvenient, sure? But if you value your health then it's worth it. And if you don't value your health, why do you care if the medicine is less effective?

Re: Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

#103

[flagged]

> no one promotes the simple tactic of not sleeping around Idiots constantly do. It's great at boosting the teen pregnancy rate [1]. [1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3194801/

I didn't say Abstinence-Only Education... I said not sleeping around is 100% effective.

And it is.

Re: Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

#104

This is incredibly exciting! The main method available for PrEP, in the United States, at least, is a daily pill. I think (I don't know) there is a monthly shot, too. Daily pills take a lot of time investment; monthly shots are better; but once every 6 months is awesome! Especially in circumstances where it might be difficult to guarantee a daily pill or even a monthly shot.

There is a generic daily pill (Truvada), a more expensive one (Descovy) and an every two months shot (Apretude.) Apretude has lower efficacy than Descovy or Truvada, but once you factor in human error in taking a daily pill regimen, it is more even. Human error is a significant factor since the current treatment protocols say if you’re not sure whether or not to take it, it is safer to skip than to accidentally doubl…

Seen these on commercial, I wish they stop with commercial for meds. Depressing asf, keep reminding me of my mortality while I’m trying to relax and enjoy a moment

Re: Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

#105

[flagged]

There are literally laws against prostitution and yet that doesn’t stop it or the STIs it can help transmit.

Who is talking about prostitution? All I'm saying is that not sleeping around is 100% effective at preventing STIs. And it is... There is no arguing that logic.

It's not my problem that our culture can't keep it in their pants.

Re: Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

#106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The problem is, as usual, payment. There have been many failed attempts at developing suppressive, curative and preventative medicine against HIV over the decades, and not all of that was funded by charities or government grants that don't expect repayment - especially not the later stage trials.

> problem is, as usual, payment If only we had an institution with the aim of pursuing the long-term interests of the collective.

We don’t, or at least not everyone agrees we do. Some of us think that we only have an institution that administers peace and order, and believe that pursuing the good is a private, voluntary concern.

Re: Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

#107
post #36
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know from experience that I'm not able to take a vitamin D pill every day in the winter months to combat winter depression. It's actually kinda difficult to build habits like that, and I'd have to remember to bring it with me wherever I may go and stay for a couple of days.

I think I got monthly vitamin D supplements a while ago. Since the body stores it it was feasible to just take one large dose once a month. (however overdosing is still a possibility ; definitely never take a monthly pill daily).

Thanks. I just realized I can just take small handfuls from time to time. I should have been taking it daily but, likely because I don't care for it, I only remember to do so about twice a month.

Re: Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

#108
post #101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> This treatment does not in fact prevent HIV infection. It prevents infected cells from producing viable virus particles Lenacapavir interferes "with multiple essential steps of the viral lifecycle, including capsid-mediated nuclear uptake of HIV-1 proviral DNA (by blocking nuclear import proteins binding to capsid), virus assembly and release (by interfering with Gag/Gag-Pol functioning, reducing production of caps…

The references you provided are prescribing information and to other drugs which actually are anti-retroviral. You did not provide any reference showing that cells that are actually infected but inhibited from producing virus through late stage assembly inhibitors are effectively eliminated by the immune system.

> references you provided are prescribing information and to other drugs which actually are anti-retroviral

The first reference is for literally this drug.

> did not provide any reference showing that cells that are actually infected but inhibited from producing virus through late stage assembly inhibitors are effectively eliminated by the immune system

I did not because this is the normal function of the immune system. The extraordinary claim, yours, is that these cells will somehow get missed by the immune system.

Re: Twice-Yearly HIV Shot Shows 100% Effectiveness in Women

#109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> no one promotes the simple tactic of not sleeping around Idiots constantly do. It's great at boosting the teen pregnancy rate [1]. [1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3194801/

I didn't say Abstinence-Only Education... I said not sleeping around is 100% effective. And it is.

> not sleeping around is 100% effective

Nope [1].

[1] https://clinicalinfo.hiv.gov/en/guidelines/perinatal/managem...

Post reply on HN