Live data from Hacker News

Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

cellio.dreamwidth.org

101–110 of 329 posts

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#101
post #3

Aren't Glassdoor's reviews pretty much a scam anyway? Last I heard companies can pay $$ to gain moderation control over their own profile to delete/downrank bad reviews.

All reviews are scammed. Phone a friend.

I have an idea. We could build a new, better review site. Sprinkle in some blockchain and AI...

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#102
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Remember when Yelp did that? And yet, somehow not dead.

Yelp has no real alternative for vetting unfamiliar restaurants, at least not one which doesn’t have similar conflicts.

I have found it preferable to visit the restaurant in question, look around, read the menu, and decide based on those cues around me whether it's worth risking a meal there.

Yelp has become useless, and TripAdvisor is as bad if not worse. The reviews on Google Maps are wholly unreliable as well.

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Many companies pay agencies to post fake positive reviews about them. This is especially common among companies who publish fake job vacancies.

Many companies just post fake positive reviews about themselves directly. Glassdoor reviews come from two places: aggrieved former employees and HR departments. The whole thing is garbage.

i wish everyone would adopt a mutation to the 5 star review, so that at a single glance a 3 star review would have coded with it whether it's a bathtub curve, or equal, distribution. like, if it's bathtub curve, change the middle star to a skull. but if it's even, leave it a star. how great would that be

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#104
post #10

If anybody doesn't think this is a problem, I overheard managers talking about a 3rd-party tool that finds "at risk employees" which they didn't define but said it included signals such as "they updated their linked in recently" as a signal that they may be on the job hunt. You better believe that data brokers are both interested in buying and selling any sort of information around your employment/job/interview behav…

I think this was done to me. I didn't even signin or anything, just looked around at what options are out there and started getting questions about my plans to leave.

What I've learned is if you plan to change jobs assume everyone at your current job will find out the minute you have an interview booked. Only applies to big companies that pay 3rd parties to monitor their employees like that though.

Sometimes I wish we had germany's privacy laws for employees in the US.

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#105

I think Glassdoor has the issue in that its not a growth business, but needs to be. You can't have a website like Glassdoor that is VC funded, owned by PE or publicly traded and not have it go to shit. The organic usage is people looking for new jobs, or posting about jobs they hate, or companies responding. A website that has <20 employees and is fine with being a $10M a year business living off of ad revenue could…

This is the essential problem with any platform whose value consists of user-generated content. For example, Reddit doesn't have to hold an IPO to continue being Reddit, they don't have to paywall their API, and they don't have to make their website a global dark pattern to force engagement; they chose to sell stakes and play the growth game. Medium is another example, as is Quora, LinkedIn, and a hundred other tech companies that are essentially specialized takes on PhpBB forums.

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#106

This is pretty shocking. I never use Glassdoor anyway, so deleted my account after reading. Worth noting that going to Settings only shows a button that says "Deactivate account", which seems misleading. Following this process does show a modal at the end that says "Account Deleted Confirmation. You have successfully deleted your account.", so seems like this is actually deletion vs. deactivation. (Your data stays in…

also worth noting that if you attempt to go in via the mobile page, specifically to delete an account that predates "fish bowl" and mandatory names, you'll be bombarded with cascading popups that require your compliance (no x to exit, just "next" and filling in the relevant forms).

Based on this story, I already knew to expect resistance, but jesus fuck that was far worse than I imagined.

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#107
post #10

If anybody doesn't think this is a problem, I overheard managers talking about a 3rd-party tool that finds "at risk employees" which they didn't define but said it included signals such as "they updated their linked in recently" as a signal that they may be on the job hunt. You better believe that data brokers are both interested in buying and selling any sort of information around your employment/job/interview behav…

Employers and recruiters are always bewildered when I say I don't have a LinkedIn account, or a public Github profile (I have a few tiny open source projects I maintain, but they are all pseudonymous) - and this is exactly why. I don't want people creeping any kind of "profile" of me. Ever.

I have such public accounts but they are specifically for said creeping.

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#108
post #58
post #10

If anybody doesn't think this is a problem, I overheard managers talking about a 3rd-party tool that finds "at risk employees" which they didn't define but said it included signals such as "they updated their linked in recently" as a signal that they may be on the job hunt. You better believe that data brokers are both interested in buying and selling any sort of information around your employment/job/interview behav…

We built this tool as part of HiringSolved. Other signals included time in current position relative to industry average and personal history.

[deleted]

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#109
post #11
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Remember when Yelp did that? And yet, somehow not dead.

Yelp isn't dead but no one I know uses it anymore, specifically due to all the issues with reviews.

Yelp rating, photos and reviews come before the street address when you click on a place in Apple Maps. I have to scroll down to get the street address, somebody decided that is less important.

Re: Glassdoor updated my profile to add my real name and location

#110

I keep thinking about this response from a glassdoor employee, and what it implies about their decision making processes: I stand behind the decision that your name has to be placed on your profile and it cannot be reverted or nullified/anonymized from the platform. I am sorry that we disagree on this issue. [...] This is my final determination. I, as well as multiple members of my team, have reviewed your request se…

this is why the GDPR right of erasure exists

fuck these companies

Post reply on HN